Film details

Thoroughbreds  2017

Thoroughbred

Cast

  • Olivia Cooke
  • Anya Taylor-Joy
  • Paul Sparks
  • Francie Swift
  • Kaili Vernoff
  • Leah Procito
  • Svetlana Orlova
  • Thomas Dings
  • Lauren Laperriere
  • Chaunty Spillane
  • Stephanie Atkinson

Synopsis

Amanda and Lily, estranged childhood friends from Connecticut's social elite, are reunited when Amanda's mother, Mrs. Reynolds, hires Lily to become a tutor to Amanda, who is awaiting trial for a gruesome knife attack on her beloved horse, Honeymooner, which it did not survive, although her mother is really paying Lily to try to be a friend once more to Amanda, and bring her out of emotional loneliness.

Lily is surprised when Amanda tells her she can't seem to feel genuine emotions, no anger, sadness, joy, sympathy and certainly nothing like remorse over what happened to Honeymooner, causing Lily to remember why she eventually found their relationship so uncomfortable, and Amanda seems isolated and abandoned, but their friendship soon becomes warm again. Amanda finds that Lily is also withholding a secret, that she dropped out of college, and also that she seems very uncomfortable around her stepfather, the unpleasant and aggressive Mark. Amanda puts it to Lily that she can be rid of her problems with Mark if they kill him, telling Lily that she only killed Honeymooner because it had a broken leg, was in severe pain and was going to be put down, seeing it as an act of love.

Lily is shocked by her suggestion, but later starts to see it as a way to move forward, and get the repulsive Mark out of her life. They approach Tim, a small-time but ambitious local pot dealer, and try to blackmail him into doing the deed, and he is forced to agree, but on the night of the supposed killing he backs out, but they know he can''t report them to the Police because of his own illegal sideline. Confronting his step-daughter for smoking in the house, Mark tells her that once she has finished college he will cut her off financially, not knowing he she has already given upon her studies.

Spending time together watching a movie, Lily spikes Amanda's drink with the sedative Rohypnol, telling her that she was going to kill Mark and frame her friend for it, but Amanda tells her to go ahead, since her life isn''t going to be worth living soon, swallowing the drink and falling asleep. Lily leaves, intent on killing Mark and framing Amanda, knowing that with her history of violence, she will be found guilty….

Production

Director
Cory Finley
Producer
Andrew Duncan, Alex Saks, Kevin J. Walsh, Nat Faxon and Jim Rash
Editor
Louise Ford
Music
Erik Friedlander
Screenplay
Cory Finley
Director of Photography
Lyle Vincent

Review

Originally premiering at the 2017 Sundance Festival, Thoroughbreds, written and directed by Cory Finlay, his feature debut, has somewhere gained an 'S' along the way, the original title being the simple Thoroughbred, subtly but definitely changing the meaning and transferring the sobriquet to the two girls involved rather than being a wider attack on their upbringing and the social strata in which they move, hinting that both have been 'bred for success', and that nothing should get in the way of that, even if it leads to murder.

British actresses Anya Taylor-Joy (The Witch / Split) and Olivia Cooke (The Limehouse Golem / Ready Player One) play the former friends, Amanda and Lily, whose paths have diverged over the years, and the fact that Amanda's mother (Francie Smith - Two Weeks Notice / Cop Out), is essentially hiring Lily to befriend her daughter after a trauma shows how deeply the borderline neuroses runs in both families. In an echo of Peter Shaffer's Equus, Amanda has attacked and killed her horse, Honeymooner, and is awaiting trial, explaining Lilly's initial reluctance to try to rekindle their relationship.

Finding their friendship sparking up again, the perceptive Amanda also uncovering Lily's own closely-held secret, but the sociopathic Amanda has also found the main problem in her rediscovered friend's life, her vile stepfather, Mark (Paul Sparks - TV''s Boardwalk Empire / House Of Cards), and with her characteristic bluntness and direct way of speaking, points out that most of the problems in Lily's life would simply vanish if Mark was done away with.

The last film completed by young actor Anton Yelchin (the Star Trek reboot / Green Room), who was killed in terrible circumstances just two weeks after shooting ended, the film carries a 'Dedicated to Anton Yelchin.' credits card, and Yelchin is dryly funny and sympathetic as the sadly pathetic rookie drug dealer Tim, who becomes another of the girl's accidental victims when they try to drag him into their plot to kill Mark.

Based on his own un-produced stage play, and it could at times be a filmed stage play, such is the intimacy of the action, Finley's film shifts between a deeply black comedy to a thriller, as the two girls, both, as the audience starts to discover, borderline disturbed, move nearer and nearer to putting their plan into action, leading to a twist-filled finale, and a chance for Finley to metaphorically twist the knife once more.

Some critics were certainly taken with Finley's sharp and acrid concoction, The AV Club saying the film '…has been made with diabolical craft and intelligence, the kind that marks Finley as a major new American talent, but it''s no empty exercise, no mere calling card. The style all comes in service of the central relationship and the superb performances that bring it to bewitching life', while Indiewire called it '…a dark and pointed piece of work that depends on the delicacy with which someone can thread the needle between Hitchcockian suspense and capitalistic venom, and Finley - adapting his own play to the screen - demonstrates a cinematic authority that eludes many filmmakers who have worked in the medium for decades', while The Film Stage complained "'Taylor-Joy and Cooke have a weird, comedic dynamic that could have put them in the canon of cinematic duos if the movie had been braver in pushing their relationship to darker territory". Ultimately, Thoroughbreds is a lot of potential with an anticlimactic payoff'. With most reviews hailing the performances of the trio of Taylor-Joy, Cooke and Yelchin, and Finley's scripting and direction, Thoroughbreds is a very black comedy indeed, which some may find unpalatable, especially if they're horse lovers.