The Personal History of David Copperfield 2019
Cast
-
Dev Patel
-
-
Peter Capaldi
-
Paul Whitehouse
-
-
-
Aneurin Barnard
-
Daisy May Cooper
-
Ben Whishaw
-
Morfydd Clark
-
Gwendoline Christie
-
Anna Maxwell Martin
-
Rosalind Eleazar
-
Bronagh Gallagher
-
Anthony Welsh
Synopsis
After the often brutal and profane political comedies of In The Loop and The Death Of Stalin, and TV's The Thick Of It and Veep, writer Armando Iannucci takes a huge detour into the world of Charles Dickens, his eighth novel, with varying results, in The Personal History Of David Copperfield, an amazingly loose and interpretive version of the novel, first published in serial form between 1849-50, 624 pages in all, and one of the lesser-produced Dickens works, being brought to the screen far fewer times than such staples as Great Expectations or Oliver Twist, the first of three silent versions being in 1911, then 1913 and '22, and the first sound version coming in '35, directed by George Cukor and starring W.C. Fields as Mr. Micawber, and regarded to be one of the best adaptations, followed by two more film versions ('69 and 2000), and five TV serials, of which the '74 BBC version running more than five hours over six episodes is the standout, and even two animated retellings, an Australian production in '83, and a musical NBC version ten years later. Partly this is because of the structure of the novel, essentially a selection of vignettes rather than having any linear plot, and Iannucci is quoted as saying 'The story is the least interesting part', and to get over the problem the writers, Iannucci and Simon Blackwell (TV's Peep Show / The Armstrong And Miller Show), essentially restructure the whole thing, and give events which happen in the book to different characters, trying to form some sort of spine, which nevertheless often takes some sharp sudden narrative turns in the telling of the scattershot story. In the book some of the major characters, such as Betsey Trotwood, Mr. Micawber or Uriah Heep, vanish for literally hundreds of pages, only to reappear when it's convenient to move the story in a different direction, and when some people claim that Dickens is a 'difficult read' one suspects that David Copperfield is the volume of his they have chosen to begin with.
The pic often magnifies the wild tonal swings in the original work, from utter poverty and despair to the occasionally forced whimsy and jollity of the more moneyed, or at least, settled classes, but without any of the genuinely serious stabs at the complacency of the middle and upper levels of society of the time, largely managing to ignore the staggering, heartbreaking poverty just outside their brocaded windows, Dickens not being afraid to ruthlessly use the death of characters to emphasise how perilous, and completely without a safety net, this era was. Oscar Wilde may have been quoted in a letter to a friend as saying 'One must have a heart of stone to read the death of little Nell without laughing', but that says rather more about Wilde than Dickens, the demise of the character in A Christmas Carol being the pivotal serious moment in the book. Here Iannucci uses one of the plot's pivotal moments, the death of a major character, as both a catalyst and more prominently a joke, quickly returning the film to business as usual, penduluming between despair and ebullience, until some melodramatic twists before the happy-ever-after ending.
In the middle of all this some characters and actors are unfortunately short-changed, purely because of the sheer number of roles and the utter 'Dickenianism' of it all, such as Paul Whitehouse (TV's The One Show) as the ebullient Mr. Peggotty, tirelessly joyous and upbeat at all times, which is dispiriting in itself, and the excellent Ben Whishaw (Daniel Craig's Q) as the unctuous Uriah Heep is unable to do much for a character written as such a grovelling creep and then pretty flimsy villain, eventually utterly destroyed by little more than a stern talking-to. But there are also striking performances, although some from characters who only have limited screen time. Patel as David is an amiable if not entirely reliable narrator; Peter Capaldi (the Twelfth Doctor) as the borderline tragic Mr. Micawber, always waiting for something to turn up; Daisy May Cooper (TV's This Country) as the warmhearted Mrs. Peggoty; Morfydd Clark (TV's His Dark Materials) as the dotty Dora Spenlow, and a quite superb turn from Hugh Laurie (TV's House) as the gentle, intelligent but quite bonkers Mr. Dick. As Betsey Trotwood one can only imagine that we'll eventually find out what Tilda Swinton actually is when others from her alien race return to Earth to reclaim her. Iannuci's lauded 'colour-blind' casting has some advantages, such as the spot-on casting of Patel and a brilliant performance from Benedict Wong (Dr. Strange) as the amiable and bibulous Mr. Wickfield, but is also at times baffling, making the viewer wonder if Mrs. Steerforth, played by Nikki Amuka-Bird (A Private War), could possibly have a son so, sorry to say, milk-white and pasty as James (Aneurin Barnard - Dunkirk).
Ironically the film's sense of period is better when out in the country, at locations such as the Trotwood house or the Peggotty's at Yarmouth, rather than trying to add a sense of scale with rather obviously CGI-enhanced docks and docksides, although one generally sees the city in teeming close-up, giving the impression of a busy, jam-packed maze of streets, alleys, back yards and cut-throughs, the budget presumably never quite stretching to a full, populated cityscape, The result is one of the more family-friendly offerings Innaucci has ever been involved with, he once having a BBC Radio series ironically entitled Armando Iannucci's Charm Offensive, and while this third feature film is made with obvious love and care, and that remarkable cast, one suspects the writer / director many be more comfortable with comedies which usually end with a body count and a full swear-box.
And while Iannucci uses one of the more correct titles for his film, rather than the shortened David Copperfield, Dickens went through as many as fifteen, one of which being The Personal History, Adventures, Experience and Observation of David Copperfield the Younger of Blunderstone Rookery (Which He Never Meant to Publish on Any Account), which you'd only get on a book spine in very small print.
Production
- Director
- Armando Iannucci
- Producer
- Kevin Loader and Armando Iannucci
- Art Director
- Nick Dent (supervisor)
- Editor
- Mick Audsley and Peter Lambert
- Music
- Christopher Willis
- Screenplay
- Armando Iannucci and Simon Blackwell, based on the novel by Charles Dickens
- Director of Photography
- Zac Nicholson