Film details

Mary, Queen of Scots  2018

Cast

  • Margot Robbie
  • Saoirse Ronan
  • David Tennant
  • Jack Lowden
  • Gemma Chan
  • Joe Alwyn
  • Martin Compston
  • Brendan Coyle
  • Maria-Victoria Dragus
  • James McArdle
  • Liah O'Prey

Synopsis

1561. Eighteen-year-old Catherine Mary Stuart, recently widowed, having lost her husband Francis II, the Dauphin of France, returns to Scotland from France, where she has spent most of her life, to reclaim the throne, that of The Earl of Moray, she believes is rightfully hers. The English throne is held by Elizabeth, her Protestant cousin, and Mary, a Roman Catholic, knows she will have to lodge her claim for ascendancy, but also that the idea of a Roman Catholic Queen in the North is regarded as dangerous by Elizabeth's advisers at court.

Mary marries Henry Stuart, Lord Darnley, her first cousin and also Catholic, bearing him a son, the arrival of a true heir putting pressure on the childless Elizabeth to do something to neutralise the threat posed by Mary, with some of the closest in her retinue telling her that she should use all means available to her, including violence if necessary. Mary does not know that her half-brother, the Earl of Moray, is in league with the English, as the obsessively devout Protestant minister John Knox organises protests against her, spreading lies and slander and calling her 'The harlot Queen'. Darnley becomes increasingly agitated and volatile concerning the situation, demanding to be made Crown Matrimonial, meaning he would assume the throne if he outlives his wife, and is murdered by members of Mary's own staff.

In 1568, fearing for her safety, Mary flees to England leaving her son, James, behind, and has a secret meeting with Elizabeth, where the possibility of some sort of accord is raised and Elizabeth's support in regaining her throne, but Elizabeth cannot accept the proposition and Mary is imprisoned, being moved around various estates and manor houses, where she will wait for nearly two decades…

Production

Director
Josie Rourke
Producer
Tim Bevan, Eric Fellner and Debra Hayward
Art Director
Nick Gottschalk and James Wakefield (supervisors)
Editor
Chris Dickens
Music
Max Richter
Screenplay
Beau Willimon, based on My Heart Is My Own: The Life Of Mary Queen Of Scots by John Guy
Director of Photography
John Mathieson

Review

Any bio-pic has a certain amount of fabrication simply due to the realities of transferring a life or certain elements therein onto a big screen for two hours, and when the film is set in a specific historical period, here the 1560s, then more liberties have to be taken, customs, behaviour and foremost language being very different from today. Where the characters in Mary Queen Of Scots speak in the actual vocabulary and grammar they used the pic would have to be subtitled. Some historians levelled accusations of embellishment and dramatic licence at Yorgos Lanthimos's The Favourite, released at roughly the same time, complaining at some of the liberties taken with the story of Queen Anne and her shenanigans around the royal court, but this steadfastly earnest retelling of the story of the recently widowed eighteen-year-old Catherine Mary Stuart, making a claim for the throne of Scotland, takes things rather further by having the two main characters, Mary and Queen Elizabeth, trying to negotiate a peaceful solution for the constitutional crisis which faces each country, the two becoming engaged in a relationship of mutual respect across several long scenes, whereas most historians will attest that is is highly improbable that the two even ever actually met.

Adapted by Beau Willimon (TV's House Of Cards / The First) from John Guy's biography Queen Of Scots: The True Life Of Mary Stuart, which won the 2004 Whitbread Biography Award, the script essentially thins out a very complex historical period, with conflicts between both England and Scotland, English Protestants and Scottish Catholics, and the various other interested parties who are manipulating both Mary (Saorise Ronan - Hanna / Lady Bird) and Elizabeth (Margot Robbie - Suicide Squad / I, Tonya) for their own ends, be it Mary's power-hungry husband, Lord Darnley (Jack Lowden - '71 / Dunkirk), adviser William Cecil (Guy Pearce - Memento / Prometheus), the firebrand John Knox (David Tennant, obviously enjoying himself), the turncoat Earl of Moray (James McArdle - Star Wars: The Force Awakens / TV's Appropriate Adult). The feature debut of stage director Josie Rourke, previously the head of the acclaimed Donmar Warehouse in Covent Garden, the script spans twenty-six years, over the course of which both female leads age suspiciously little, and certainly Rourke stages much of this impressively, from the various royal estates and lands, with locations in both England and Scotland, as well as Gloucester Cathedral, with meetings between Mary and Elizabeth eventually being carried out against diverting backgrounds, including, so this version would let us believe, in a secluded barn where it seems half the kingdom's laundry is drying, a complete invention but certainly well designed.

This was also a brutal period, as the script also acknowledges, and even supposed allies were capable of knocking off members of their own side if expedient, as Mary's own husband finds out to his cost, and the atmosphere of mutual distrust and suspicion is very evident, but the film also almost completely skips over the nearly twenty years Mary spent imprisoned in various nobel houses before what was almost a botched execution at Fotheringhay Castle. Basically the story has been retooled in order to make it a drama between the two most powerful women of the time, with little regard for absolutely immutable facts such as the fact that, at nearly six foot tall, Mary towered over almost everybody else, male or female, in a time were the average height was around 5''7"'', whereas Saorise Ronan is very slight of stature, and Elizabeth certainly wasn''t the rather glam, ice queen figure presented here, and the very murky political morass surrounding the whole affair thinned out, wisely, Rourke's pic divided critics, The Playlist believing "'Despite its ruff collars and Elizabethan English, Mary Queen of Scots is no staid, stuffy period drama, as restrained as the breathing of corseted women. Instead, this a vital film, whose lace-trimmed bosom heaves with life"', Empire noting "'It turns out that a feminist angle really can revive the same old Tudor psychodramas, thanks in large part to Ronan and Robbie's authoritative performances",' while Variety compared it to '"an entire season of peak television crammed into the space of two hours, Mary Queen of Scots spares us not only the butchery but also a great deal of the drama that might explain how the misfortunate monarch came to find her neck on the line'.

Very much a female-led historical drama rather than any particularly faithful version of the real events, and as such in keeping with the previous retellings of the story, at least thirty different films and TV series being made about the subject, going back to the one-minute 1895 short The Execution Of Mary, Queen Of Scots, one of the first films to use camera tricks as rudimentary special effects, and 'starring' the rather wonderfully named Mrs. Robert L. Thomas.