Cast
-
George MacKay
-
Essie Davis
-
Nicholas Hoult
-
Charlie Hunnam
-
-
Thomasin Harcourt McKenzie
-
Jacob Collins-Levy
-
Claudia Karvan
-
Earl Cave
-
Sean Keenan
-
Harry Greenwood
-
Jillian Nguyen
Synopsis
Even since Peter Carey's novel The True History Of The Kelly Gang won the Booker Prize in 2001 a film version has been pending, passing through the hands of various filmmakers, and the fact that it took nearly two decades to reach the screen may tip one off to the problems involved with transposing Carey's admittedly highly speculative and interpretive version of the real events of a comparatively short period in the late 1800s into a coherent script. Now directed by Justin Kurzel (Snowfall / Assassin's Creed) from a screenplay by Shaun Grant (Berlin Syndrome), one of the first things on the screen is a caption which belies the film's title, in saying 'Nothing you are about to see is true', just as Kelly himself (George MacKay - 1917 / Ophelia) narrates, insisting everything he is about to tell us is actually the truth. so the viewer is already warned that this will be tapping into the more fanciful side of the story of a family of robbers, thugs and killers who, through time and intentional myth-making, have become folk heroes.
In many ways Kelly has become the Australian Robin Hood - a folk figure, seen by many as holding the same values as the Lincoln green-clad archer in taking from the rich and giving to the poor, although the reality was rather different, and as with Hood while the very bare bones of the story are true, so much myth and legend has been spun into the fabric of the story as to now become virtual fantasy, the bushranger bandit Kelly and his gang being vicious killers who somehow captured the imagination of some of the populace who sided with them against the hardline and often iniquitous rule of law of the day, and even the iconic armour Kelly wore was a late invention, for what would prove to be his final shootout with the Police in June 1880, and was what led to his downfall, since the Police knew shooting at his encased head and body would be useless they aimed for his completely unprotected legs, a basic schoolboy error on the behalf of Kelly.
Carey's novel was criticised for several purely invented episodes and characters, including adding several lovers and having Ned father a number of children, a completely imaginary plot thread, and indeed Ned was not known to have been involved in any lasting relationships with women, which in Kurzal's film has screenwriter Grant interpret this as having him unsure of his sexuality, and seeming to cast him as a furtive bisexual and occasional crossdresser, even though the entire narrative is framed as a letter being written by Ned for his (eventually imaginary) unborn child.
Essie Davis, star of the superb The Babadook and not incidentally Mrs. Justin Kurzel, drew most praise as the driven Ellen Kelly, trying to both raise her family against what she sees as ruthless harassment and intimidation from the forces of law, while Russell Crowe as bushranger Harry Power resembles the few existing pictures of the infamous robber, and plays him very much as the surrogate father the young Ned is searching for, rather than a ruthless criminal who would eventually be imprisoned in 1870, previously having escaped from jail while serving ten years, and was not released until 1885, when he was 66 years old. Several critics noted that George McKay seemed rather slight and literally lightweight for the role, the real Kelly being described as well-built, as he would need be to eventually don the heavy iron armour, and not quite as imposing or charismatic as the bandit was described to be.
Oddly the film only received a limited release in Australia, even as reviews were mixed but generally positive, The Hollywood Reporter finding 'The Robin Hood-like renegade hero of the Antipodean common man, Ned Kelly gets a ripping reinvention in director Justin Kurzel's feverish punk Western, a raw rebel yell of a movie that combines visceral violence with a kind of delirious, scrappy poetry'. But other critics were more taken with the visuals rather than anything else, The Wrap noting 'There is a terrible majesty to the landscape and to the story, and Kurzel gives it room to breathe', while Screen Daily believing 'While the emotional intensity and somewhat protracted narrative can be exhausting, in visual terms the film is a tour de force, steeped in blood, dust and squalor', The Guardian adding 'It is a very gruelling spectacle, often brilliant, sometimes slightly redundant and perhaps not able to maintain the storytelling rush of its first act. But it is always weirdly plausible in its pure strangeness and in the oddly poignant moments'. IndieWire decided 'The movie hovers in a curious paradox, coming across as both operatic tribute and horrific condemnation, but it's never less than a nasty crime drama with plenty of grimy characters to keep the stakes compelling throughout'.
What is bizarre is the grip the character has over the Aussie psyche, being the subject of at least eight different stage plays and two stage musicals, a number of novels and scholarly essays, and what is recognised as the world's first feature-length narrative film, The History Of The Kelly Gang was made In Australia in 1906 (although only 17 of its estimated 70 minute runtime still exists), the first of at least twenty film and TV re-tellings of the story, including the infamous 1972 misfire which starred Mick Jagger in the title role, and Kurzel's version comes only sixteen years after the late Heath Ledger's portrayal in Ned Kelly ('03), another attempt which played fast and loose with the facts, and was another financial failure, but as long as the character retains his strange mystical grasp on the Antipodean imagination, films and TV programmes about the unrepentant murderer will continue to be made.
Production
- Director
- Justin Kurzel
- Producer
- Hal Vogel, Liz Watts, Paul Ranford and Justin Kurzel
- Art Director
- Janie Parker
- Editor
- Nick Fenton
- Music
- Jed Kurzel
- Screenplay
- Shaun Grant, based on the novel by Peter Carey
- Director of Photography
- Ari Wegner