Film details

& Sons  2025

Film still

Cast

  • Noah Jupe
  • George MacKay
  • Johnny Flynn
  • Anna Geislerová
  • Arthur Conti
  • Shalom Brune-Franklin
  • Dominic West

Synopsis

A.N. Dyer is one of the great novelists of his generation, but in old age he has become a recluse, sunk in alcohol and his own sense of importance. For all his command of language, he is hopeless at conversation; he talks at people rather than with them, and he refuses to use the telephone. His teenage son Andy, the child of an affair that wrecked Dyer's marriage, is the one who tries to rouse him from his afternoon stupors.

The news that one of Dyer's oldest friends has died – one of the few people who stood by him as he withdrew from the world – unsettles him. Perhaps sensing his own mortality, he calls his two elder sons home to hear something important.

Richard is a filmmaker and Jamie a visual artist. The brothers are very different in temperament, but they share a deep resentment of their father, especially over the affair that drove their mother, Isabel, away and resulted in Andy's birth. They arrive expecting another dose of their father's narcissism.

What Dyer tells them is far stranger than they could have imagined. His account of Andy's origins involves a dark confession, a scientist with an unlikely speciality and a connection to the legacy of Alfred Nobel, and it would change Andy from an accident into something more like an experiment. The brothers are convinced that their father has lost his mind.

Yet Dyer is a master storyteller, and the question of whether he is confessing or inventing hangs over everything that follows. If he is telling the truth, what does it mean for Andy? As the revelation ripples through the family, old wounds reopen, and Isabel returns to confront her former husband.

The film mixes family melodrama with a touch of speculative science fiction and moments of drawing-room comedy. Argentinian director Pablo Trapero, known for Rolling Family and The Clan, works from a screenplay by Sarah Polley, based on David Gilbert's novel. Bill Nighy plays Dyer, with Noah Jupe, Johnny Flynn, George MacKay and Imelda Staunton.

Production

Director
Pablo Trapero
Producer
Phin Glynn, Axel Kuschevatzky, Cindy Teperman, Pablo Trapero, Christina Piovesan, Emily Kulasa, Trudie Styler, Celine Rattray and Jackie Donohoe
Editor
Pablo Trapero, Gemma Cabello and Thom Smalley
Music
Cristobal Tapia de Veer
Screenplay
Sarah Polley, based on the novel by David Gilbert
Director of Photography
Diego Dussuel

Review

The brilliant but impossible artist father has become a familiar figure in prestige cinema, and Bill Nighy's A.N. Dyer joins a crowded field. The idea at the heart of Pablo Trapero's film is a good one: truth is slippery, and artists are especially well equipped to send the people they love chasing after it. It is a natural subject for Sarah Polley, whose documentary Stories We Tell turned on a revelation about her own parentage.

Because Dyer is a celebrated storyteller, the audience is never sure whether his outlandish explanation of Andy's birth is a confession or a convenient fiction that softens his own bad behaviour. The film poses these questions conscientiously, but without much flair. Trapero has a proven talent for staging family confrontations, as he showed in his Argentinian films, but he never quite overcomes the gimmicky premise. Material like this might have benefited from a cooler, more deadpan approach; Trapero instead leans towards naturalism, skilfully but to the film's cost, and it grows increasingly sluggish as it goes on.

The supporting cast fares well. George MacKay, his eyes permanently wide with disbelief, is a walking double take, and Imelda Staunton energises the film when Isabel comes back to face her former husband. Oddly, the weakest link is the star. In a role that demands a divisive, magnetic patriarch, Nighy is merely adequate, coasting on familiar charm.