Film details

A Talent for Murder  2026

Film still

Cast

  • Alden Ehrenreich
  • Olivia Cooke
  • Juliet Stevenson
  • James Faulkner

Synopsis

It is 1995, and Patricia Highsmith, author of Strangers on a Train and the Ripley novels, is living in seclusion in a house in the Swiss Alps. Now elderly and steeped in alcohol, she shares her home with little more than her grudges. Her literary reputation is secure, her opinions are as abrasive as ever, and there are few people left who would put up with them. What she does have is an unfulfilled contract with her publisher in New York.

The publisher's answer is to send Edward Ridgeway, a young, rather nerdy but articulate literary agent, to visit her. His task is to convince her to resurrect Tom Ripley, the charming con man and killer whose adventures made her famous, for one last novel. On the train through the mountains he strikes up a flirtation with a young woman from a wealthy family with ties to the area, a meeting that will have consequences of its own.

Highsmith receives him with suspicion. She is reluctant to write another book and still less inclined to take instructions from a junior representative of her publisher, but she clearly enjoys having someone to spar with. As a gesture of goodwill, Edward has brought her a custom-made steel knife, a gift that hints at both admiration and menace. Over the course of his stay, their conversation becomes a contest of wills, as Highsmith probes his motives, needles his weaknesses and tests how far he is prepared to go. Edward, meanwhile, displays a smooth charm and a talent for adapting himself that seem alarmingly familiar, as though he had stepped out of the pages of one of her novels. Is he a devoted admirer, an imaginary companion for a lonely woman, or a disciple ready to put her ideas into practice? And is he, or his host, the one in danger?

Joanna Murray-Smith adapts her successful 2014 two-character play Switzerland, opening it out with additional characters and locations. Anton Corbijn, a photographer and director known for Control and A Most Wanted Man, directs, with cinematography by Robbie Ryan. Helen Mirren plays Highsmith, with Alden Ehrenreich as Edward and Olivia Cooke as the heiress he meets on the train.

Production

Director
Anton Corbijn
Producer
Gabrielle Tana, Troy Lum and Andrew Mason
Art Director
Dimitri Capuani
Editor
Andrew Hulme
Music
Chris Chard and Marc Furmie
Screenplay
Joanna Murray-Smith, based on her play Switzerland
Director of Photography
Robbie Ryan

Review

Anton Corbijn's adaptation of Joanna Murray-Smith's play is essentially a variation on the mystery-writer games of Sleuth and Deathtrap, with the fictional author replaced by a real literary legend. Despite Corbijn's reputation as a visual stylist, the film never escapes its theatrical origins; most of the action consists of two people talking in a room.

That is not necessarily a problem, because there are worse ways to spend an evening than watching Helen Mirren devour the scenery as Patricia Highsmith. Whether her performance truly captures the writer's famously exquisite misanthropy or reduces her to a cartoon of a cantankerous recluse is open to debate, but Mirren is never less than compelling. Alden Ehrenreich holds his own as her visitor, in a role that gradually shifts according to the play's metafictional conceit into something like a double part.

The film is knowing and arch, and its cat-and-mouse games are satisfying on their own terms. Its weakness is that it has little new to say about Highsmith or her work; admirers of her novels will find few revelations, although the enthusiasm with which it makes the case for her dark imagination is welcome.

A slender, sinister entertainment that is enjoyable while it lasts, rather than a substantial portrait of a great writer.