Cast
-
Charlie Hunnam
-
Rami Malek
-
Eve Hewson
-
Roland Møller
-
Nikola Kent
-
-
Michael Socha
-
Christopher Fairbank
-
Brian Vernel
-
Ian Beattie
-
Joel Basman
-
Liam Westwood
Synopsis
On the boat to South America with the other condemned men, Papillon meets Louis Dega, an eccentric counterfeiter. That night Dega is awakened when the convict next to him is murdered by two others, who slit open his stomach and steal the money he had swallowed. Seeing Dega is bullied by the others, and targeted by the killers, who also believe he has swallowed some money, Papillion saves his life when Dega is attacked, which earns him severe punishment from the guards. In exchange for his protection, Louis agrees to finance Papillon's escape attempts from the island, which is ruled by the hardline Warden Barrot. As the months pass, Papillon and Dega form a close bond.
After an execution on the prison's guillotine, and Papillon and Dega are ordered to take the prisoner's body away, a guard turns on Dega, whipping him, causing Papillon to attack the guard with a rock, then running into the jungle. Eventually captured, he is given two years in solitary, Dega supplementing his meagre rations by smuggling in food, but when this is discovered, his rations are cut in half. Although the Warden demands Papillon tells him who smuggled the food, he refuses to betray Dega, who acts as an aide to the Warden.
Papillon feigns insanity brought on by the solitary confinement, and in the prison infirmary works on another escape plan. Dega bribes another prisoner, Celier, who has a connection to get a boat. Another prisoner, Maturette, who has been the victim of repeated sexual abuse in the prison, joins the plan. Dega gets the guards drunk, then the four go over the prison walls down to the shore to the boat, Dega injuring himself, but when a storm strikes it becomes clear the boat will not survive the journey with four passengers. Cellier wants to kill Dega and throw his body over the side but in the ensuring fight Cellier is killed. The three survivors make shore and are taken in by the sisters in a convent in Columbia, but the Mother Superior contacts the authorities and they are taken back to the prison. Papillon is condemned to five years in solitary.
When he is finally released he is a broken man, weak and prematurely aged, but finds that Dega has fitted well into the prison system and, unlike he, has no desire to escape. But Papillon has been working on a final plan, making a raft out of coconuts and risking both the launch from the cliffs into the sea, and then the dangerous tides, and is willing to die at sea rather than on Devil's Island.
Production
- Director
- Michael Noer
- Producer
- Ram Bergman, Roger Corbi, David Koplan and Joey McFarland
- Art Director
- Tom Frohling (principle a.d.)
- Editor
- John Axelrad and Lee Haugen
- Music
- David Buckley
- Screenplay
- Aaron Guzikowski, based on the screenplay of the 1973 film Papillon, by Dalton Trumbo and Lorenzo Semple Jr., based on the books Papillon and Banco by Henri Charriére
- Director of Photography
- Hagen Bogdanski
Review
The '73 version, directed with a overbearing sense of scale by Franklin J. Schaffner (Planet Of The Apes / Patton: Lust For Glory), really was a gruelling experience, running a punishing 151 minutes and with a very obviously self-imbued sense of gravity, and with the finale, Papillon's finally escape attempt, seeming to be quite ridiculously over-extended. McQueen gives a quasi-Method performance determined to show every bead of sweat and drop of blood as his character is repeatedly beaten and punished, while Hoffman's counterfeiter Dega seems to be an early runout for the sort of withdrawn, obsessive mildly autistic character who would finally blossom into Rain Man's Raymond Babbitt fifteen years later.
Noer's version runs eighteen minutes shorter (although the German release print is cut by a further fifteen minutes) but crams in more incident and has an overall better pace, as well as including a post-prison postscript, with Charrière, now free, working on the book which would become the bestseller after being published in 1970, captions explaining what happened post-publication. As effective as this is, it doesn''t match the quietly shocking final shots of Schaffner's version, as the camera glides through the genuine and now derelict halls, corridors and cells of the Devil's Island camp, having been shut down in 1953, a hundred and one years after it opened, showing not only the sheer scale of the place but the stark and coldly unembellished facilities, all of which were created for punishment, not rehabilitation.
Living up to such distinguished predecessors in their roles, Charlie Hunnam (Pacific Rim / TV's Sons Of Anarchy) and Rami Malik (Bohemian Rhapsody / TV's Mr. Robot) are already hobbled by what has gone before, but this version of the story is more action-oriented, upping the pace and less concerned with its own portentousness, Noer making this more of a prison break film than the often plodding pseudo-profound character study Schaffer at times seemed to be attempting. Hannan's character is believably low-life as Charrière, admitting to being a thief and robber but insisting he has been framed for murder, while the bespectacled Malik makes Dega fiercely intelligent and extremely vulnerable, their relationship, Papillon acting as his paid protector, turning into something much closer. This is grim stuff at times, with prisoners willing to slit each other open should they believe another has smuggled money by swallowing it, and the island was still used for executions, as the guillotine in the main courtyard constantly reminds the inmates.
Of course Charrière's books caused controversy, first being seen as an expose of the brutal, murderous regime on the island, but then causing more headlines when the authenticity of Charrière's account, along with his second book, Banco, was brought into question, some saying Charriére had not so much embroidered the truth as woven entire fictional tapestries, claims the author, who died in 1973, aged 66, vigorously denied, eventually conceding the books were '75% true', but researchers believed that much of the pivotal events in the books were taken from stories told by other inmates and events which happened to other prisoners, which the writer then claimed as his own experiences. The book caused such controversy that journalists launched their own investigations into the story, and those interested in following that branch of the story should check out Les Quatre Vérités De Papillon (The Four Truths Of The Butterfly) by Georges Ménager, a former Paris-Match reporter, and the book Papillon Épinglé (Butterfly Pinned), French journalist Gerard de Villiers, creator of the bestselling SAS Malko Linge spy series, stating that 'Only about 10 percent of Charrière's book represents the truth'.
Some critics were relatively kind, The Film Stage believing '"Noer isn''t interested in the pulpy, wannabe mythic journey of Papillon when there''s a meatier through-line highlighting our humanity in dire straits. Rather than make his film about how far our bodies can go, he seeks to portray the lengths our hearts will"', while Variety took the film at face value, saying '"On its own terms, Noer's adventure is ultimately a dramatic and dynamic-enough telling of an indelible fact-based story to connect with viewers".' The leads drew the attention of The Guardian, who believed 'Hunnam and Malek both hold up their end of the deal. Noer, for his part, meets them halfway by conjuring golden-hued beauty for the jungle surroundings and a due griminess for the danker chambers of their holding compound. He doesn't overcomplicate things for himself, keeping the clunky dialogue to a minimum and focusing on the guiding light of Papi's indomitable willpower'. The Austin Chronice surmisied "'If you''re a fan of the two leads, it is worth your time, but if you''re a fan of the original film, it becomes more of a curio, an interesting comparison of filmmaking in the Seventies to what contemporary cinema gives us today"'. And the idea of remaking the story at all puzzled some, for different reasons, Entertainment Weekly finding '…"it wisely doubles down on high adventure, but it's still as lifeless as its predecessor. Just in different ways"', while The Playlist pondered '"With no unique viewpoint on the story of its own, it's perplexing why Papillon went in front of cameras at all'".