Mr. Jones 2019
Cast
-
James Norton
-
Vanessa Kirby
-
Peter Sarsgaard
-
Joseph Mawle
-
-
Fenella Woolgar
-
Celyn Jones
-
Krzysztof Pieczynski
-
Martin Bishop
-
Martin Hugh Henley
-
John Edmondson
-
Marcin Czarnik
Synopsis
The films of Polish director Agnieszka Holland often have a hard and serious political edge, such as Oscar-nominated Europa Europa ('90) and In Darkness ('11), and Mr. Jones tells a quite remarkable true story, that of Welsh reporter Gareth Jones (James Norton - TV's Happy Valley / McMafia), who was not only the first foreign reporter to interview Adolf Hitler just days after he became German Chancellor in 1933, Joseph Goebbels being another prominent Nazi on the same flight, but also had an ambition to interview Josef Stalin, as Stalin's own controversial five-year development plan was being reported as having incredible effects on Russia's previously badly ailing economy, backed by extraordinary modernisation and infrastructure schemes, all of which seemed far too good to be true, which is what piqued Jones' interest. Of course, it was far too good to be true, and Jones exposed the horror of the Holodomor, the man-made famine imposed on the region by Stalin, and which eventually claimed at least three and a half to four million lives, and was probably responsible for several millions more in legacy birth defects and illnesses.
One can see Jones as a pioneer in investigative reportage, his interest piqued simply through his, and others, disbelief at the seeming miracle being shown in the turnaround of the moribund Russian economy, but no one in the West seemed to have an idea about what was going on, with hints that those in government who had heard unsettling rumours turned a blind eye rather than offend Stalin, at the time seen as a valuable if basically untrustworthy ally.
Holland's film almost splits into two halves, the first dealing with an array of characters and locations, from Wales to London and Moscow, where correspondents such as the louche and duplicitous Walter Duranty (Peter Sarsgaard - Shattered Glass / Black Mass) have uncomfortably chummy connections to the Kremlin, Duranty also throwing decidedly decadent and extravagant parties which Russian official attend, but once Jones arrives in Ukraine the tone and style change dramatically to show the dichotomy of the two worlds Jones now inhabits. Much of the colour is drained from the photography by Tomasz Naumiuk (Amok / High Life), the score by Antoni Komasa-Ćazarkiewicz (Warsaw '44 / Spoor) almost vanishes entirely, and the whole aspect darkens, with the crunch of boots on snow and the relentless wind being all that is heard for extended periods.
Filmed largely in Poland and Ukraine, with Edinburgh, bizarrely, standing in for London, and Kraków for Moscow, Holland has a strong cast playing who were largely genuine characters, with Vanessa Kirby (Mission: Impossible - Fallout / TV's The Crown) as Ada Brooks, Joseph Mawle (The Hollow / TV's Ripper Street) as Blair / Orwell, and the always watchable Kenneth Cranham (Valkyrie / TV's Rome) as Lloyd George.Originally shown with a running time of 140 minutes in festivals such as the Berlinale and London and now pared back to 119, most critics found there was still extraneous material, notably the inclusion of Blair / Orwell, although he did acknowledge Jones' work as being instrumental in writing Animal Farm, and the relationship between Jones and Ada Brooks was also seen by some to be largely pointless, and slowed down the first half of the story, The Observer noting 'A subplot about George Orwell is perhaps surplus to requirements, but otherwise the film is a striking, efficient political thriller, with Time Out echoing 'If a subplot showing Orwell writing Animal Farm as he becomes persuaded by Jones's evidence doesn't entirely work, there's plenty in this thoughtful journalism drama that does. And not a single scene in a car park'. Holland's film received other strong reviews, The Guardian believing 'Mr Jones is a bold and heartfelt movie with a real Lean-ian sweep', Screen Daily believing 'With a cast impressively headed by James Norton, and cinematography that captures the bleakness of winter and deprivation to grimly palatable effect, Holland's drama comes across in part as a meticulously mounted, sometimes solemn history lesson', and Variety adding 'As drama, Mr. Jones sometimes struggles to get out of its own way, but its message still lands with concrete force'. IndieWire were not so convinced, saying 'Mr. Jones is stymied by the clarity of its hero's crusade. Exasperatingly scattershot for most of its long running time, this restless and misshapen film suggests its director's nagging discomfort with a straightforward history lesson'.
Holland's film is a fitting if sombre and chill tribute to a great and brave man, but if one wonders why Gareth Jones isn't better known, one should look up the rest of his story, which unfortunately has a genuinely tragic ending.
Production
- Director
- Agnieszka Holland
- Producer
- Klaudia Smieja, Andrea Chalupa and Stanislaw Dziedzic
- Art Director
- Fiona Gavin
- Editor
- Michal Czarnecki
- Music
- Antoni Komasa-Ćazarkiewicz
- Screenplay
- Andrea Chalupa
- Director of Photography
- Tomasz Naumiuk