Film details
Scum 1979
Still unavailable
Cast
-
-
Phil Daniels
-
Julian Firth
-
Ray Burdis
-
John Judd
-
Mick Ford
-
Bill Dean
-
John Blundell
-
P.H.Moriaty
-
Philip Jackson
-
John Grillo
-
Peter Francis
Synopsis
Carlin, a new inmate at a boy's borstal, soon works out the hierarchy, knowing who he has to take on to become the 'Daddy', the one who runs the wings, the ones the others defer to. Also new to the institution are Archer, an intelligent and philosophical inmate with a studied and detached view of life and of why he is incarcerated, and Davis, a sensitive and vulnerable inmate who is immediately the subject of bullying, and worse, by the others. Carlin, enforcing his claim to being the Daddy with an iron bar, soon asserts his position, while Archer manages to alienate the wardens and guards by making them realise they are as much prisoners as those they are guarding. After Davis has been sexually assaulted, and his obvious mental disintegration goes without comment from the guards, he takes the only form of escape left to him, and commits suicide. His death, and the reaction to it from the Governor and Warders is the spark that ignites a violent riot, but you cannot beat the system...
Production
- Director
- Alan Clarke
- Producer
- Clive Parsons and Davina Belling
- Art Director
- Judith Lang
- Editor
- Mike Bradsell
- Screenplay
- Roy Minton, based on his own television play
- Director of Photography
- Phil Meheux
Review
Notorious for being a film version of a TV play made for the BBC by director Alan Clarke and effectively banned from transmission after it was pulled from the schedules, Scum is undeniably powerful, with a visceral hit, but it is only after viewing that Roy Minton's screenplay can be seen as terribly biased. Ray Winstone, in a career defining turn as the vicious Carlin, is an undoubtedly dangerous and anti-social character, almost certain to become a career criminal, borstal merely being a staging post in his career, but he is the most magnetic character here and is portrayed in an oddly attractive light. The borstal staff, including such reliable actors as Ken Loach regular Bill Dean and P.H.Moriaty, are portrayed almost to a man as either stupid, apathetic or as violent as those they are guarding and a couple of Minton's pivotal moments in the script are just too exaggerated. Would warders turn a blind eye to a young boy being gang-raped, intimating their approval? And an inmate receiving a letter from his family giving him the PS that his wife has died in a handful of words is actually risible. Strong and impactful, but after viewing one realises that balance and plausibility do not rate high in Roy Minton's script.