Film details

The Next Best Thing  2000

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Abbie is a yoga teacher, running classes in an affluent part of Los Angeles in the early 90s. She is dumped by her boyfriend Kevin and turns for a shoulder to cry on to Robert, her best friend, who is a gardener and gay. She tells him she hoped that she and Kevin would have a baby together. After both attending a funeral the next day, both Abbie and Robert get drunk and fall into bed together. Weeks later Abbie discovers she is pregnant from the one night stand with Robert. She asks him to move in with her and raise the child. He agrees, and becomes father to her son, Sam. They live together happily as a family until six years later, when Abbie meets Ben, an investment banker. They meet for coffee and drinks and are obviously attracted to each other. She brings him home to meet Robert, whom she explains away as a house mate. Robert is openly hostile, especially when Abbie tells him that she and Ben plan to get married. Robert is worried that the presence of Ben will impinge on his relationship with Sam. Ben is offered a job in New York which will mean prestige and promotion. When Abbie says she will come with him he takes the job. Abbie tells Robert that she is moving and taking Sam. Robert hires a lawyer and sues Abbie over the custody of Sam. She tells Robert something she has kept from him for years - that he is not Sam's father. His biological father is actually her ex-boyfriend Kevin. Robert manages to track down Kevin and give him the news. As the court case continues Kevin appears and demands access to his son. As the evidence mounts, the judge tries to sort out some sort of amicable solution.

Production

Director
John Schlesinger
Producer
Tom Rosenberg, Leslie Dixon and Linne Radmin
Art Director
David S. Lazan
Editor
Peter Honess
Music
Gabriel Yared
Screenplay
Thomas Ropelewski
Director of Photography
Elliot Davis

Review

Madonna and Rupert Everett have a hard job convincing us of the plot of this pic, which doesn't know if it wants to be a light frothy comedy of sexual identity or a serious courtroom drama dealing with parental issues, so tries to be both. The pair may be best friends in real life but that doesn't always translate onto the screen. Odd to think that years ago director John Schlesinger was making serious and ground breaking movies revolving around gay themes, including Midnight Cowboy and Sunday Bloody Sunday.