Film details

Rules Don't Apply  2016

Cast

Synopsis

1958, and Marla Mabley, a small town beauty queen and devout Baptist, arrives in Hollywood to be put under contract by RKO Studios, owned by the eccentric and reclusive billionaire Howard Hughes. Her assigned driver is the newly-appointed Frank Forbes, and they strike up a relationship through their shared Christianity, although Hughes has very strict rules about any of his staff having any sort of relationship with his stable of contracted actresses.

When Marla and Frank finally get to meet Hughes it is obvious he is mentally ill, and as their secret relationship continues Hughes' behaviour becomes more and more eccentric and unpredictable as his business empire starts to crumble, but he also announces plans to marry in order to avoid his enemies committing him to a mental institute.

Marla receives a call ordering to meet Hughes in the middle of the night in his palatial but empty mansion, and she is introduced to alcohol for the first time. After listening to her sing, Hughes gives her a diamond ring. Later taking advantage of her in her drunken state, he takes her to bed, not knowing that Marla was a virgin. Weeks later she discovers she is pregnant, having not told Frank of her liaison with Hughes, and when she tries to contact Hughes he refuses to take her calls or see her. She leaves Hollywood, leaving Frank behind, he being caught in the middle of Hughes' empire seemingly unravelling and his boss's increasingly bizarre behaviour as well as believing Marla has walked out on him.

1964. In Acapulco, Howard Hughes is about to make a very rare appearance to a group of journalists to refute claims made in a recently published unauthorised biography that he is completely insane, Marla arrives with her young son, planning to give Hughes evidence that will thoroughly discredit the biographer, but also to finally make a stand against the man who changed her life forever.

Production

Director
Warren Beatty
Producer
Warren Beatty, Steve Bing, Ron Burkle, Molly Conners, Frank Giustra, Sarah E. Johnson, William D. Johnson, Jonathan McCoy, Aaron Milchan, Steven Mnuchin, Sybil Robson Orr, James Packer, Brett Ratner, Terry Semel, Jeffrey Soros and Christopher Woodrow
Art Director
Jeanne Oppewall
Editor
Robin Goncalves, Leslie Jones, F. Brian Scofield and Billy Weber
Music
Andrew M. Chukerman and Heavy Young Heathens (uncredited - and Victoria De Mare)
Screenplay
Warren Beatty, based on a story by Bo Goldman and Warren Beatty
Director of Photography
Caleb Deschanel

Review

Warren Beatty's first film on either side of the lens since 2001's disastrous and now infamous Town & Country, Rules Don't Apply received some fascinatingly baffled reviews when it opened in the US, some critics being completely fascinated by this strange mixture of slightly queasy sex comedy, religious conjecture, fictionalised biography and a strange, uncomfortable love story, while others just saw it as a possibly vanity vehicle for Beatty, and a final chance to make a version of the Howard Hughes bio-pic he had reputedly been planning since the mid-1970s, only to see Martin Scorsese's The Aviator hit screens in 2004.

Beatty finally gets his wish, sort of, and plays Hughes on screen in a film in which, for at least the first half, he's a shadowy behind-the-scenes manipulator, but one has to also consider that in the period in which the film is set, the real Hughes was 53 years old. At time of filming in early 2014 Beatty was 77. Unfortunately this eccentric project, which also took an extraordinary sixteen producers, including veterans such as Aaron Milchan and Terry Semel, and money men such as Las Vegas casino magnate Steve Bing and Trump cabinet member Steven Mnuchin, as well as two co-producers to bring to the screen, flopped disastrously, making only $3.7m (£2.88m) during its US release in November '16, against a budget of $26.7m (£20.82m), and the equally embarrassing news that it isn't getting a theatrical release in a large number of territories, going straight to DVD and VoD, would seem to be another indicator of how misbegotten a project it is.

The project is certainly prestigious enough to attract a first rate supporting cast, including some fascinating names as both genuine and invented characters, such as Alec Baldwin (TV's 30 Rock) as Hughes' head of operations, ex-CIA man and private investigator Robert Maheu, and Martin Sheen (Apocalypse Now) as Noah Dietrich, the CEO of Hughes' business empire, with other roles taken by the likes of Matthew Broderick (The Producers), Ed Harris (Pollock), Candice Bergen (TV's Murphy Brown), Oliver Platt (Lake Placid) and Dabney Coleman (9 To 5), as well as an appearance by the missus, Annette Bening, as Lucy Mabrey, the female lead's mother. The actual leads in the form of Lily Collins (Love, Rosie) and Alden Ehrenreich (Han Solo in the Star Wars stand-alone spin-off) are suitably appealing, Collins taking the role originally to have been played by Felicity Jones (Rogue One), who was cast back in November 2011, but dropped out through the repeated delays in beginning production.

Behind it all, in so many ways, is Beatty as Hughes, and who seems to be a peripheral character very much becomes centre-stage as the film, halfway through, very much shifts to becomes a different sort of story, focusing on the unpredictable Hughes and his handling of his contract actresses, knowing the influence and power he wields over them, issuing diktats as to their behaviour, appearance and who they can and cannot see while completely avoiding the accusations of very serious sexual harassment repeatedly made against Hughes during this time, and also conveniently ignoring the fact that by 1958 Hughes had sold RKO three years earlier and had nothing more to do with the studios.

Reviews were a mixture of the baffled and those who hoped this wouldn't be Beatty's cinematic swansong, The AV Club outlining 'Warren Beatty, who hasn't directed a movie since Bulworth or acted in one in 15 years, returns to film with Rules Don't Apply, a 1950s-set sex comedy about hormones, premature ejaculation, religious belief, and the mythology of Howard Hughes that is as intriguing in its idiosyncrasy as it is flat-footed in execution. Its conceit is to turn the mentally ill billionaire Hughes (Beatty) into a stand-in for God, inspiring awe and guilt in a couple of church-going young people who work at his Hollywood film studio. ...Aside from Beatty's performance, the only consistent thing the movie has going for it is ineffable strangeness,' while conversely IndieWire found it to be 'A sweet, old-fashioned Hollywood romance that just so happens to involve Howard Hughes as a supporting character, Beatty's long-gestating project is a modestly enjoyable, well-acted nostalgia piece with just a touch of edge. As passion projects go, this one's disarmingly slight in its ambitions, the opposite of Hughes' legacy in every way.' Vulture opined 'The movie is so misbegotten that it's almost poignant. But I hope Beatty has a few more left in him.' Beatty seems to have finally made his Howard Hughes project, but in a version which nobody have foreseen.