Film details

Dead Man Walking  1995

Film still

Cast

  • Robert Prosky
  • Raymond J. Barry
  • R. Lee Ermey
  • Celia Weston
  • Lois Smith
  • Scott Wilson
  • Roberta Maxwell
  • Margo Martindale
  • Barton Heyman
  • Steve Boles

Synopsis

Sister Helen Prejean is a sincere and devoted nun, a member of the Sisters of St. Joseph of Medialle, working at the St. Thomas Housing Project in New Orleans, working with some of the poorest people in the city, and also working as a prison visitor to the inmates of the notorious Angola Prison, where some of the state's most sadistic and brutal criminals, rapists, child molesters and murderers are housed. She begins a correspondence with a prisoner on Death Row, Matthew Poncelet, a convicted murderer awaiting execution, and the letters they exchange make Sister Helen start to believe that Matthew may be innocent, or least the victim of a flawed judgment, although he confesses that on the night in question when the crime occurred, both he and his friend, Carl Vitello, had been taking large quantities of drugs, and may not have total recollection of how events occurred. With Poncelet's execution less than a week away, Sister Helen realises it is a race against time in order to get the execution postponed and a new trial ordered, but when the pair start to meet, and she starts to find out more about Matthew Poncelet and his beliefs, she finds herself in a moral and ethical quandary, being determined to save the life of a man who may be a ruthless and utterly remorseless killer, and a genuine danger to anyone he meets.

Production

Director
Tim Robbins
Producer
Jon Kilik, Tim Robbins and Rudd Simmons
Art Director
Tom Warren
Editor
Lisa Zeno Churgin and Ray Hubley
Music
David Robbins
Screenplay
Tim Robbins, based on the book by Sister Helen Prejean C.S.J.
Director of Photography
Roger Deakins

Review

Based on the true story of Sister Helen Prejean, and her relationship with Death Row prisoner Matthew Poncelet, Dead Man Walking, based on Prejean's 1993 bestseller, comes with an obvious agenda, screenwritten and directed by Tim Robbins, coming after his debut feature Bob Roberts, and starring his then-wife Susan Sarandon (White Palace) as Prejean, the film has an obvious anti-death penalty message, the devoted nun wanting to have Poncelet's sentence either postponed or commuted, but also finding herself sympathising with both families when she starts to get both sides of the story of the killing for which Poncelet and his partner-in-crime have been arrested, and as played by Sean Penn (The Falcon And The Snowman) the condemned man is both a figure of pity but also, in Robbins' most dramatic and underplayed moment, reveals more about himself than Prejean realises, altering the balance of the film to an oddly ambivalent one, still taking an anti stance but also facing the realities of just how ruthless and brutal most murders and murderers really are. With the film largely playing out like a stage piece, Dead Man Walking could be a two-hander, most of the major scenes being between the prisoner and the nun, and there is genuine drama, even though the eventual outcome is never really in doubt. Sarandon largely plays the film without any obvious make-up, a brave decision, but also in character, and Penn manages to make his character more believable than the pantomime villain he could become in another actor's hands. Sarandon secured the Best Actress Oscar, while the film was also nominated for best Actor, Director and Original Song, and remains a mature and very well judged piece of work which has considerable emotional power.