Cast
-
-
-
-
Alec McCowen
-
-
Mary Beth Hurt
-
-
Alexis Smith
-
-
-
Michael Gough
-
Stuart Wilson
Synopsis
New York, the 1870s, and in the circles of the city's high society, ripples are caused by the arrival of Ellen Olenska, a beautiful young American woman who has returned from a long stay in Europe, having left her wealthy aristocratic husband. Ellen is a cousin of May Welland, a young woman who is about to formally announce her engagement to Newland Archer, a prominent young lawyer who has connections to the highest families on the Eastern seaboard. Archer is eager to be wed to May, and is urging her to agree to move up the date of their wedding, but then he meets Ellen, who is dramatically different to any other woman he knows, including his intended, being independent, free-spirited, determined and sensual. Archer finds himself in a quandary, not only because of the feelings he has discovered for Ellen, very different from the almost pale emotions May stirs within him, but because he knows he has a prescribed role in society, to wed a suitable woman, start a family and have a good, productive career, but the way Ellen makes him feel makes him doubt all that, wondering if he can go against the hidebound conventions and expectations of the time for such a thing as true love.
Production
- Director
- Martin Scorsese
- Producer
- Barbara De Fina
- Art Director
- Speed Hopkins and Jean-Michel Hugon
- Editor
- Thelma Schoonmaker
- Music
- Elmer Bernstein
- Screenplay
- Jay Cocks and Martin Scorsese, based on the novel by Edith Wharton
- Director of Photography
- Michael Ballhaus
Review
A luxurious and very faithful adaptation of Edith Wharton's Pulitzer Prize-winning original novel, written in 1921, Martin Scorsese makes a very different New York-set film from such as been associated with him in the past, such as the brutality and alienation of Mean Streets and Taxi Driver, being a slowly paced but beautifully judged story of love, conflicted emotions and the expectation in a rarefied society which was the New York elite of the fin de siècle New York. Although previously filmed in 1934, with Irene Dunne and John Boles, that now rarely-seen version focuses more on the conventional romantic aspects, while Scorsese's film, scripted by the director with Jay Cocks, is more concerned with focusing on the difficulties of having such strong emotions in a society which was restrained to the point of being repressed, where emotions were meant to be concealed at all times, public propriety demanded strict manners and an observance to special protocols at all times, which makes for a completely convincing portrait of the period but which also makes some scenes frustrating, as their characters are literally unable to say what they fell for fear of offending what was seen as the norm of the times. What keeps the film so watchable, at a languorous two and a quarter hours, are the performances, with Daniel Day-Lewis giving a tight and restrained performance initially akin to his Cecil Vyse in the film version of A Room With A View, and certainly more controlled than in the director's subsequent Gangs Of New York, while Winona Ryder is also well cast as the eager May Welland, keen to be married to lawyer Newland Archer, keenly aware of what it will do their social standing, adding another layer of respectability. Where the casting works the best is with Michelle Pfeiffer as the exotic and beautiful Ellen, the sort of woman who would truly cause ripples in the social strata in which she moved, and whose air of dangerous allure, not only having already walked out on her husband but having recently returned from exotic Europe, only makes her all the more dangerous in the eyes of many, and it is utterly understandable how Archer should threaten his social standing in pursuit of her. The director also manages to capture the opulence and gentility of the period perfectly, where manners and geniality were everything, and its amusing to see Scorsese give himself a small cameo as a formal photographer, amid a very strong largely British supporting cast including Richard E. Grant (Withnail And I), Alec McCowan (Cry Freedom), Mary Beth Hurt (Scorsese's subsequent Bringing Out The Dead), Geraldine Chaplin (The Moderns), Robert Sean Leonard (TV's House) and Jonathan Pryce (Tomorrow Never Dies), all speaking the mid-Atlantic accent which would have been perfect for the time and location, another instance of the attention to detail. Nominated for five Oscars, the film only scored in the category of Best Costume Design, failing to lift Best Supporting Actress, for Winona Ryder, Adapted Screenplay, Art Direction and Original Score.