Film details

Can You Ever Forgive Me?  2018

Can You Ever Forgive Me

Cast

  • Melissa McCarthy
  • Jane Curtin
  • Dolly Wells
  • Anna Deavere Smith
  • Stephen Spinella
  • Ben Falcone
  • Marc Evan Jackson
  • Michael Cyril Creighton
  • Shae D'Lyn
  • Kevin Carolan
  • Brandon Scott Jones

Synopsis

Having written successfully for magazines such as Vanity Fair, profiling Katherine Hepburn, and written biographies of actress Tallulah Bankhead in 1972 and journalist and TV personality Dorothy Kilgallen in 1980, the latter of which appeared on The New York Times Bestseller List, freelance writer Lee Israel is rocked when her biography of cosmetics heiress Estée Lauder, published in '85, flops badly, both with critics and readers, Lauder having written and released her own autobiography at exactly the same time to thwart the unauthorised book, leaving Lee in financial trouble and struggling with both writer's block and her own alcoholism, with many in the literary world unwilling to deal with her because of her abrasive and confrontational personality. Her agent, Marjorie, tries to get her an advance for another project, but cannot find a publisher, forcing Lee to start to sell her possessions in order to raise money, including one of her most personal; a letter written to her by Katherine Hepburn, which she sells to Anna, a local book dealer.

Working on a book about vaudeville entertainer Fanny Brice, Lee is conducting research in the New York Public Library for the Performing Arts at Lincoln Center when she comes across a handwritten letter from Brice hidden in a book. She steals it, taking it to Anna, who gives her a low price, since the content of the letter itself is quite uninteresting, but Lee realises that she can make money through forging such letters. She begins to produce her own letters from deceased writers, actors and playwrights, such as Dorothy Parker, Lillian Hellman and Louise Brooks, ageing them through various methods and buying a number of vintage typewriters, making sure to include enticing incidents and intimate references so as to make them more interesting and valuable to unweary buyers and to fetch a higher price. Anna buys whatever Lee can produce, and tries to interest her romantically, but Lee rebuffs her.

After a letter claiming to be from Nöel Coward in which he supposedly blatantly discusses his homosexuality is questioned as to it's provenance, it being very unlikely he would ever have put this down on paper, buyers blacklist Lee, causing Anna to refuse to sell any more of her material. Finding herself unable to sell the forgeries herself, she turns to her friend, flamboyant gay drug dealer Jack Hock, a fellow alcoholic, to pretend to be a dealer in letters and manuscripts, acting as a front for Lee, who starts to visit libraries and archives and steal original, genuine letters and documents, replacing them with forged copies. Making very good money for the first time in years, being able to pay her considerable back rent and pay for veterinarian care for her elderly cat, Lee spends the evenings drinking with Jack in various dive bars and at home. When Lee comes home after another larcenous outing to find her cat, which Jack was looking after, has died she is utterly furious and breaks off their friendship, but also knows she needs Jack to sell her forgeries, so continues the business arrangement. After two years Lee has forged over four hundred pieces of work, managing to sell most of them.

1992. During a sale of Lee's forgeries to a supposed client, Jack is arrested by the FBI. In exchange for clemency he informs on Lee, who is issued a court summons for forgery. Panicking, she gets rid of the more than a dozen typewriters she has used, in local bins and dumpsters. Consulting a lawyer, as she starts to realise just how serious the charge is, he advises her to try to show contrition for the crimes, do something worthwhile like community service or volunteering, and to enrol in Alcoholics Anonymous, but as the court case nears, she, without her lawyer's consent, decides to take another line…

Production

Director
Marielle Heller
Producer
Anne Carey, Amy Nauiokas and David Yarnell
Art Director
Marci Mudd
Editor
Anne McCabe
Music
Nate Heller
Screenplay
Nicole Holofcener and Jeff Whitty, based on the memoir Can You Ever Forgive Me? by Lee Israel
Director of Photography
Brandon Trost

Review

In a neat twist, Can You Ever Forgive Me?, the film version of Lee Israel's story now seen on screen, isn't actually the 'original', the first version being planned to go into production in mid-2015 with Julianne Moore as Israel and Chris O'Dowd as the louche junkie Jack Hock, the film being directed by Nicole Holofcener, but Moore and Holofcener, both claiming 'creative differences', dropped out in July of that year, leaving the film in limbo until the producers reactivated it the following year, Marielle Heller (The Diary Of A Teenage Girl ) directing from Holofcener and Jeff Whitty's script, with Melissa McCarthy (Bridesmaids / Spy ) as Lee and Richard E. Grant (Withnail & I / Gosford Park ) as Jack, and there's not many films about which you can say Melissa McCarthy replaced Julianne Moore in the lead.

While obviously taking liberties with the story, one of the most obvious is, as irascible, irritable, foul-mouthed and downright unpleasant McCarthy depicts the struggling, resentful Lee Israel, a little research will show that this is a quite sympathetic portrait compared to the real person, who died in 2014, going to the grave insisting she had done little wrong, blaming everyone else for anything which went wrong in her life. The real Lee Israel was a freelance writer who had moderate success with a couple of mass-market biography, but was scuppered by the hugely wealthy cosmetics heiress Estée Lauder who, finding Israel was writing an unauthorised biography, rushed her own book into the shops, beating Israel's effort and scuppering the whole enterprise, as well as Israel's career.

She is working on another seemingly doomed project, a biography of turn-of-the-century entertainer Fanny Brice, played by Barbra Striesand in Funny Girl , that her agent (Jane Curtin - TV's SNL / 3rd Rock From The Sun ) has already told her nobody will be interested in, when she sells a genuine letter she has found in a research volume, the dealer telling her it isn't very valuable because it lacks personal details and distinctiveness, which quickly alerts her to the fact that she can forge these, and in a way tailor them to the gullible collectors. And she was very successful, although her desire to make her 'material' desirable to buyers means that suspicions were raised in the collecting world, not only because she immediately seemed to be such a source of such valuable and previously unseen letters, but also because of the sheer quantity she had access too, a letter from Nöel Coward in particular raising suspicion through being so explicit about him being gay in a time when, in his native country, homosexuality was still illegal. Her solution is to use Jack Hock (Grant), a gay drug dealer and, like herself, an alcoholic, but who could liaise with dealers and customers by using his considerable charm, something Lee acknowledged she just didn't have.

The heart of Heller's film is largely the unlikely friendship between these two outsiders, people with a knack of attracting trouble and who have each other and almost no one else, initially drinking partners who are brought together by their boozing and reckless behaviour, before falling into an uncomfortable business relationship, Jack using his louche charms to sell what Lee is producing, even if he admits he has no idea who most of the people are Lee is impersonating.

The sad thing is that Lee Israel was a good writer, and convinced many of the veracity of what she produced, saying at one point 'I write a better Dorothy Parker than Dorothy Parker', and two of her faked Nöel Coward letters turned up in a collection of the man's (genuine) correspondence, but also, as the film shows, but not nearly as emphatically as in reality, Israel believed she had done nothing wrong, the title of the film also being the title of her own, rather defiant autobiography, that what she was doing was a victimless crime, despite the obvious fraud, the collectors who lost money and the damage to genuine literary archives and academe.

Heller's film is probably extremely kind to both Israel and Hock, who also served time for armed robbery, but strangely in dealing with blatant forgery, have created something captivating and almost original.