Film details

Wonder Wheel  2017

Cast

Synopsis

Coney Island, the 1950s. Ginny, a former actress who now waits on tables at a clam house on the boardwalk, tells herself that she is just playing the 'thankless' part of a waitress, and will return to the other sort of boards soon enough, but she is married to carousel operator Humpty Rannell, being his second wife, living with him and her ten-year-old son Richie, who has a problem in starting fires.

Humpty is bad tempered, boorish and alcoholic, the marriage being in trouble and their relationship dull and stale. Ginny, approaching her fortieth birthday, craves some new excitement or passion in her life, but Humpty also has to deal with the problem of his daughter, Carolina, estranged from her father and now apparently the partner of a local gangster. Ginny is surprised when Mickey Rubin, an NYU student working as a lifeguard at the boardwalk, comes into her life, and the two are soon involved in an affair, Ginny finding her life rejuvenated through her falling for the younger man, who is also an aspiring playwright, but Carolina, now on the run from the mob, turns up once again in the life of the Rannells.

Carolina, spoilt and entitled, moves in, much to Ginny's displeasure but at Humpty's insistence as she insincerely begs for forgiveness and claiming she is fearing for her life since she has betrayed her mobster husband to the Police. When Carolina meets Mickey and wants him for herself, tensions rise within the Rannell household as Ginny starts to realise she is losing her lover to the younger woman, and the frustrations of years start to flow from her…

Production

Director
Woody Allen
Producer
Erika Aronson, Letty Aronson and Edward Walson
Art Director
Miguel López-Castillo
Editor
Alisa Lepselter
Music
Various
Screenplay
Woody Allen
Director of Photography
Vittorio Storaro

Review

Another year, yet another Woody Allen feature with an unfeasibly strong cast, largely, but as one can see from the news, a number of these involved in Allen's previous films are finally starting to realise that being involved with the filmmaker is perhaps inadvisable in this new climate where alleged abuse is no longer being swept under the carpet, and while his films remain divisive among critics and audiences alike, Wonder Wheel taking just $1.4m (£997,150) during it's entire US theatrical run, which peaked at 536 cinemas, even his most ardent proponents were force to admit that, like '13's Blue Jasmine, which won Cate Blanchett an Oscar, this is another uncredited reworking of Tennessee Williams' classic A Streetcar Named Desire, even down to critics comparing lines and dialogue exchanges from the film to Williams' 1947 stage work.

Set on the Coney Island of the 1950s, where Allen spent a lot of time as a child, if a decade earlier, Williams' Blance Du Bois has transmuted into Kate Winslet's Ginny, like Blanche an unhappy woman in a loveless marriage, here to the oddly named Humpty (Jim Belushi – TV's According To Jim / Wild Palms), fearing aging and being drawn to a much younger man.

But whereas Du Bois had the brooding, steaming Stanley Kowalski, a role which forever made Marlon Brando a cinema icon, Ginny escapes into an affair with Mickey (singer, actor and SuperBowl disappointment Justin Timberlake), not only a lifeguard but also an NYU student and aspiring playwright, and with Timberlake being 37 years old, about fifteen years too old, who also frequently breaks the fourth wall to address the audience as to what is actually going on. Add to this an arsonist son, and the arrival of Humpty's daughter, gangster's moll Carolina (Juno Temple – Maleficent / Unsane), on the run from her gangster husband and all the ingredients for the pot-boiler are safely in the pan.

Using his regular DoP, the masterly Vittorio Storaro, reviews mentioned how the camerawork bathes everything in the sort of orange nostalgic glow that never really existed in nature, but which has become cinematic shorthand, but even this goes off the rails in a late scene where the character of Ginny looks up at the titular Wonder Wheel, the ferris wheel at the end of the Coney Island pier, in a scene so deeply and fizzily orange / copper toned one suspects New York has just gone up in a nuclear strike.

Of the cast both Winslet and Temple received praise for what were seen as thankless roles, Allen really having little sympathy with any character involved, causing The Hollywood Reporter to note 'The warming affection that the director has bestowed on so many of his best characters is largely missing. In fact, he seems barely engaged,' and The Wrap to add 'Allen is too self-aware and cold a creative personality to create a genuine tragedy in Wonder Wheel. Instead, he makes a gesture towards a tragic situation. He knows what a tragedy would be like theoretically, but he is unable to create one himself because he doesn't have enough conviction to do so.

Allen's writing oscillates here between stilted dialogue that sounds like dialogue and the kind of formality of phrasing that is probably an echo of his own youth in Brooklyn in the 1950s'. But it was down to RogerEbert.com to reflect the bulk of the critic's opinions, saying 'Turgid even in its brightness, overwritten in a way that does nothing to camoflauge its first-draft quality, jaw-droppingly overacted by all but one of its central cast members; it's a Woody Allen disaster that elicits both a cocked head and a dropped jaw.

Given that Mr. Allen's professional approach to moviemaking most resembles a basketball player's free-throw practice – he endeavors to make a picture once a year, no exceptions, and has been hitting that goal for decades – variability of quality is a given. But, man, this one'. Woody Allen has made nearly fifty features over five decades with almost metronomic regularity, but with the winds of change in Hollywood, and his own advancing age, one has to wonder how many more he will be responsible for.