The Marvellous Mabel Normand 1913-27
Cast
-
(<i>Mabel's Dramatic Career</i>)
-
Mabel Normand
-
Mack Sennett
-
Alice Davenport
-
(<i>Mabel's Blunder</i>)
-
Mabel Normand
-
Harry McCoy
-
Charley Chase
-
(<i>His Trysting Place</i>)
-
Charles Chaplin
-
Mabel Normand
-
Mack Swain
-
(<i>Should Men Walk Home?</i>)
-
Mabel Normand
-
Oliver Hardy
-
Creighton Hale
Synopsis
Mabel's Blunder - Mabel is engaged to Harry, the son of the Boss of a major company, but the Boss also has an eye for Mabel too, a situation which leads to mistaken identities and confused relationships involving not only Mabel, Harry and the Boss, but also Harry's friend Billy Bronx, The Bos's's business associate, Mabel's brother and Harry's sister.
His Trysting Place - After meeting in a restaurant for a meal, Charlie and his good friend Ambrose accidentally leave with each other's coats. Charlie was going to pick up a bottle for a baby while Ambrose was planning to post a love letter that he was carrying in his coat pocket. Charlie's wife finds the letter and starts to believe he has a secret lover, while Ambrose's wife his horrified to think he has an illegitimate child. In the park Charlie and his wife and Ambrose and his wife confront their respective husbands before everything is explained, but Charlie manages to throw everything into turmoil again by showing Ambrose's wife the love letter that was in his pocket.
Should Men Walk Home? - Two successful jewel thieves, a Girl Bandit and a Gentleman Crook, crash a society party, trying to avoid the completely inept detective on their trail.
Production
- Director
- (<i>Mabel's Dramatic Career</i>) Mack Sennett, (<i>Mabel's Blunder</i>) Mabel Normand, (<i>His Trysting Place</i>) Charles Chaplin, (<i>Should Men Walk Home?</i>) Leo McCarey
- Producer
- (<i>Mabel's Dramatic Career</i> / <i>Mabel's Blunder</i>/ <i>His Trysting Place</i>) Mack Sennett, (<i>Should Men Walk Home?</i>) Hal Roach
- Editor
- (His Trysting Place) Charles Chaplin (uncredited), (Should Men Walk Home?) Richard C. Currier
- Music
- The Meg Morley Trio (new score)
- Screenplay
- (Mabel's Blunder) Mabel Normand, (His Trysting Place) Charles Chaplin, (Should Men Walk Home?) Albert Austin and Alf Goulding, titles by H.M. Walker
- Director of Photography
- (His Trysting Place) Frank D. Williams, (Should Men Walk Home?) Floyd Jackman
Review
The four shorts here, preserved in the BFI National Archive, comprise Mabel's Dramatic Career (1913), Mabel's Blunder (19'14), His Trysting Place (19'14), and Should Men Walk Home? ('1927), her penultimate screen appearance, which also features a small role for a young Oliver Hardy, backed by a new score from The Meg Morley Trio. Her films ranged from the slapstick style of the Mack Sennett movies, many believing she was the first performer on film to actually receive the trademark pie-in-the-face, appearing several times with the Keystone Kops, to more subtle work, but she was a very watchable performer, often scene-stealing from the male stars, and working on a string of huge successes with virtually all the big names of the period, ranging from making twelve films with Chaplin, His Trysting Place being more of a Chaplin vehicle than a Mabel Normand film, and Roscoe 'Fatty' Arbuckle, making seventeen films together, to Charley Chase, Mack Swain and frequent co-star Ford Sterling.
Indeed she was credited with saving the career of Charlie Chaplin after Mack Sennett was considering releasing him from his first contract after his first appearance in a film, Making A Living ('1914), severely disappointed Sennett, who felt he over-acted terribly, had little personality on screen and wasn''t suited for cinema, Normand persuading Sennett to persevere with him.
Sadly, and through no fault of her own, her name became associated with scandal through the 1920s, being linked with the 1922 murder of director William Desmond Taylor, an enduring Hollywood mystery, and in the 1924 shooting of millionaire oil broker Courtland S. Dines, who was shot and wounded by Normand's chauffeur, Joe Kelly, using her pistol, although she was never considered a suspect in either crime. In addition the scandals involving Roscoe Arbuckle after the death of an aspiring actress at a party in Arbuckle's hotel suite in September 1921, and the subsequent legal actions, he eventually being acquitted after three trials, meant that for a long period of time the films they made together, often believed to be some of their best work, were withdrawn from distribution. Such events affected Mabel's career and in 1923 she suffered a recurrence of the tuberculosis which had plagued her, hastening her retirement from films and eventually causing her death in 1930 at the age of just 37.
Four shorts running just 78 minutes doesn''t really do justice to a fine performer and her range of work, but as an introduction to Mabel Normand and her films this is a good jumping-off point and there's a wealth of quite brilliant comedies to be tracked down and enjoyed. (Incidentally she is the 'Mabel' in the Broadway musical Mack And Mabel, which premiered in 1974, she originally being played by stage star Bernadette Peters, the plot revolving around a completely fictionalised romance between Mack Sennett and Normand, highly unlikely as Sennett was largely believed to have been gay.