Film details

Embrace  2016

Cast

  • Taryn Brumfitt
  • Matthew Brumfitt
  • Jade Beal
  • Amanda De Cadenet
  • Mia Freedman
  • Harnaam Kaur
  • Stefania Ferrario
  • Renee Airya
  • Tuna Pitt
  • Nora Tschirner
  • B. Jeffrey Madoff

Synopsis

In 2013 Taryn Brumfitt, who presents herself as a Body Image Activist, posted a 'before and after' picture of herself on social media, but instead of the expected format the image instead reversed expectations, the 'before' image represented Brumfitt as the idealised female body posing during her days in women's bodybuilding, while the 'after' image represented her self-acceptance years later after having had three children with her husband Matthew. The images were viewed by more than a hundred million people online and caused outrage, argument and debate. She believed that showing pride in the woman she had become was a simple gesture which would make millions think about the traditional and expected image of women's bodies. Her gesture was widely praised and applauded by many, but also received thousands of online comments ranging from being abusive, offensive and obscene to death threats.

It was this aspect of the reaction which caused her to crowdfund a documentary in which she travels to several countries and interview both prominent and ordinary women, who speak openly about their bodies, how they feel about themselves, and the reaction to how they look, in a world where the overwhelming media images of woman are within the parameters of size zero models to size four dresses, anything over being described as 'plus size' in the modelling industry, with slimming aids and diet medications having a colossal annual advertising spend.

Brumfitt is shocked to hear that over 90% of women dislike their body and the most common adjective used by women to describe their own is 'disgusting'. Venturing into the online world of pro-anorexia and bulemia websites, she finds websites promoting both conditions, these sites including glamorised images of extremely emaciated women. She also examines how the increasing globalisation of media has meant that in cultures where traditionally a fuller female form was admired and desired, they are now dealing with women finding themselves coerced by new societal expectation for smaller and slimmer bodies.

A crowdfunded documentary with undeniably good intentions, Taryn Brumfitt's Embrace has ironically caused controversy in it's native Australia by being rated MA15+ by the Australian Classification Board, meaning that people under 15 may only legally view it when accompanied by an adult guardian, which essentially puts the documentary in a bracket alongside the likes of Fifty Shades Of Grey, and Facebook reputedly banned the film's poster, featuring Brumfitt is in a perfectly chaste, if nude, pose, on the grounds it showed 'excessive' skin, both decisions the filmmaker complained about.

Brumfitt's film stems from her posting of a 'before and after' image on social media, one being from her days in female bodybuilding, a strange and bizarre world in itself, and the latter from after having three children, she now being perfectly happy in her post-childbirth body, but it wasn't something others were willing to accept, with a torrent of online trolls amid the general acceptance and congratulation, causing her to investigate the tyranny of body image and 'acceptable depictions' of the female form.

Her interviewees are female, ranging from chat show Ricki Lake, who admits she only got the job which made her a TV staple by undergoing a major weight-loss programme, Nora Tschirner, the German musician and actress who is the German voice of Lara Croft, a character who in some iterations of the Tomb Raider game has been an extraordinarily exaggerated cartoon version of a woman, and also, given her physical dimensions, structurally inviable, and Turia Pitt, an Australian activist, severely burned in a fire, who advocates for the need for reconstructive plastic surgery over cosmetic surgery, and indeed one of the few men seen is a very creepy cosmetic surgeon to whom Brumfitt subjects herself, and finds herself being treated like a side of meat being marked up for butchery, the doctor prodding and poking at various bits and intoning how he would cut, remove and reshape as if he was working on some sort of mannequin.

The squeamish might want to be warned of brief shots of scalpels cutting into flesh during scenes of cosmetic procedures, and scenes of Botox injections. Brumfitt's film is apparently admirably free from hectoring or lecturing, and although dealing with a serious and sensitive subject is surprisingly humane, unlike the online trolls which spawned it, but one has to be surprised that the piece focuses almost exclusively on women, when men in the current climate find themselves under similar pressure.

Production

Director
Taryn Brumfitt
Producer
Taryn Brumfitt and Anna Vincent
Editor
Lindi Harrison and Bryan Mason
Screenplay
Taryn Brumfitt
Director of Photography
Hugh Fenton