Film details

Inheritance  2020

Cast

  • Lily Collins
  • Connie Nielsen
  • Patrick Warburton
  • Chace Crawford
  • Michael Beach
  • Marque Richardson
  • Rebecca Adams
  • Alec James
  • Joe Herrera
  • Lucas Alexander Ayoub
  • Mariyah Francis

Synopsis

2008. In New York City, Archer Monroe, hedge fund tycoon and the patriarch of the wealthy and powerful politically connected Monroe family, dies suddenly.

His substantial estate is divided among his family, between his wife Catherine; his son William, a politician in a re-election fight, and his daughter, Lauren, District Attorney in Manhattan. Privately, the family attorney, Harold Thewlis, contacts Lauren privately, and gives her a message which her father left with him that reveals a large secret bunker beneath the sprawling family estate. When she goes to investigate the tunnels under the house she is shocked to find a dishevelled, emaciated man being held captive. He tells her his name is Morgan Warner and that he has been held in the bunker for thirty years. Releasing him, she tires to get more information out of Warner but he falls asleep, seemingly exhausted and weak, she takes his fingerprints, sending them to her Police contacts for identification, keeping him in the bunker until she can verify his claims.

Later he tells her that he once was a close friend and business associate of her father, but one night, after a long drinking session, they knocked over and killed a pedestrian while driving drunk. Warner wanted to go to the Police but Monroe insisted on covering up the crime, then taking Warner prisoner and locking him in the bunker to ensure he would not go to the authorities. Over the years of captivity, he says, her father came to him many times, acting as a confessor and telling him of the secret business activities and just how far he was willing to go in the cause of expanding and reinforcing his empire.

Warner tells Lauren where the pedestrian's remains can be found buried. She also follows up what Warner tells her of Sofia Fiore, Archer's longtime mistress and with whom he had a son, as well as evidence that her father paid extensive large bribes in order to get his both herself and William elected to public office.

Realising what her father has done to his former friend, Lauren releases Warner from the bunker, instructing Harold Thewlis to set up an offshore bank account for him and organise a private jet so he can get out of the country and start a new life.

The fingerprint samples are identified and sent back to the Monroe house, but Catherine is the one who takes the delivery, opening the file and being stunned by what she reads, and the sudden appearance of Warner, who, shocked, she addresses as 'Carson', just as Lauren, in her office, receives news that Harold Thewlis has been found brutally murdered….

Production

Director
Vaughn Stein
Producer
Arianne Fraser, Richard Barton Lewis and David Wulf
Art Director
Diane Millet
Editor
Kristi Shiimek
Music
Marlon Espino
Screenplay
Matthew Kennedy
Director of Photography
Michael Merriman

Review

The second feature directed by Vaughn Stein, after Terminal ('18), which also starred Simon Pegg, Inheritance, which boasts an impressive and unexpected cast, also has an equally unexpected screenplay by Matthew Kennedy, his first produced script, which certainly seems to take some if it's inspiration from Dumas' The Count Of Monte Cristo, and by most accounts requires an awful lot of audience goodwill to actually work.

The inheritance of the title would been to be what is left to his daughter, Lauren (Lily Collins – Mirror Mirror / Love, Rosie), after the death of her father, hedge fund magnate Archer Monroe (Patrick Warburton – TV's Family Guy / Rules Of Engagement), largely seen in flashbacks, a man whose ruthlessness both professionally and personally will soon become apparent. But where most inheritances usually include family possessions, the odd bit of treasured jewellery or maybe a property, it's far more unusual to find what is in the cellar of the Monroe family manor, the emaciated, ragged Morgan Warner (Pegg, who lost 12kg in weight for the role, despite never being exactly the most robust physique), apparently imprisoned by her father after a fatal hit-and-run accident years ago. According to Warner her father kept him locked up to avoid him going to the Police with the truth of the accident, and over the years become his confessor, Monroe, for some reason, revealing all the crooked and deeply corrupt business deals he was involved in. One may ask that if Monroe was so morally bereft that he was capable of callously killing someone and covering up the crime without a second thought, yet seemed unable of dispatching the only witness, instead keeping him under lock and key for three decades, but of course that's if one believes Warner's story, which is where the plot gets really convoluted.

One needs almost a cellarful of salt to swallow the direction the plot takes, although some details, such as Lauren and her brother being told they only have the high-ranking positions they now occupy through their father's sizeable bribes, are effective, and the cast is solid, including Chace Crawford (TV's Gossip Girl / Lethal Weapon), Michael Beach (TV's Third Watch / Sons Of Anarchy) and the excellent Connie Nielsen (Gladiator / Wonder Woman), but while Pegg is now a regular big-screen presence in the Star Trek and Mission: Impossible franchises, if sometimes as the rather laboured comic relief, he is less effective in his 'serious' parts, such as playing a hitman in Kill Me Three Times ('14).

Stein's film drew some remarkably divergent opinions, some critics accepting the essential hokiness of the plot and other rejecting it quite vehemently, The Film Stage believing 'Inheritance might have benefited from its third act being a tad subtler, but I get the allure of throwing away nuance for splashy suspense', Screen Rant finding 'Despite great performances from Lily Collins and Simon Pegg, [film] is weighed down by heavy exposition and its overly ambitious story'. Taking a position on the fence were IndieWire, saying 'Though Stein's film doesn't exactly work up to a big surprise, it does unveil some new twists in its final act that hint at better craftsmanship than what was initially on offer', and The Wrap, calling it 'A thriller that wants to be more than that and stretches the bounds of plausibility to get there, Inheritance may have you squirming in your seat and shaking your head in equal measure'. But even though Variety had a firm opinion of the pic, saying 'This overlong tale spends most of its nearly two hours as a somewhat draggy, talky mystery before finally deciding to be a thriller, with credibility lacking throughout', it wasn't as strong as Rolling Stone, which complained 'One adjective you don't hear much anymore is 'preposterous', defined as 'contrary to nature, reason or common sense'. Yet the word applies perfectly to Inheritance, a blithering botch job of a thriller that begs the question: 'Come on, are you f**king kidding me?''