Film details

Cape Fear  1991

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Imprisoned for the rape and battery of a 16-year-old girl, Max Cady discovers his defence lawyer, Sam Bowden, suppressed a report on the victim's promiscuity which might have helped reduce the sentence. Released after 14 years, Cady tracks down Sam and starts harassing his family, scornfully dismissing Sam's offer of money to go away. When the family dog is poisoned, Sam goes to the police, who apart from arresting Cady and strip searching him, can do little else. Then Cady picks up Sam's mistress from a bar and violently rapes her; however despite Sam's urging, she refuses to press charges as she doesn't want to undergo the trauma of cross-examination. Fearing that his own wife, Leigh, may be next, he hires a private detective, Claude Kersek, to track Cady down and warn him off, but Cady once more shrugs off the warnings. After Cady shows the vulnerability of Sam's teenage daughter by luring her to the school theatre by posing as her drama teacher, Sam decides to take Kersek's advice, and hires some thugs to beat Cady up, but the ex-con easily sees them off. Sam approaches criminal lawyer Lee Heller to get a restraining order on Cady, but finds his rival has beaten him to it but hiring Heller to take a restraining order out on 'him'. When an attempt to get rid of Cady by luring him to his booby-trapped home goes badly wrong, Sam escapes with his family to their houseboat at Cape Fear, intending to get away from it all until the police catch Cady, but is unaware Cady has secretly come along for the ride.

Production

Director
Martin Scorsese
Producer
Barbara De Fina (uncredited - and Robert De Niro)
Art Director
Jack G. Taylor Jr
Editor
Thelma Schoonmaker
Music
Adapted from the original score by Bernard Herrmann by Elmer Bernstein
Screenplay
Wesley Strick, based on a screenplay by James R. Webb, and the novel ÔThe Executioners' by John D. MacDonald
Director of Photography
Freddie Francis

Review

A remake of the 1962 suspense pic directed by J. Lee Thompson, Martin Scorsese makes a generally good job of ramping up Cape Fear, adding a couple of angles to the original screenplay by Wesley Strick, based on the original script by James R. Webb, making both protagonists rather less cut and dried than in the admittedly tense and spare original. As the lawyer Sam Bowden, played so well by Gregory Peck in the original, Sam is here not quite the dashing crusader always on the side of right, being a womaniser whose peccadillos have nearly ended his marriage to the already resentful Leigh (Jessica Lange), while Robert DeNiro's Max Cady is a far obvious threat than that posed by Robert Mitchum in the first, being a swaggering, Hawaiian-shirt wearing boor and loudmouth with an ever present cheap cigar, but one knows that there is real danger behind this bluff and bluster, and that the Bowdens are going to be the centre of his very unwanted attentions. Some of Scorsese's additions, such as this blurring of the characters, Cady having been the victim of a miscarriage of justice instigated by his own lawyer, even though he was guilty, and De Niro's Cady is genuinely scary, the scene where he reveals his tattooed body, tellingly with huge scales of justice across his back, weighing truth and justice, being very effective. Unfortunately Scorsese doesn't always know when to stop, the notorious scene of Cady attacking the young clerk Lori (an early role for Illeana Douglas - Grace Of My Heart), is either utterly horrific or ridiculously over-the-top depending on your point of view, and while the film builds to an undeniably tense and effective ending on a houseboat the Bowdens have hired, cut adrift by Cady during a storm and sailing towards possible doom, would be all the more effective were it not for a bizarre coda to the set-piece with De Niro's Cady, who also quotes Bible scriptures, slowly sinking beneath the waves while speaking in tongues, another bizarre reference to religion in a Scorsese film which really should have hit the cutting-room floor. Although it really doesn't work quite as effectively as the first version, which was a smaller, tighter pic, and twenty-three minutes shorter than this version, mostly because it is oddly difficult to sympathise with Nolte's Bowden, there is a lot of talent on both sides of the camera, with the late Freddie Francis acting as DoP, and the model work at the climax, as opposed to CGI, is brilliantly staged and filmed. Interestingly three of the stars of the first film, Gregory Peck, Robert Mitchum and Martin Balsam, are reunited here in small roles. Certainly effective, and Juliette Lewis is extremely good in a pivotal role, showing that beneath that occasionally scarily eccentric exterior there's a good actress, Cape Fear still delivers, but the original did it with more economy, and with less graphic violence and borderline hysteria.