Film details

Happy as Lazzaro  2018

Lazzaro Felice / Heureux Comme Lazzaro / My Bitter Land

Cast

  • Nicoletta Braschi
  • Adriano Tardiolo
  • Sergi López
  • Alba Rohrwacher
  • David Bennett
  • Elisabetta Rocchetti
  • Tommaso Ragno
  • Alessandro Genovesi
  • Daria Pascal Attolini
  • Carlo Massimino
  • Natalino Balasso
  • Gala Othero Winter

Synopsis

A sprawling widespread tobacco-growing estate, near the quiet village of Inviolata, is owned by the ruthless Marchessa Alfonsina de Luna, a rich tobacco baroness, and worked by more than fifty sharecroppers and labourers, all of whom feel like an extended family, especially when she regularly treats them badly, barely being able to hide her condescension behind a fake, brittle smile. The workers accept their lot, knowing that to try to cross the Marchesa will result in disaster, but no accepts their position more readily than Lazzaro, a happy, angelic young man who seems almost disturbingly innocent and open. Lazzaro sees the best in everyone, no matter their motives, which makes him easy to manipulate, as does the de Luna family's devious son, Tancredi, who enlists his eager help in faking his own kidnapping. This brings in the Police, which causes panic in the de Luna family, since share cropping had been legally abolished years earlier, and the Marquis Alfonsino de Luna is brought to trial, the family having their land taken away from them, having exploited their workers for decades. Everything seems to be resolved, until Lazzaro accidentally falls off a cliff…

Years pass. Those who were sharecroppers and land workers are now living in the city, although none of the seem to be better off.

Lazzaro awakes from what should have been a fatal fall, but not only is he not dead but he hasn't aged a day, or changed in any way, still having the same breezy, optimistic attitude, whereas everybody else has aged a decade. He agains meets Tancredi, now a man in his fifties, with a greying ponytail, living in greatly reduced circumstances since his family lost their estate. Tancredi again seems friendly and welcoming toward Lazzaro, and persuades him to go to the local bank, demanding they returns the family's assets, convincing Lazzaro they have been seized illegally. He enters the bank and demands the bank release the de Luca's property, and when the staff ask if he is armed, Lazzaro replies he is…

Production

Director
Alice Rohrwacher
Producer
Carlo Cresto-Dina, Gregory Gajos, Arthur Hallereau, Alexandra Henochsberg, Pierre-François Piet, Tiziana Soudani, Michel Merkt, Viola Fugen and Michael Weber
Art Director
Emita Fragato
Editor
Nelly Quettier
Music
Karol Mossakowski
Screenplay
Alice Rohrwacher, the story of Antonia is inspired by San Francesco E Il Lupo / Saint Francis And The Wolf, written by Chiara Frugoni and illustrated by Felice Feltracco
Director of Photography
Héléne Louvart

Review

The third feature from young Italian filmmaker Alice Rohrwacher, coming after Corpo Celeste / Heavenly Body ('11), and Le Meraviglie / The Wonders ('14), which controversially won the Jury Grand Prize at the 2014 Cannes Film Festival, having severely divided critics. This third effort, having been in development for several years, showed at the 2018 Cannes fest, and it would be fair to say that it largely baffled a good number of the scribes, some finding it to be a fable, others a bizarre comedy, and with a few finding it just undefinable.

Shot, for the first half, in some beautiful parts of the Italian countryside around Milan and Turin, with the town of Bagnoregio being the main location, the main character, Lazzaro (Adriano Tardiolo in his feature debut), is described by more than one character as 'a saint', and it seem clear, with his sunny attitude, unflagging optimism and contented demeanour, that he's very different from the rest of the populace around the small town of Inviolata, which tellingly translates in English as 'inviolate', or protected from injury or damage. Almost everybody in the area works as sharecroppers on the tobacco estate run by the wealthy and ruthless Marchessa Alfonsina de Luna (Roberto Begnini's longtime partner and muse Nicoletta Braschi), their intense loathing being mutual, but despite the backbreaking work, hard conditions and the Marchessa's obvious detestation of those she sees as peasants, but Lazzaro faces this with the same, rather creepy attitude, even falling in with the de Luna's lazy and despised son, Tancredi, helping him stage his own kidnapping, the event which eventually brings down the de Lunas and has their estate forfeited. What would seem to be a happy ending is barely halfway through the film, and the story's complete lurch into an Italian form of 'magic realism' comes when Lazzaro, who inconveniently fell off a cliff decades earlier and was believed dead, returns, unblemished, unsullied and not having aged a day, unlike the rest of the villagers, who are now in various forms of destitution, living on the outskirts of the city and scratching a living through various scams. He meets up again with the fifty-something Tancredi (played as an adult by Tommaso Ragno - L'Uomo Privato / Pandemia), and once more is drawn into one of his illegal money-making schemes.

Several critics compared Tardiolo's Lazzaro, the name being unsurprisingly the Italian equivalent of Lazarus, to Peter Sellers' Chauncey Gardner in Being There ('79), essentially a simpleton whose words and deeds are misunderstood by the supposedly intelligent to be deep and profound, when he is essentially a cheerful idiot, or the 'holy fool' of history, but of course that doesn't explains the second half of the film, or indeed his 'miraculous' return. Indeed, while getting some superb reviews, some critics admitted everything from bemusement to bafflement, The Village Voice saying the film has ' …genuine sweep and grandeur, and Rohrwacher's most impressive feat here might be her ability to find just the right narrative and emotional distance for each section of the story, as it moves from rustic drama to picaresque journey to more pointed social allegory; we're always given just enough information to understand and appreciate the characters' interactions and motivations', while The Guardian believed 'With Happy as Lazzaro, Rohrwacher has crafted a magic-realist fable that doubles as an origin myth for a modern Italy subsumed by corruption and decline'. The Hollywood Reporter found 'The main problem of Happy as Lazzaro is that it's unclear what Rohrwacher finally wants to say in part two, which combines the near-documentary realism of her first feature with the occasional flights of fancy of her second', while, like several others, The Wrap noted the 128 minute running time - 'If you can surrender to her peculiar vision, its beauty is undeniable; if not, impatience may set in long before the film winds down just past the two-hour mark'.