Cast
-
Daisy Edgar-Jones
-
Esmé Creed-Miles
-
Caitríona Balfe
-
Frank Dillane
-
Herbert Nordrum
-
George MacKay
-
-
Tom Brooke
-
Stacy Martin
-
Chloe Pirrie
Synopsis
Their half-brother John and his grasping wife Fanny take possession of the family home and set about persuading themselves that the late Mr Dashwood's request to provide for his widow and daughters need not be taken too seriously. The Dashwood women leave Sussex for a modest cottage on the Devon estate of a relative, where they are taken under the wing of the warm-hearted but endlessly curious Mrs Jennings, who is determined to find husbands for the girls, and the weather-obsessed but surprisingly perceptive Lady Middleton.
The two eldest sisters could hardly be more different. Elinor is controlled and sensible, quietly in love with Fanny's brother, the gentle Edward Ferrars, but keeping her emotions to herself. Marianne believes in expressing every feeling openly. At a lively country dance she falls headlong for the charming John Willoughby, and their flirtation becomes the talk of the neighbourhood.
When the family's search for security takes the sisters to London, both romances are put to the test. Secrets emerge, hearts are broken and each sister comes to see something of value in the other's way of facing the world. Throughout their trials, the women of the family keep one another going with a private language of glances, smothered laughter and whispered confidences.
Directed by Georgia Oakley, from a screenplay by the Australian novelist Diana Reid, the film moves between the woods of Sussex, the moors of Devon and the noise of London. Daisy Edgar-Jones plays Elinor and Esmé Creed-Miles plays Marianne, with Caitríona Balfe, Frank Dillane as Willoughby, George MacKay as Edward, Fiona Shaw as Mrs Jennings, Tom Brooke and Stacy Martin as John and Fanny, and Chloe Pirrie as Lady Middleton.
Production
- Director
- Georgia Oakley
- Producer
- Tim Bevan, Eric Fellner, India Flint and Jo Wallett
- Editor
- Izabella Curry
- Music
- Roger Goula
- Screenplay
- Diana Reid, based on the novel Sense and Sensibility by Jane Austen
- Director of Photography
- Arnaud Potier
Review
The result is thoughtful and moving, but rather heavy. Tragicomic episodes alternate with gloomy, abstract interludes, the editing lacks the momentum to carry the story forward, and there are rather too many wistful shots of skies glimpsed through leaves.
The supporting cast, however, are a joy. Tom Brooke and Stacy Martin steal every scene as the deliciously nasty John and Fanny, Fiona Shaw is irresistible as Mrs Jennings, and Chloe Pirrie is a delight as the unexpectedly sharp Lady Middleton. Two superbly choreographed dance scenes capture the story's shifts of mood, from the exuberant country dance where Marianne flirts with Willoughby to a London ball charged with Elinor's restrained longing.
The film is at its best when it celebrates the sisters' solidarity in a world where women cannot act on their own desires. Handsome and sincere, if not essential.