Film details

The Mauritanian  2021

Prisoner 760

Cast

  • Benedict Cumberbatch
  • Tahar Rahim
  • Shailene Woodley
  • Zachery Levi
  • Langley Kirkwood
  • Denis Ménochet
  • Corey Johnson
  • Melissa Hiaden
  • Matthew Marsh
  • Andre Jacobs
  • Saamer Usmani

Synopsis

Mauritania, November 2001. Thirty-year-old Mohamedou Ould Slahi, having returned from years working in Germany, is arrested on suspicion of being involved in the 9/11 attacks on the US and is handled over to the Americans, via Jordan and the CIA's rendition base at Bagram in Afghanistan, and sent to the Guantánamo Bay detention camp, being held without charge.

February 2005. Having had his case taken up by defence attorney Nancy Hollander, a partner in New Mexico law firm Freedman Boyd and Hollander, Slahi is visited at the camp by Hollander and Teri Duncan, her junior associate. Being told Slahi was one of the chief recruiters of the 9/11 hijackers, Lt. Colonel Stuart Couch, a military attorney, is given the task of leading the prosecution. Initially suspicious of Hollander and Duncan and their motives, Slahi eventually starts to trust them, and begins to send them a detailed account of the events which led up to his arrest, including admitting to a short involvement with Al-Qaeda.

As both Hollander and Couch start to prepare their cases, both find their attempts to build a case stymied by the US government, which blocks access to evidence and vital documents, including what they claim is Slahi's signed confession, made in 2003. Slahi claims that, after undergoing civilised and non-aggressive questioning he was handed over to the US Military Intelligence and tortured over a period of seventy days, being forced to drink seawater, being repeated beaten around the head, face, neck and genitals and subjected to a mock execution, with the interrogators claiming they will have his mother arrested, brought to the camp and raped in front of him, and under such pressure he admits to all the charges put towards him.

After years of pressure the documents are finally released to both Hollander and Couch, but after reading his confession, and hearing details such as his deletion of all the contacts on his mobile phone before being arrested, Teri Duncan resigns from the case, saying she no longer believes him to be innocent.

Couch, discovering the truth about how the confession was secured and the extent of the torture, also resigns his position, refusing to stand at the Military Commission and stating 'Slahi's incriminating statements – the core of the government's case – had been taken through torture, rendering them inadmissible under U.S. and international law'.

2009. The case comes to court, with Hollander bringing a writ of habeas corpus for illegal imprisonment, and Judge James Robertson eventually orders Slahi to be released on March 22 2010, but the US government launches an appeal, meaning Slahi has to remain in custody until the appeal is held, and government agencies start to utilise complex legal delaying tactics to ensure he remains behind bars.

Production

Director
Kevin Macdonald
Producer
Benedict Cumberbatch, Adam Ackland, Leah Clarke, Lloyd Levin, Beatriz Levin, Mark Holder, Christine Holder, Branwen Prestwood-Smith and Michael Bronner
Art Director
Christopher Dalberg (supervisor)
Editor
Larry Siems
Music
Tom Hodge
Screenplay
'M.B. Traven' (Michael Bronner), Rory Haines and Sohrab Noshirvani, based on a screen story by 'M.B. Traven' (Michael Bronner), based on the memoir Guantanamo Diary by Mohamedou Ould Slahi
Director of Photography
Alwin H. Kuchler

Review

Directed by Kevin Macdonald, The Mauritanian, based on the true-life ordeal of Mohamedou Ould Slahi, arrested on suspicion of being involved in the 9/11 attacks and sent to Guantánamo Bay, the helmer would seem to be a good choice for the project, being an Oscar-winner documentarist, making the superb One Day In September ('99) and Touching The Void ('03) among others, while his narrative features are more variable, ranging from the vivid and compelling The Last King Of Scotland ('06) to the political drama State Of Play ('09) and the barely-seen thriller Black Sea ('14), but although the focus is the ordeal of Slahi (Tahar Rahim, also seen in Macdonald's 2011 Roman Legion drama The Eagle), more interesting, especially given the uncertainties and inconsistencies in Salani's own account, published in 2015 as Guantanamo Diary, is the clash between defence attorney Nancy Hollander (Jodie Foster – Taxi Driver / The Silence Of The Lambs) and military attorney Lt. Colonel Stuart Couch (Benedict Cumberbatch – 1917 / TV's Sherlock), leading the prosecution, polar opposites in terms of stance, attitude and their approach to their profession, but brought together when the evidence they have both sought is finally presented in one of the film's most effective moments, causing both sides to realise that in many ways they have the same opponent, Hollander on legal and humanitarian grounds whereas Couch is angered by the sheer flouting of the laws he has vowed to uphold.

Adapted by Michael Bronner, Rory Haines and Sohrab Noshirvani, the focus is Slahi, but the drama concerns the two lawyers and their individual efforts to get to what seems to be the truth, despite the obstacles put in front of them by both the Bush and then the Obama administrations, with Bush and his sidekick Donald Rumsfeld being almost proud of their 'enhanced interrogation' techniques, which horrify Hollander, and many Americans, and force Couch to reconsider his position despite having been a loyal servant of the US Armed Forces for years, re-evaluating his years in uniform. Macdonald stages one of the most striking moments in the film, the arrival of a hundred classified document boxes in Hollander's office, only to be found to contain hundreds of thousands of pages on which every single word and line is 'redacted', with a thick black line through them, turning everything into reams and reams of zebra-pattern print, with force and a genuine feeling of both astonishment and dreadful finality.

Tahar Rahim is obviously given the central role, but the elements in his character's story which arguably triggered the whole chain of events, that he deleted all his mobile phone numbers and texts when first approached by the local Police, some vague and inadequate explanations for some of his travels and meetings with known jihadists in both Germany and Afghanistan and his eventual admission that he was indeed a member of Al-Qaeda, although he insists only for a short time, are largely brushed over, but their cumulative effect was to have Hollander's assistant, Teri Duncan (Shailene Woodley – Divergent / TV's Big Little Lies) finally withdraw from the case, purely because she was no longer convinced, after working in his case for a number of years, that he was innocent, an angle of the story the film could have perhaps highlighted a little more.

Foster and Cumberbatch are compelling in the leads, and one can be forgiving to his occasionally shaky Southern accent as the Louisiana-born Couch, although some interesting names in the supporting cast, including Zachery Levi (Shazam! / TV's Chuck) as Federal Agent Neil Buckland, a colleague of Couch, Denis Ménochet (Inglourious Basterds / By The Grace Of God) and Corey Johnson (Captain Phillips / Ex Machina), are given comparatively little to do, and the recreation of the stark and forbidding Guantánamo compound, constructed on the outskirts of Cape Town in South Africa, actual location shooting seemingly being refused, is convincing.

Macdonald's film, shot under the title Prisoner 760, is obviously achingly sincere, and Slahi obviously had a horrendous ordeal over the fourteen years he spent at Guantánamo, but unlike Hollander and Couch, the script never really digs too much below the surface.

(The fact that co-writer and producer Michael Bronner is billed as 'M.B. Traven' appears to be a reference to the pen-name of an author only known as 'B. Traven', the writer in the Twenties of a number of novels including The Treasure Of The Sierra Madre (1927), and who never positively identified, although many literary scholars put forward their own theories over the years, and which appears to be some sort of in-joke).