Cast
-
Bárbara Lennie
-
Leonardo Sbaraglia
-
Aitana Sánchez-Gijón
-
Victoria Luengo
-
Patrick Criado
-
Milena Smit
-
Quim Gutiérrez
-
-
Carmen Machi
Synopsis
It soon becomes clear that Elsa and Bonifacio belong to a story within a story. They are characters in a script being written by Raúl, an acclaimed writer-director with a shock of silver hair. Raúl has his own devoted partner, Santi, whom he largely takes for granted, and a far closer working relationship with his assistant of many years, Monica.
When Monica tells Raúl that she is quitting to look after a friend whose child is gravely ill, he responds by mining that situation for his screenplay, which he calls Bitter Christmas. In his script, Monica's experience becomes the story of Natalia, a former model and old friend of Elsa's, who is sunk in depression after the death of her child.
Elsa decides to take Natalia to Lanzarote in the hope that the island will help her heal, even though a previous trip there did nothing to repair Elsa's friendship with Patricia, who walked out after a row about her toxic marriage. On the island's dark volcanic sands, the conversations between the women become strange and halting, and the fictional film begins to feel like a draft still being worked on, its connections and characters only half formed.
Meanwhile, the real-world consequences of Raúl's borrowing catch up with him. In the final act, Monica confronts him and sets out, in furious detail, exactly what she thinks is wrong with his screenplay and with the way he has treated the people in his life.
Pedro Almodóvar writes and directs this self-reflexive comedy-drama about the ethics of creative inspiration. Bárbara Lennie, in her first major role for the director, plays Elsa, with Leonardo Sbaraglia as Raúl, Aitana Sánchez-Gijón as Monica, Patrick Criado as Bonifacio, Milena Smit as Natalia, Victoria Luengo as Patricia and Quim Gutiérrez as Santi.
Production
- Director
- Pedro Almodóvar
- Producer
- Agustín Almodóvar
- Art Director
- Isabel Peinado
- Editor
- Teresa Font
- Music
- Alberto Iglesias
- Screenplay
- Pedro Almodóvar
- Director of Photography
- Pau Esteve Birba
Review
The film has two recognisable stand-ins for its director: Elsa, a filmmaker struggling with her muse while leaning on a remarkably attractive boyfriend, and Raúl, who with his silver hair and dubious ethics is perhaps the more honest self-portrait, since he comes out of things worst. Aitana Sánchez-Gijón is terrific as Monica, the assistant whose life is plundered for material.
Once the action moves to Lanzarote, the already flimsy story-within-a-story becomes almost abstract, Almodóvar's trademark bright colours standing out against the black volcanic beaches. Bárbara Lennie is very good as Elsa, but the role is never allowed to become as vivid as those the director has written for Penélope Cruz. A copy of a copy loses its fine detail.
Even so, there is something fascinating about following a story that is visibly a work in progress, its characters practically annotated with notes to the writer. In a sharp finale, Monica lists every flaw in Raúl's screenplay, which happen to be the flaws in Almodóvar's – he is a step ahead of us once again. If this is a warm-up for something more substantial, it is a thoroughly entertaining one.