Film details

Citizen Verdict  2003

Film still

Cast

  • Jerry Springer
  • Justine Mitchell
  • Rafaello DeGruttola
  • Dorette Potgieter
  • Clive Scott
  • Lynn Blades
  • Andre Jacobs
  • Langley Kirkwood
  • Danny Keogh
  • Nicole Sherwin

Synopsis

Marty Rockman is a TV producer, working in Florida at the end of the next decade. Marty, who knows that TV programmes have to be new and shocking to gain any sort of impact in the over-saturated market, manages to persuade State Governor Bull Tyler to let him transmit his latest 'reality' show - Citizen Verdict, in which a real criminal would be tried before the cameras, the verdict being given by the viewers by telephone and e-mail votes. Tyler, who wants to cultivate his hard-man image, determined to enforce justice and thin down the over-crowded jails, agrees, and the criminal selected is Ricky Carr, a delinquent who is charged with the rape and brutal murder of Dolly Hamilton, a popular TV cookery show hostess. As the programme prepares for broadcast, Professor Sam Patterson, who has studied law, is appointed to defend Ricky Carr, although the case looks airtight, Marty wanting to give the viewers little room for doubt in their first programme. He interviews Carr who tells him that Dolly Hamilton had a taste for rough sex with male escorts, of whom he was one, and it was during one of their sessions together, for which she paid him, that she died, her death being an unfortunate accident. Knowing that this side of Dolly Hamilton's life has been covered up by her PR people and the network bosses, Sam starts to try to find any other male prostitutes who can back up Carr's statement, and discovers Vince Turner, who confirms Hamilton's taste for brutality. Citizen Verdict hits the airwaves, drawing a huge audience. Sam believes he has done enough to prove Carr innocent of murder after addressing the TV audience, but is shocked when at the last minute a video tape showing Carr murdering Hamilton is produced as evidence and shown over the network. The public vote for Carr to be executed. The execution itself is to be shown as a separate pay-per-view event. Carr calls for a final meeting with Sam which reveals something telling about Marty Rockman, a detail which Sam must somehow use to convince Governor Tyler that there has been a major corruption of justice, all to satisfy the voyeuristic demands of the TV audience.

Production

Director
Philippe Martinez
Producer
Philippe Martinez and Helmut Breuer
Art Director
Zack Grobler
Editor
Kristina Hamilton
Music
Guy Farley
Screenplay
Tony Clarke and Frank Rehwaldt, Kristina Hamilton and Philippe Martinez
Director of Photography
Michael Brierley

Review

Taking a clever idea, aided by the impish casting of Jerry Springer as the soulless Marty Rockman, Citizen Verdict is an enjoyable enough thriller which casts some nice swipes at the plague of 'reality' TV shows, only to refuse to take the plot to its natural conclusion. Having the man who is perhaps the touchstone of trash TV play a corrupt TV producer is one of the better casting choices by debut director Philippe Martinez, and while Roy Scheider (Jaws / 2010) is still impressively craggy if now clearly getting on a bit, Armand Assante (I, The Jury) seems miscast as the law professor Sam Patterson. While Assante is perfectly capable at playing everything from John Gotti to Mike Hammer, he seems constrained in a role which is essentially that of an academic, not allowed much in the way of action or set-pieces. Citizen Verdict is a clever concept which is pulled in too many directions, from Rockman's cynicism to Tyler's pragmatism in seeing a way of clearing the jails, but not knowing whether to opt for satire or straight drama. It may seem far-fetched, but in a world where genuine murder trials can be derailed by the presence of TV cameras in the court rooms, anything is possible.