Film details

Roman J. Israel, Esq  2017

Cast

  • Carmen Ejogo
  • Shelley Hennig
  • Tony Plana
  • Nazneen Contractor
  • Brittany Ishibashi
  • Joseph David-Jones
  • James Paxton
  • DeRon Horton
  • Amanda Warren
  • Andrew T. Lee

Synopsis

Roman J. Israel, an attorney, is told by his secretary that his law partner, William Henry Jackson, has had a heart attack, so he needs to go to court and work all the cases, and to just ask for continuances due to his partner's indisposition.

Instead he finds himself getting into arguments over fees and charges, eventually being fined $5,000 for what the judge sees as contempt of court. Back at his office he's met by his law partner's daughter, Lynn, as well as another attorney, George Pierce, who inform him that Jackson is in a perceptive vegetative state and the law firm is on a bad financial footing, and while he's going to be able to finish up some of the cases, the office is probably going got have to close.

Having been very active in the civil rights era of the 60's, Roman is invited by activist Maya Alston to speak in front of a group of young protesters to give them general legal advice and particularly on what to do if they're arrested, but his combative nature leads him to arguing with one of the female members of the student group, and when Maya follows him out onto the street where they find a homeless man laying on the street. The Police arrive as they try to see if he's breathing, Roman putting a business card into the man pocket, telling Maya that if he'd dead than at least the Police will have someone to contact.

George Pierce offers Roman a job at his firm, reminding him his is a law firm with high profile clients and huge amounts of revenue coming in, and that following Roman's example is going to take on more pro bono work. One case Roman is involved with concerns a young man, Derrell Ellerbee, accused of the murder of an Armenian convenience store clerk, who denied the killing and told Roman who he believes responsible. Finding the victim's family is offering a $100,000 reward for information, Roman anonymously contacts the family and makes a deal, swapping the information for the money, even though it is illegal for Roman to do so because of his position.

Picking up the money at a cash drop, Roman takes the money home, seeing it as a reward for years and years of unpaid work, and seeing his contemporaries make fortunes. He starts to spend extravagantly, travelling to Santa Monica, buying new suits and renting an high-rise apartment overlooking the beach, When he returns to George Pierce's law firm, Pierce immediately notices a change in him, and when he puts him in charge of the new Pro Bono division Roman asks for an assurance it won't affect his new, higher salary.

On their first case they travel to the prison to interview a client arrested for murder, Carter Johnson, and it is the suspect whose name Roman gave over the phone. Roman finds that Derrell Ellerbee, the young man originally charged, has been found dead, and Johnson tells him that he knows what Roman did, and that's he's next. Roman goes home and starts to pack up his belongings, trying to organise a moving van, and realising that he has a choice, tell the truth or be running for the rest of his life…

Production

Director
Dan Gilroy
Producer
Todd Black, Jennifer Fox and Brian Oliver
Art Director
Robert W. Joseph
Editor
John Gilroy
Music
James Newton Howard
Screenplay
Dan Gilroy
Director of Photography
Robert Elswit

Review

Audiences probably won't be aware that the release version of Roman J. Israel, Esq., written and directed by Dan Gilroy, his second feature after the acclaimed Nightcrawler, isn't the one which debuted to a very modestly received premiere at the 2017 Toronto Film Festival, the film now having been heavily re-edited, cut by twelve minutes and had major changes made to the multiple music choices on the soundtrack, Washington's character being an obsessive soul and jazz fan, with James Newton Howard's score being moved around and re-purposed, Gilroy saying in an interview with Deadline: Hollywood 'The first time we actually showed the film to a real audience was in Toronto. We went right from the cutting room to the Ryerson Theatre. We wanted to make that festival but realized, watching with that crowd, that Denzel so inhabits and embodies his character that we could lean much more into the plot than we had. We re-conceived the balance of the movie, in crucial sections.

The day after Toronto, Denzel and I went back into the cutting room and spent weeks making changes. Not just to the pacing, we reordered scenes, we changed elements, particularly with Colin [Farrell]'s character', Farrell playing fellow lawyer George Pierce. To be fair the re-cutting of films after festival premieres is hardly uncommon, with writer / director Taylor Sheridan cutting some four minutes from his thriller Wind River after its Sundance debut, the result being that at Cannes, Sheridan was awarded Best Director in the Un Certain Regard sidebar for his 'finished' version, which went on to earn genuine acclaim and become one of the highest grossing 'high-end' film releases of the year.

Unfortunately that certainly didn't happen to Gilroy's movie, despite all its ambition to portray the title character as a conflicted but somehow still dedicated lawyer, serving the poor and disadvantaged, which received some scathing reviews, with some critics broaching what would seem to be the unthinkable, accusing Washington of giving a poor performance, the central problem in a twisty, convoluted pic which put complex and deliberately eccentric characters, particularly Washington's titular lawyer, into a not particularly interesting legal drama, which lurches into all-out melodrama come the end, Indiewire calling it ' …a prosaic character study laid out in painfully obvious terms, with a tacked-on twist in the third act just so that the story can find some way to end,' and The Hollywood Reporter deciding '…something at the center just doesn't hold, and it flies apart over the course of 133 minutes into confusing shards of plot, legalese-heavy monologues and, perhaps most surprising of all given Gilroy's bona fides, a touch of soggy sentimentality in the home stretch'.

Delayed some three months from its original UK release date of 1st December 2017, presumably to take it out of the firing line of such heavy hitters as Star Wars: The Last Jedi, the last word probably as to go to The AV Club who noted, with incredulity, 'Roman J. Israel, Esq., the new film written and directed by Dan Gilroy, does something rather remarkable, maybe even unprecedented, albeit not in a way anyone involved might prefer: It gets a bad performance out of Denzel Washington,' the same sort of utter incredulousness which greeted the announcement of Washington's nomination in the Best Actor bracket at the Oscars for his role.