Film details

The Truth  2019

La Vérité / La Vérité De Catherine / The Truth About Catherine

Cast

Synopsis

The first non-Japanese project from the superb writer / director Hirokazu Kore-eda, whose poignant but sharp Manbiki Kazoku / Shoplifters won the Foreign Language Oscar in 2018, this French / English language drama was interestingly originally announced under the title La Vérité De Catherine / The Truth About Catherine, either a Freudian slip or a case of the man character having her name changed, since it is pretty clear that Kore-eda's script is quite unapologetically based on Deneuve herself, who in recent years has absolutely embraced the Grande Dame role, unapologetic about her aloof and diva-ish behaviour, stories of which are plentiful, and quite shamelessly trading on her career, fame, reputation and past glories in order to get away with it. In many more ways than the obvious, Kore-eda's film is the most high-profile of his career, which includes such superb observational dramas as Dare Mo Shiranai / Nobody Knows; Soshite Chichi Ni Naru / Like Father, Like Son, and Umimachi Diary / Our Little Sister, but also shows adherence by dealing with his familiar theme of familial bonds and responsibilities, as difficult and sometimes tortured as they may be.

Interestingly the script is adapted from a stage play Kore-eda wrote, but which has never been performed, and one can expect that to change some time in the future, but one can see it as a stage production, with it's limited cast and the few detours outside Fabienne's house, such as the film studio, being easily rewritten and relocated.

'I'd prefer to have been a bad mother and a bad friend but a good actress', Fabienne states at one point, and it perfectly matches Deneuve's performance, which Kore-eda admits he largely wrote for her, and there are certainly parallels with her own life, her relationship with her actual daughter, Chiara Mastroianni, being famously turbulent, although in the script Binoche's Lumir went so far as to move to the States in order to get out of her mother's smothering grip, and amid the tensions and complications there is a very telling and perhaps acutely painful strand, the death of her friend and screen rival, Sarah, for which Fabienne is said to have not shown any remorse or sympathy, an uneasy parallel to the death in real life of Deneuve's own sister, fellow actress Françoise Dorléac, in a car accident in 1967, and which some said Deneuve faced with the same detachment and dispassion.

But it isn't a depressing film. Fabianne is a fascinating if borderline monstrous creation, and the responses to her memoir, amusingly entitled The Truth, range from exasperation, as her long-time manager finds he has been written out of her story completely, to initial disbelief as Lumir reads a version of her life which bears very little resemblance to what actually happened, she very quickly realising that the entire book has purely been written to show her mother in the best possible light and edit out the more inconvenient and less flattering episodes of her life.

The Truth is very much a love letter to its star, or more over her immaculate image, several critic noting that Deneuve is never seen as anything less than perfectly coiffured and dressed, even seeming to wake up first thing in the morning without so much as a hair or an eyelash out of place, and Kore-eda knows better than to twist the knife, although many would believe that Fabienne deserves the opprobrium of those she has either offended, insulted or simply ignored over the decades, and while the project was apparently instigated by Juliette Binoche, who has a fascinating habit of working with directors making their first films outside their native countries, such as Abbas Kiarostami and Hou Hsiao-Hsien, but the film fits very well into Kore-ede's warm and humane CV.

The filmmaker has always been an arthouse favourite, and the reviews generally reflected this, The Wrap calling it '… a fascinating exploration of the fallibility of memory and of how the truths we tell ourselves so frequently outweigh an empirical certainty', and Variety noting 'From first shot to last, it's a film of high wit and confidence and verve, an astonishingly fluid and accomplished act of boundary-leaping'. IndieWire advised 'This wise and diaphanous little drama finds Kore-eda once again exploring his usual obsessions, as the man behind the likes of Still Walking and After the Storm offers yet another insightful look at the underlying fabric of a modern family'. The Playlist found 'There's the potential for melodrama, but despite the misleadingly grandiose title, The Truth is not in the business of the grand, tormented revelation. Instead, it's an accretion of little moments, often very funny, sometimes a little sad, but always embedded in the reality of these sharply drawn, idiosyncratic characters'.

Production

Director
Hirokazu Kore-eda
Producer
Muriel Merlin
Art Director
Riton Dupire-Clément
Editor
Hirokazu Kore-eda
Music
Alexeï Aïgui
Screenplay
Hirokazu Kore-eda, adapted by Léa Le Dimna, based on Kore-eda's unproduced stage play
Director of Photography
Eric Gautier