Film details

The Turning  2020

Cast

  • Mackenzie Davis
  • Finn Wolfhard
  • Brooklynn Prince
  • Barbara Marten
  • Niall Greig Fulton
  • Denna Thomsen
  • Kim Adis
  • Darlene Garr
  • Karen Egan Uncredited
  • Mark Huberman Uncredited

Synopsis

Henry James' original novella The Turn Of The Screw, first published in 1898, has been a popular and highly admired novel, and one which is also interesting in its ambiguity, raising questions as to whether the narrative can be trusted, and if there is indeed a supernatural element to the increasingly unsettling events happening in Bly House. It has also been adapted for the screen and stage a number of times, in several different interpretations, with several stage versions, an acclaimed opera by Benjamin Britten in 1954, and a 1999 ballet, as well as a number of films, the most notable being Jack Clayton's The Innocents ('61), and Michael Winner's surprisingly intriguing and effective prequel The Nightcomers ('72), as well as versions as diverse as Eloy de la Iglesia's Spanish-language Otra Vuelta De Tuerca ('85); Rusty Lemorande's 60's-set take ('92); Walter Lima Jr.'s Brazilian Através da Sombra / Through the Shadow ('16), and at least a dozen TV versions, including a 1959 American adaptation directed by John Frankenheimer and starring Ingrid Bergman; a 1974 adaptation directed by Dan Curtis; The Haunting Of Helen Walker ('95), directed by Tom McLoughlin, and an impressive 2009 BBC film starring Michelle Dockery and Sue Johnston.

In addition, Alejandro Amenabar's superb 2001 production, Los Otros / The Others, starring Nicole Kidman, can very much be seen as a 'reversal' of James' original story.

This 2020 version had more than a few obstacles in the way of making it to the screen, first announced under the title Haunted in early 2016, to be directed by Juan Carlos Fresnadillo (Intacto / 28 Weeks Later) and executive produced by Steven Spielberg, with Alfre Woodward and Rose Leslie attached, until radical script changes to the screenplay by Carey and Chad Hayes (House Of Wax remake / The Conjuring series) made by Scott Z. Burns (Contagion / Side Effects) in autumn '16, caused Spielberg to pull the plug, saying the changes altered the original project too much. It was restarted in late 2017, with Italian director Floria Sigismondi, only her second feature after 2010's The Runaways, in a career of nearly thirty years, mostly spent making shorts and pop videos, and a new screenplay by Jade Bartlett, based on the Hayes' script and closer to the original concept, although interestingly Bartlett isn't credited on the finished print. Production started in Ireland in February 2018, ending in early April, with an opening date of February 2019 which was later changed to January 2020.

Sigismondi's film changes the location to North America from England, although this was largely filmed in Ireland, and the time period to the early 1990s, a period increasingly used by filmmakers to avoid plot-ruining devices such as cell phones and the internet, allowing characters to be what can termed as information-isolated. Given that the material has been adapted so many times, and is so familiar to so many, the screenplay does actually makes some changes, which may infuriate the purists, shifting character traits and having different fates befall certain characters, at least adding an element of uncertainty to those who already know the story but retains the basics, as Kate Mandell (Mackenzie Davis - Terminator: Dark Fury / Blade Runner 2049), the character being unnamed in the original story, being appointed as the tutor to an orphaned seven-year-old, Flora (Brooklynn Prince - The Florida Project), in an imposing estate, after the disappearance of her predecessor, Miss Jessell, Flora being joined by her older brother, Miles (Finn Wolfhard - It / TV's Stranger Things), arriving from boarding school, and with Kate, with the help and hindrance of the stern housekeeper Mrs. Grose (Barbara Marten - TV's Casualty / Public Enemies), realising there is more going on in Bly House than she has been told. A major subplot is added in that Kate has problems with her own mentally unstable mother (an underused Joely Richardson - Red Sparrow / TV's Nip/Tuck), and fears that her instability might be hereditary, further muddying the story so one is uncertain if there is indeed any ghostly goings-on, or is it perhaps just Kate's own fears and paranoid, until the film makes the previously suggested rather more concrete, and just to cover all options, throws in multiple endings, almost to cover all eventualities.

Reviews were decidedly mixed, with The Chicago Tribune believing 'It may not work for everyone, but those for whom it works will find much to savor and puzzle over in The Turning', while The Wrap noted 'The Turning is not a total loss. There are some stylish, nearly giallo-like sequences and sensitive performances from both Wolfhard and Prince, both of whom look like they could go further with their roles if the script didn't eventually limit them to reactions in the second half'.This version of an old, old story won't please James' purists, but will probably satisfy the casual viewer, throwing in a number of jump scares of varying effectiveness, and Davis and Richardson together have impressive if limited screen time, but the project's troubled production seems to result in a number of very obvious compromises.

Production

Director
Floria Sigismondi
Producer
Roy Lee and Scott Bernstein
Art Director
Nigel Pollack (supervisor)
Editor
Duwayne Dunham and Glenn Garland
Music
Nathan Barr
Screenplay
Carey Hayes, Chad Hayes and Jade Bartlett, based on the novel The Turn Of The Screw by Henry James
Director of Photography
David Ungaro

Review

Floria Sigismondi's stylish, atmospheric updating of Henry James's The Turn of the Screw builds an unsettling mood, with a strong, physically demanding performance from Mackenzie Davis and eerie turns from Brooklynn Prince and Finn Wolfhard. But its imagery grows repetitive, it only scratches the surface of its themes, and its abrupt ending was widely criticised.