Film details

The Promise  2016

Cast

  • Oscar Isaac
  • Charlotte Le Bon
  • Shohreh Aghdashloo
  • James Cromwell
  • Angela Sarafyan
  • Tom Hollander
  • Michael Stahl-David
  • Daniel Giménez-Cacho
  • Kevork Malikyan
  • Rade Serbedzija Uncredited

Synopsis

Turkey, 1914. Mikael Pogosian, an apothecary in Sirun, a small Armenian town, is set for an arranged marriage to Maral, before he leaves to go to medical school in Constantinople. Once there, attending the Imperial Medical Academy, he meets the aristocratic Ana Khesarian, an Armenian woman raised in Paris, at a soiree arranged by his wealthy uncle Emre, and falls for her, discovering that she is already involved with Chris Myers, an American journalist based in Paris working for Associated Press.

As war breaks out, Mikael manages to avoid conscription in the Ottoman Army through his medical status, but in April 1915 the Turks start to round up Armenians and he is arrested and sent to a labour camp. He manages to eventually escape, but returning to Sirun finds the Turks have turned on the Armenian populace, discovers Maral is still alive and, urged by his surviving parents, marries her before leaving for a remote mountain cabin where she soon becomes pregnant.

Having heard that Mikael has been killed, Ana tells Chris, who starts to investigate the rumours of prison camps and mass executions. Maral soon becomes ill when she suffers complications, Mikael returns to the village, hearing that Ana and Chris are at a nearby Red Cross facility, helping orphans escape by sea, and tells Chris of what he has seen and endured himself and how his family need help in escaping. Returning to Sirun with members of the refugee group, he finds Maral brutally slain and his mother and his niece left for dead. Turkish troops find Chris and arrest him, taking him back to Constantinople, where he is charged with being an enemy spy and sentenced to be executed, but with the intervention of Emre, who pleads his case to Henry Morganthau, the American Ambassador, Chris is put onto the French destroyer Guichen, and allowed to depart for Malta, but for his interference in the matter Emre is executed by the authorities.

Finding the Turkish Army are trying to track them down, the group with which Mikael and Ana are travelling join forces with another band of refugees and ambush the Turkish division on their trail, taking casualties but also driving back the soldiers. Reaching a beach where they have been told they will be rescued, the refugees are picked up by the Guichen, the boat having been on an investigative mission which has confirmed France's suspicions of what has been happening, but the Turks start to heavily shell the beach and the panicking escapees, as the French troops return fire...

Production

Director
Terry George
Producer
Eric Esrailian, William Horberg, Mike Medavoy and Ralph Winter
Art Director
Didac Bono (supervisor)
Editor
Steven Rosenblum
Music
Gabriel Yared
Screenplay
Terry George and Robin Swicord
Director of Photography
Javier Aguirresarobe

Review

Directed and co-written by Terry George, who took a similar subject, the Rawandan genocide of the 1990s and turned it into the gripping and sometimes painfully poignant Hotel Rwanda (2004), the subject of The Promise, scripted by George and Robin Swicord, is the events of 1914 which led into both the First World War and the Armenian genocide by the Turks, events which are still disputed in the region, to the point of Turkey entirely denying it ever happening despite overwhelming historical evidence and which are still sensitive, the period being largely ignored in cinema until writer director Atom Egoyan's Ararat (2002), which dealt with the supposed making of a film dealing with the events, and 2015's 1915, in which a stage director decides to mount a production around the tragedy. Indeed shortly before The Promise opened in the US there was a brief, unsuccessful release for The Ottoman Lieutenant, helmed by Joseph Ruben, and as with The Promise is a love story with the Armenian situation as a background.

Reputedly budgeted at $100m (£78.25m) and fully financed by the late billionaire Kirk Kerkorian, the former owner of MGM, himself of Armenian descent and who died in March 2015 shortly before production began, the producers of The Promise announced that any proceeds made will be donated to a variety of charities, ranging from refugee support to AIDS charities. Unlikely to be showing in multiplexes in Istanbul any time soon, with the Turkish government having made veiled threats against any distributors which handle the film internationally, given its very disappointing opening in the US, one hopes no charities are holding their breath waiting for a share-out of the profits.

Set in the last days of the formerly formidable Ottoman Empire, and the repercussion of the collapse, the script focuses on young medical student Mikael (Oscar Isaac – Inside Llewyn Davis / The Force Awakens), who becomes involved in a love triangle with the aristocratic Ana (Charlotte Le Bon – Yves Saint Laurent / Anthropoid) and American journalist Chris Myers (Christian Bale – The Dark Knight trilogy) as the early days of the Armenian genocide begin, villages are torched, massacres carried out, and the government sternly denies everything

As many reviewers noted, the film truly wants to be an epic on a grand scale, to be compared to the likes of Doctor Zhivago, but just fails in scale and scope, and while it has some fine talent on both sides of the camera, just doesn't have the heft to really give it any true impact. George utilises a swelling score by Gabriel Yared (City Of Angels / Cold Mountain), impressive cinematography by Javier Aguirresarobe (The Others / Thor: Ragnarok), Spanish, Portuguese and Maltese locations standing in for Turkey, understandably, and a cast which also includes Iranian actress Shohreh Aghdashloo (House Of Sand And Fog / TV's The Expanse) and James Cromwell (Babe / The Green Mile), but the feeling some critics had that this 133 minute version was cut down from something longer was emphasised by the fact that the peerless Jean Reno (Leon / Ronin) has literally two lines as a French admiral, and the excellent Tom Hollander (TV's Rev / The Night Manager) has less than that in what is literally seconds of screen time.

The film may be hugely well intentioned, shining light on a genuine war crime which has largely gone unreported, and The Promise it itself made, to give all proceeds away, is equally admirable, one just seems to wish the pic was better than the critics believed.