Film details

Suspiria  2018

Suspiria: Six Acts and an Epilogue Set in a Divided Berlin

Cast

  • Dakota Johnson
  • Mia Goth
  • Chloë Grace Moretz
  • Jessica Harper
  • Renée Soutendjik
  • Sylvie Testud
  • Angela Winkler
  • Ingrid Caven
  • Malgorzata Bela
  • Vanda Capriolo
  • 'Lutz Ebersdorf' (Tilda Swinton)

Synopsis

2018 became the year of the iconic horror sequel / remake, with David Gordon Green tackling the relaunch of Halloween through Blumhouse Pictures, the original John Carpenter pic celebrating its fortieth anniversary while the Italian release of Dario Argento's Suspiria was a year earlier. Ironically Green was originally set to helm this remake when the project was first announced over a decade ago, with the setting being switched to an American High School, losing most of the dance and balletic elements, and rumoured to have a dark secret other than a coven of witches to be the core of the plot. That version, luckily, never came to pass, but it was certainly unexpected when Luca Guadagnino, coming off the huge acclaim for 2017's Call Me By Your Name, was announced as the helmer of this Italian / US remake, shot in Berlin and with the Grand Hotel Campo dei Fiori in Varese standing in for the central location of the dance Academy itself, and, just for good measure, a good 75% of the film's dialogue is in German, but subtitled with inventive, often blood-red Gothic-font captions.

The approach Guadagnino takes almost seems to perversely be the opposite of what Argento did with the original in every aspect. A languorous running time of 152 minutes instead of the tightly-packed 97 of the '77 version; 35mm photography by Sayombhu Mukdeeprom which seems to mostly have a flat, dry colour palette of muted greys and blues, without primary colours, instead of Luciano Tovoli's eye-searing three-strip Technicolor vistas, and Goblin's tremendous score, with its earworm of a central motif, is replaced with Thom Yorke's noodling which, after some light, looped arpeggios in the early sequences, has definite echoes of Fabio Frizzi's work for City Of The Living Dead and The Beyond. And then there is the performance in the lead male role of 'Lutz Ebersdorf ', who turns out to be Tilda Swinton, playing one of her three roles in the film, under extremely heavy latex work designed by Mark Coulier, which is generally extremely convincing, only giving away it's prosthetic nature in some scenes shot outdoors under supposed natural sunlight. Of course having an actor under a pseudonym in an Argento-related project is not new. Who could forget the enigmatic 'Byron Deidra' from Argento's own benighted Giallo? (Oh? Seemingly everybody).

Skeptics may say that Guadagnino's film is unsaveably pretentious from the credits onwards, with the title of the film being presented on screen in a clever / tumid way, delete as desired, and at times the whole production seems to be almost an in-joke between himself and Swinton. The pair have been constant collaborators since 2009's I Am Love, followed by 2015's A Bigger Splash, but here her Madame Blanc (the imperious Joan Bennett in the original) appears at time to be a parody of a New Age hippy-dippy guru, until one realises that Swinton is being perfectly serious as she recites the borderline gibberish the screenplay by David Kajganich (The Invasion / TV's The Terror) puts in the character's thin-lipped mouth, and one could cruelly say Madame Blanc is almost written as a parody of Swinton herself. She is more effective as Klemperer simply because 'he' has the better scenes and less risible dialogue, but for her third role in the film, it truly could be anybody under a metric tonne of prosthetics which make the character looks like a horror version of The Thing from Fantastic Four.

While so much seems to be almost unpalatably self-indulgent on behalf of the director and lead, some of the film works remarkably well, the opening scene, with American student Patricia (Chloë Grace Moretz - Let Me In) bursting into Klemperer's office in near-hysteria, making claims that the matrons of the Academy are trying to kill her, and defile her body. She leaves but forgets to take with her a book packed with clues, which the psychiatrist starts to try to decipher, and the main performances, from Dakota Johnson, having swapped the hell of the Fifty Shades series for this one, and Mia Goth (A Cure For Wellness) as the doomed Sara, are strong, in a 98% female cast which includes such arthouse favourites as Angela Winkler (The Lost Honour Of Katharina Blum), Ingrid Caven (Malou), Sylvie Testud (La Vie Un Rose) and Renée Soutendijk (The Fourth Man), and it's a pleasure to see Jessica Harper back in the remake of the film which made her a genre icon, as brief as her cameo is, but the whole never manages to live up to the promise of Moretz's vivid, impassioned scene.

Apart from a clever and gruelling death scene, where a rebellious student is smashed and broken against walls and mirrors as her body replicates dance moves performed by Susie in another studio, Guadagnino, again in a calculated move to separate it from it's source, otherwise avoids any particularly gory or violent set-pieces, and certainly nothing as memorable as the '77 version's first murder, one of the true classics of horror cinema. His finale, set in the basement / crypt of the Academy indeed has exploding heads and erupting throats galore, but the director almost retreats from this by bathing the gory action in a seemingly post-production deep red wash, and adding not only another twist, totally altering Susie's character, but also a bizarre, and needless, coda as well as a shot seeming to promise / threaten the return of one of the main characters.

One can understand the filmmaker not wanting to make a carbon copy of the unique original, or even attempting to, but this 'remake' lays so many false trails that it becomes unsatisfying as so many subplots either go nowhere or are just left dangling, the seeming political angles (and did the Academy literally have to be ten feet from the Berlin Wall?) of the divided city, the violence of the Baader-Meinhof Gang and what seems to be the awakening of some ancient evil, as well as the country's Nazi past, are quickly dispensed with.

Suspiria 2018 is certainly ambitious, even though it shares really very little with the Argento film, as if taking a polar opposite stance on all aspects of production, although anyone who knows the original might probably be interested in seeing this version, but as for Guadagnino and Swinton it might be healthy for the couple to take a break from each other for a while and start seeing other people, for everybody's sake.

Production

Director
Luca Guadagnino
Producer
Brad Fischer, Luca Guadagnino, David Kajganich, Francesco Melzi d'Eril, Marco Morabito, Gabriele Moratti, William Sherak and Silvia Venturini Fendi
Art Director
Merlin Ortner and Monica Sallustio
Editor
Walter Fasano
Music
Thom Yorke
Screenplay
David Kajganich, based on the screenplay of the 1977 film Suspiria, written by Dario Argento and Daria Nicolodi
Director of Photography
Sayombhu Mukdeeprom

Review

Luca Guadagnino's bold, hypnotic reimagining of Dario Argento's 1977 horror classic, set in a divided Berlin in 1977, is a dense, disturbing and visually extraordinary film, with Tilda Swinton in several roles and a haunting score by Thom Yorke. Critics were sharply divided: some hailed it as a masterpiece, others found it pretentious and overlong.