Film details

Lizzie  2018

Cast

Synopsis

1892. Andrew and Abby Borden, a wealthy and influential New England couple, living in Fall River, Massachusetts, are found brutally murdered in their comfortable home. Lizzie Borden, the younger of Andrew's two daughters by his first marriage, and unwed thirty-two year-old who still lives at home, is suspected of involvement in the killings, which were carried out with an axe.

Lizzie is questioned by the authorities, eventually revealing that she had a fraught and often volatile relationship with her father, who was a strict disciplinarian and extremely cautious with money. He was also worried, having become the recipient of anonymous threatening letters. The family employed a new maid, Bridget Sullivan, who came to live in the Borden's house.

She and Lizzie became close friends, but Bridget also becomes involved in a furtive sexual relationship with Andrew. He sought a way to avoid financial penalties by transferring the family's financial affairs to be the responsibility of his late first wife's brother, John Vinnicum Morse, who Lizzie detested.

In a fit if anger and spite, Andrew killed Lizzie's pet domesticated pigeons. Increasingly resentful towards her parents, Lizzie and Bridget became involved in a secret relationship, but Andrew became suspicious and warned Lizzie to end it. On August 4th, both Andrew and Abby Borden were savagely murdered, their bodies showing signs of multiple axe blows. Lizzie and her sister Emma stand to inherit the entire estate, but Andrew's will cannot be found. Lizzie is arrested and held in jail, where Bridget visits her, asking Lizzie never to contact her again, no matter what happens.

The trial, held in New Bedford, with Lizzie accused of both murders, defended by attorney Andrew Jennings, begins on June 5th, 1893…

Production

Director
Craig William Macneill
Producer
Naomi Despres, Elizabeth Destro and Chloë Sevigny
Art Director
Nicole LeBlanc
Editor
Abbi Jutkowitz
Music
Jeff Russo
Screenplay
Bryce Kass
Director of Photography
Noah Greenberg

Review

Lizzie Borden took an axe / And gave her mother forty whacks / When she saw what she had done / She gave her father forty-one, or so at least that's how the song goes, this charming ditty reputedly being written by a newspaper columnist to publicise the sensational case, although the truth behind this, like so much about the case, isn't entirely clear.

The case remains strangely prominent in American folklore, and much speculation and rumour has grown around it, not only because of the severity of the crime, at least for the time, but the quite extraordinary court case which followed. More than twenty-five film and TV versions, offering different accounts of the crime, some more speculative than others, have been made, some even suggesting supernatural influences, as well as being the subject of theatrical productions, musical works and any number of books and investigative pieces.

While different approaches have been taken by various writers and directors, helmer Craig William Macneill (TV's Channel Zero) and screenwriter Bryce Kass, his first cinema feature, take the real events and largely speculate as to motive and method, as well as adding a completely invented romance between the unmarried thirty-two year-old Lizzie (Chloë Sevigny - Eyes Wide Shut / TV's Big Love) and family maid Bridget Sullivan (Kristen Stewart - The Twilight Saga / Clouds Of Sils Maria). Macneill and Kass stay true to some aspects of the story, with Lizzie being seen as an awkward outcast, utterly dominated by her dictatorial father, Andrew (the excellent character actor Jamey Sheridan - Spotlight / TV's Law & Order: Criminal Intent), who is also, again only in fiction, having an employer / employee affair with Bridget, before Bridget secretly also starts to become involved with Lizzie.

While this sets up a rather uncomfortable triangular relationship, and the threat of blood and axes to come, Macneill chooses not to set the film up as any sort of thriller, but almost as a strangely chaste romance, with lots of furtive glances, heavy silences and gazing into each other's eyes between Lizzie and Bridget but not much else, and even the stance Sevigny, one of the producers, has stated was its' intent, a feminist-slanted retelling emphasising the role of women at the time against the hegemony of men, seemed to be put on the back burner. And while modern theorists have proposed the notorious skinflint Andrew's wealth and estate (worth about $8m / £6.2m at today's rates), and what he proposed to do with the family's various properties as a motive, again this remains undeveloped.

The execution of the crime itself is also here just speculation, having both Lizzie and Bridget involved in joint-enterprise slaying, and what Kass' script seems to think is a revelatory idea, the fact that the killer / killers stripped naked before carrying out the crime, thus no bloodstained clothes were ever found, was first proposed by the 1975 TV movie The Legend Of Lizzie Borden, starring Elizabeth Montgomery as the axe-swinger.

Lizzie certainly isn't the first retelling of the story, and it certainly won't be the last, the story being so strange and bizarre, in so many ways, that it is bound to be historical catnip for many filmakers in the years to come.