Film details

A Hidden Life  2019

Radegund

Cast

  • August Diehl
  • Valerie Pachner
  • Bruno Ganz
  • Matthias Schoenaerts
  • Michael Nyqvist
  • Jürgen Prochnow
  • Alexander Fehling
  • Franz Rogowski
  • Martin Wuttke
  • Max Mauff
  • Karl Markovics
  • Tobias Moretti
  • Ulrich Matthes

Synopsis

A Hidden Life, a German language production telling the true story of Austrian farmer and wartime conscientious objector Franz Jägerstätter, indicates a change in the string of Terrence Malick films which have appeared sporadically over the past decade or so, but unlike his most recent, Knight Of Cups ('15) and Song To Song ('17), both of which had degrees of improvisation, and at times very obviously in the latter, which resulted in the performances of some major cast members, including Christian Bale, Benicio del Toro, Haley Bennett, Boyd Holbrook and several more, being entirely cut from the finished film, Malick said during a very rare Q&A that he had ' …gone back to working with a much tighter script'.

But certain Malick elements never change. DoP Jörg Widmer, better known as a camera operator on Malick's more recent work as well as a veteran Stedicam operator, captures the Alpine beauty of the region, with locations all over Austria's South Tyrol, and there are many, many scenes of Franz (August Diehl - The Counterfeiters / Inglourious Basterds) and his wife, Fran (Valerie Pachner - All My Loving / The Ground Beneath My Feet) tending their land in the sort of beautifully calibrated half-light which is almost a Malick cliché, and it is largely this pastoral middle section, between Franz's two periods of military enrolment, which take A Hidden Life to a running time of 173 minutes. As is usual with the filmmaker's productions these days the actual schedule was also extraordinarily extended, with shooting happening in summer 2016, and a post-production schedule of nearly three years, and indeed the post-work was so extended that the film became the final screen appearances of both Michael Nyqvist, who died in June 2017, and the superb Bruno Ganz, who passed away in February '19.

Jägerstätter was a real person, a conscientious objector who was eventually executed by the Nazis for refusing to fight in World War Two, and while his story is not widely known, it was retold in an Austrian TV movie entitled Verweigerung / The Refusal ('71), and a short documentary, Franz Jägerstätter: A Man Of Conscience, debuted in 2011. The religious undertones of many of Malick's films are much more prominent here. Indeed he followed A Hidden Life with The Lost Planet, a film dramatising several vignettes in Christ's life, so the intention is clear from the beginning, a battle between a man's life and a man's faith, and the script makes it perfectly obvious which Franz will choose. He was repeatedly offered the chance to save himself from prison, and eventually save his own life, by simply signing the oath of loyalty, the Austrian authorities going so far as to promise him non-combatant work, to comply with his anti-violence beliefs, once released, but to Franz that would be betrayal, both of God and himself, and the outcome is inevitable, Ganz's scenes as the reluctant Judge, passing the sentence of execution, being powerful simply because he realises the futility of the argument on both sides.

Malick has a number of familiar European actors in the cast, including Matthias Schoenaerts (Rust And Bone / Red Sparrow), Jürgen Prochnow (Das Boot / The Da Vinci Code), Alexander Fehling (The Captain / TV's Homeland) and Franz Rogowski (Transit / Undine), and as ever the technical qualities of the pic are unimpeachable, but while it took the Catholic Church until October 2007 to beatify, but some believed Malick's film does it from the very beginning.

As usual the film received a divided reception, very much divided between the devoted fans and the unconvinced, The Playlist raving 'The Tree of Life spanned eons to capture the entirety of existence, and while the filmmaker works on a tighter four-year canvas this time around, the feeling that the stakes are nothing less than the soul of all humanity has persisted. This is art of salvation' and Variety believing 'Whether or not he is specifically referring to the present day, its demagogues, and the way certain evangelicals have once again sold out their core values for political advantage, A Hidden Life feels stunningly relevant as it thrusts this problem into the light', while The AV Club suspected 'Maybe Malick has committed so hard to his own principles, artistic as well as ideological, that he's lost his grasp on drama. I'd love to see him step out of the church he's built around his work and give us the world again, with or without a script', and The Hollywood Reporter bemoaning 'Unfortunately, instead of embracing the weighty moral, religious and political components of the story, Malick has alternately deflected and minimized them'.

Production

Director
Terrence Malick
Producer
Elisabeth Bentley, Dario Bergesio, Grant Hill and Josh Jeter
Art Director
Steve Summersgill (supervisor)
Editor
Rehman Nizar Ali, Sebastian Jones and Joe Gleason
Music
James Newton Howard
Screenplay
Terrence Malick, inspired by the book Franz Jägerstätter: Letters And Writings From Prison, edited by Erna Putz
Director of Photography
Jörg Widmer