Film details

The Good Liar  2019

Das Alte Böse

Cast

  • Russell Tovey
  • Jim Carter
  • Mark Lewis Jones
  • Jóhannes Haukur Jóhannesson
  • Lily Dodsworth-Evans
  • Stella Stocker
  • Daniel Betts
  • Lucian Msamati
  • Laurie Davidson
  • Phil Dunster

Synopsis

One can imagine why Oscar-winning writer / director Bill Condon (Dreamgirls / Chicago) was drawn to The Good Liar, adapted from the novel by Nicholas Searle, since the pairing of veterans Ian McKellen, as a roguish and surprisingly ruthless con artist, and Helen Mirren, playing Betty, a recently bereaved and wealthy widow who comes into Roy's sights as one of his 'marks', or intended victims, seeing the two play off against each other, as well as being his third collaboration with McKellen after Gods And Monsters (1998) and Mr. Holmes ('15), and lunch on-set must have been a quite superb place to pick up the latest gossip.

Shot in both London and Berlin, the finished pic proves that some plots are easier to accept on the page rather than on film, the script by Jeffrey Hatcher (Stage Beauty / The Duchess) adapting the book's twist upon twist upon twist, as well as two lengthy flashbacks, firstly in 1948 and then back to 1943, and also asks the audience to believe that veteran conman and career criminal Roy wouldn't spot the clues which most viewers will pick up on, and hasn't actually done his homework on his intended mark. And anybody who has ever travelled on the Bakerloo Line will be amused by the idea that the platforms at Charing Cross tube station are apparently not only entirely deserted at lunchtime, but are also only covered by one CCTV camera.

The very precise setting of the pic, 2009, is pertinent, since the character of Roy, as the viewer will discover, could not have been born any later than 1925, making him at least 84 years old, with McKellen being 79 at time of filming, and Roy isn't only targeting former Oxford academic Betty, but, with his partner Vincent (Jim Carter - Shakespeare In Love / TV's Downton Abbey), also drawing in victims of a fake investment scheme which is genuinely one of the oldest con games known, which makes it all the more surprising that it still manages to draw in some unsuspecting investors but the plot does require the characters to do some rather unexpected things, such as Betty and Roy going to Berlin for a romantic weekend, with Betty's grandson, Steven (Russell Tovey - TV's Being Human / Him & Her), in tow.

Although this sounds almost a genteel and twisty thriller, Condon isn't afraid to add sudden flashes of unexpected violence, and one character's eventual fate, being a victim of said violence, is certainly entirely deserved. The leads are certainly having fun, McKellen gradually turning Roy from a crotchety con man into a truly heartless and vicious character, despite his advancing years, and Mirren's Betty, living out her retirement in a suburban cottage, is also a character with hidden aspects.

The good reviews the film received largely focused on the leads, Variety finding 'The pleasure of The Good Liar, and it's a major one, is the chance to watch Mirren and McKellen act together in a cat-and-mouse duet that turns into an elegant waltz of affection and deception', and The San Francisco Chronicle saying 'The back and forth, the listening and reacting between Mirren and McKellen, as each of their characters gauges the other and as we mark the incremental shifts and exchanges of power, is pure pleasure'. IndieWire noted 'Pleasant and preposterous in almost precisely equal measure, the film never offers anything less than two all-time British actors having the time of their lives, which makes it hard to get frustrated that it seldom offers anything more'. Bot otherwise it received a less genial reception, The Globe And Mail (Toronto) calling it 'A con-artist movie that is something of a con itself', and The Wrap observed the film '…really wants to be either a thriller or a caper. Unfortunately, it has neither the excitement necessary for the former nor the fun required of the latter'. For The Telegraph, 'The film's twists, alas, fall into one of two categories - the obvious and the tasteless - and the side-orders of gruesome violence feel like they've been delivered to quite the wrong table'.

Production

Director
Bill Condon
Producer
Bill Condon and Greg Yolen
Art Director
Vicki Stevenson (supervisor)
Editor
Virginia Katz
Music
Carter Burwell
Screenplay
Jeffrey Hatcher, based on the novel by Nicholas Spade
Director of Photography
Tobias A. Schliessler