Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil and Vile 2019
Cast
-
Zac Efron
-
Lily Collins
-
Jim Parsons
-
-
Haley Joel Osment
-
-
Dylan Baker
-
Terry Kinney
-
Angela Sarafyan
-
Jeffrey Donovan
-
Grace Victoria Cox
-
James Hetfield
Synopsis
1974. Ted is reported to have been on a street corner shouting racist comments about Jamaicans. Several young woman in Washington and Oregon have disappeared, including two from Lake Sammamish State Park in broad daylight. A man was seen asking several young woman to help him load a sailboat onto a Volkswagen, and the description of the man generates a composite picture of the suspect which is very close to Ted. It is released to the media and hundreds of phone call flood in. Ted is arrested the following year, Liz having seen the news reports.
Carol DaRonch, who managed to escape an abduction attempt by a violent kidnapper, immediately picks Ted out of a police lineup of eight men. Despite this, Ted is released on bail. He returns home to Liz, who is visibly upset, but claims that the Police illegally showed Carol DaRonch his picture before the lineup, Ted telling her he believes the Police are trying to frame him for the killings. The case goes to trial, where he is found guilty of attempted abduction and given a sentence of one to fifteen years in Utah State Prison.
1975. A few weeks into his sentence, he is charged with murder by Colorado authorities and transferred to Aspen. Liz refuses to believe he is guilty, not believing he is capable of the horrific killings, torture and mutilation with which he is accused, but the worry causes her to start drinking heavily. On trial at the Pitkin County Courthouse in Aspen, Ted, who claims to have previously studied law, not saying he was a poor, inattentive student who quickly changed college courses, elects to defend himself, and is allowed not to be handcuffed or shackled in the courtroom. During a recess he escapes by jumping from a second storey window and running into the mountains. A manhunt is organised and he is recaptured after six days on the run. Liz ends her relationship with him, but he escapes again, sawing through the ceiling in his cell ceiling. Two women at a sorority house on the Florida State University campus are horrifically murdered and mutilated, followed by ruthlessly vicious attacks on two more, Ted is arrested after a routine traffic stop checking licences. He tries to contact Liz but she hangs the phone up on him.
Bundy starts to receive dozens of letters from women, some claiming they love him, just as Carole Ann Boone, an old friend who is convinced of his innocence, reappears in Ted's life. Bundy is offered a plea deal, life imprisonment without parole in exchange for his full confession, instead of the death penalty, but his vanity will not permit him admit to being guilty. Bundy rejects the deal.
He is eventually found guilty and sentenced to death in July 1979, Judge Edward Cowart calling his crimes 'Extremely wicked, shockingly evil and vile'. But Liz is still not convinced he is the reviled killer everyone seems to believe, so arranges one last visit, demanding Ted tell her the truth….
Production
- Director
- Joe Berlinger
- Producer
- Nicolas Chartier, Michael Costigan, Ara Keshishian and Michael Simkin
- Art Director
- Matt Hyland
- Editor
- Josh Schaeffer
- Music
- Marco Beltrami and Dennis Smith
- Screenplay
- Michael Werwie, based on the book The Phantom Prince: My Life With Ted Bundy by Elizabeth Kendall
- Director of Photography
- Brandon Trost
Review
Berlinger's films obviously initiated the appeal which led to the three accused boys being released, but also showed the deeply dubious prosecution which had them imprisoned in the first place, and the incredible lengths the West Memphis judiciary went to to try to keep them in jail, even after their innocence was proved. Although one can see the appeal of telling the story from another angle, from that of Bundy's partner, Liz Kendall (Lily Collins - Love, Rosie / Tolkien), who, at least as seen here, always believed in Bundy's innocence, what is a surprise is that Berlinger, so rigorous in pursuing the painful truth in the Paradise Lost series, directs a script by Michael Werwie, based on Liz Kendall's book, which very definitely plays fast and loose with the truth on several occasions, yet stranger since Berlinger was also in production with a four-part documentary series, Conversations With A KIller: The Ted Bundy Tapes, at the same time as shooting the feature. Certain events in the relationship between the undeniably good-looking Bundy, played here by former Disney teen heartthrob Zac Efron, and Liz Kendell, are re-jigged in time, or invented altogether for dramatic purposes, particularly towards the end of the story where the need for dramatic confrontations seem to have overtaken the veracity of the events.
What Berlinger has also made is the most restrained version of the Bundy tale. Where as the Harmon version was confined by TV network standards, and other retellings, such as Matthew Bright's unpalatably tasteless Bundy ('02) have treated it as everything from an all-out slasher story to hideous black comedy, here by choosing another point-of-view keeps the carnage mostly off-screen, only finally being revealed in detail in the final 1979 court case, and in a couple of final flashbacks, showing just what the man was capable of, a reminder of just how brutal Bundy really was, but for most of the film he is seen as a persistent but almost petty offender, managing to get out of police custody with surprising ease, and while Lily Collins makes Liz a sympathetic character, seeing her get ever more fretful and alarmed, when the audience knows exactly what is going on off-screen, gets repetitive.
What Berlinger has on his side is a strong supporting cast, including The Big Bang Theory''s Jim Parsons as Florida Prosecutor Larry Simpson, Kaya Scodelario (The Maze Runner series / TV's Skins) as Carole Ann Boone, the woman Bundy eventually married, the aforementioned Malkovich, the dependable Dylan Baker (Revolutionary Road / TV's The Americans) as Prosecutor David Yocom, and the always watchable Terry Kinney (TV's Oz / Billions).
Most critics praised the performances, but perhaps questioned the approach, IndieWire caling it '"More sad than salacious, it's the rare film about a criminal that offers human details without humanising a man who so many agree was a monster"', and The Hollywood Reporter believing 'It''s quite a story, which Berlinger moves along with unrelenting energy'. But The A.V. Club found '"Dramatically speaking, it''s a failed thought experiment - you get, watching it, why no one has really told this kind of story in this way. But it's still hard not to admire the film's perversely un-perverse strategy, its good-faith attempt to do something more than simply trot out the awful, salacious details', and The Guardian finding 'It''s a star vehicle that starts and ends with its star, the film around him struggling to justify its existence. Efron is wicked, the film less so'.