Film details

Silence  2016

Silencio / Chinmoku

Cast

  • Andrew Garfield
  • Adam Driver
  • Ciarán Hinds
  • Tadanobu Asano
  • Shin'ya Tsukamoto
  • Nana Komatsu
  • Ryô Kase
  • Michié
  • Sabu (Hiroyuki Tanaka)
  • Issei Ogata

Synopsis

A personal project for Martin Scorsese, who first worked with writer Jay Cocks on a screenplay nearly thirty years ago, Silence, based on the novel by Japanese Catholic Shûsaku Endô, has already been filmed once before, in 1971 by Japanese director Masahiro Shinoda, and while Scorsese's film has been receiving some truly five-star reviews from US critics, emphasising the film's depth, power and striking visuals, shot by Rodrigo Prieto (Argo / Brokeback Mountain) with Huang Wen-Ying (Flowers Of Shanghai / The Assassin) as art director, but saying that the film's two hours and forty minutes, 32 minutes longer than the '71 version, are not for the easily distracted, containing some passages where the pace slows to almost glacial, but also warning that the filmmaker also doesn't flinch from the violence inflicted on the Christian believers by the Japanese authorities, including decapitations, burnings and a horrifying scene of a mass crucifixion in a river, the victims struggling as the waves wash over them. The depth of Scorsese's religious faith has been a recurrent theme, in films as diverse as Mean Streets ('73), The Last Temptation Of Christ ('88), Kundun ('97), Bringing Out The Dead ('99) and, most heavy-handedly, The Departed ('06), and Silence premiered in Vatican City before Pope Francis, as the ultimate seal of papal approval. Given the subject matter one shouldn't be surprised that, visuals aside, this is a stringently austere movie, unflinching in depicting suffering, and offering up some major theological questions, including the question of faith in the face of violence and oppression, God's silence in the face of huge amounts of pain and suffering, and the renouncement of faith when faced with martyrdom, which have been posed for centuries, and still haven't provided any answers, and as several critics noted, unlike Mel Gibson's The Passion Of The Christ, here the violence is presented as dreadful and tragic, and not revelled in and almost fetishised. Scorsese has also strongly cast his film, shot largely in Taiwan, with Japanese actors, including Yôsuke Kubozuka (Ichi / Tokyo Tribe) as the priests' Christian guide Kichijiro, and Yoshi Oida (The Pillow Book / Wasabi), as well as Tadanobu Asano (Thor / Ichi The Killer) as an interpreter and veteran Issei Ogata (Yi Yi / Tony Takatani) as the feared Inquisitor. And unexpectedly he also casts two fascinating director / actors in Shin'ya Tsukamoto (Tetsuo, The Iron Man / Tokyo Fist) and Hiroyuki Tanaka, better known under his nom-de-screen Sabu (Monday / Postman Blues). The main Western cast are an impressive line-up, in the form of Adam Driver (Star Wars: The Force Awakens / Paterson), Liam Neeson (the Taken series / A Monster Calls) and Ciarán Hinds (The Woman In Black / TV's Rome), although to some the only weak link was Andrew Garfield (The Amazing Spider-Man), believing him not entirely capable of portraying the internal struggles of such a conflicted character when presented with something which shakes his faith, essentially the essence of everything he believes in, to the core, and the fact that Garfield is always immaculately presented, even in the harshest of conditions, made some wonder if this congregation of persecuted Christians in hiding had a 24-hour hairdresser among their ranks. Silence is apparently at times gruelling viewing, and is bound to be in a slew of nominations for the major film awards, if not perhaps being one of the favourites to win, but in a cinemascape seemingly currently dominated by superhero and space opera pics of wildly variable quality, an intense and personal vision such as Scorsese's is to be cherished and encouraged.

Production

Director
Martin Scorsese
Producer
Randall Emmett
Art Director
Huang Wen-Ying (supervisor)
Editor
Thelma Schoonmaker
Music
Kathryn Kluge and Kim Allen Kluge
Screenplay
Jay Cocks and Martin Scorsese, based on the novel Chinmoku / Silence by Shûsaku Endô
Director of Photography
Rodrigo Prieto