Film details

The Two Popes  2019

I Due Papi / Dos Papas / The Pope

Cast

  • Juan Minujin
  • Federico Torre
  • Sidney Cole
  • Pablo Trimarchi
  • Thomas D. Williams
  • Maria Ucedo
  • Juan Miguel Arias
  • Lisandro Fiks
  • Matthew T. Reynolds
  • Fabricio Martin

Synopsis

Directed by Brazilian helmer Fernando Meirelles (City Of God / The Constant Gardener) and written by scripter Anthony McCarten (The Theory of Everything / Darkest Hour), The Two Popes has two powerful actors in the title roles, the first being Anthony Hopkins as Joseph Ratzinger, Pope Benedict XVI, and Jonathan Pryce as Argentinian Cardinal-Archbishop Jorge Mario Bergoglio, who would eventually become Pope Francis in 2013, and the film makes it clear that it is entirely speculative, the two men probably having met, almost certainly when they were in the lower ranks of the Vatican enclave, but the events of Meirelles' film are fictional, instead being the framework for is almost a two-man show, as the two very different characters, one a hardline conservative traditionalist and the other a more liberal pragmatist, discuss matters of duty, devotion, faith and responsibility, both intelligently and entertainingly.

Both men are carrying their own forms of guilt, Ratzinger with the responsibility of having to oversee the Catholic Church's investigation into decades, or more honestly centuries, of child abuse, and Bergoglio with the guilt of not having spoken out against the ruling junta when his country was under military jurisdiction, and his fellow Jesuits were targeted under the widespread bracket of 'political dissidents'. The incumbent Pope summons the Cardinal from Buenos Aires, and his ineptitude with modern technology is amusingly seen when he tries to book a plane ticket over the phone and coming up against a automated voice menu, and he believes he is being summoned to Rome to explain his desire to retire from the position of Cardinal and to return to be an ordinary parish priest, only to find himself being sounded out by the Pope, who tells him that he is going to do something which has not happened in nearly eight centuries, that a serving Pope will step down, and he wants to assess, through some serious and diverse conversations, whether Bergoglio should be his successor.

The casting is astute, Hopkins, 82 years old at the time of filming, gives Ratzinger a fearsome strength of character within an increasingly frail body, and one has to remember that Hopkins' first major film role, as Richard The Lionheart in The Lion In Winter was as far back as 1968, while Pryce, ten years younger than his co-star and whose film roles have been interspersed with his very active stage and TV career, is also a excellent choice as the quiet but also quietly charismatic Argentinian, fighting both guilt and self doubt. Adding to the authenticity is the remarkable recreation of the Vatican, the location for 90% of the pic, on specially constructed sets at Cinécitta Studios in Rome including a striking recreation of the Sistine Chapel, which, with authenticity of the opulent robes and Papal robes and accessories, and location shooting in Argentina and Spain, shows the serious budget producers Netflix were willing to put into a prestige production such as this, but what many critics noted was that the dialogues between the two seemed completely convincing, although they are entirely invented. Whether talking about faith or football, McCarten's dialogue and arguments came over as persuasive.

Despite being made for the streamer, Meirelles' film received some of the most rapturous reviews of '19, many focusing on the lead pairing, The Wrap saying 'What makes The Two Popes so delightful, other than the very funny script, is watching two seasoned actors play off each other for two hours. Both Hopkins and Pryce illustrate what the craft of acting is really about', The Hollywood Reporter adding 'Anchored by two outstanding performances from Anthony Hopkins and Jonathan Pryce, the film is a triumph of writing as well as unostentatious filmmaking'. Variety noted 'While its subject may be religious, The Two Popes doesn't want to convert the viewer. Rather, as an extraordinary piece of writing - and an even more impressive showcase for its actors - it eloquently communicates the importance of giving people something to believe in', with Screen Daily adding 'The delicate dance between the two veteran actors, both eagerly devouring a late-life jewel of a script, is a joy to behold'. The Globe and Mail (Toronto) observed 'It is extremely difficult to make something as invisible and ineffable as religious faith seem real, let alone touching, on film; doing that is only one of the achievements of Fernando Meirelles' unusual look inside the papacy'. One of the few less than entirely convinced were Film Threat, saying 'The two actors are bound to be showered with awards, as is the production design, the polished script, etc. But there's no intrigue, no real substance beneath all the gloss'.

Production

Director
Fernando Meirelles
Producer
Tracey Seaward
Art Director
Saverio Sammali
Editor
Fernando Stutz
Music
Bryce Dessner
Screenplay
Anthony McCarten, based on his own stage play The Pope
Director of Photography
César Charlone