Film details
Black and White 2002
Still unavailable
Cast
-
-
Charles Dance
-
Kerry Fox
-
Colin Friels
-
Ben Mendelsohn
-
David Ngoombujarra
-
Vincent Ball
-
Max Stewart
-
Bille Brown
-
John Gregg
-
Roy Billing
-
Peter Whitford
Synopsis
A nine year old girl's body is discovered at Ceduna Beach in South Australia in 1958. An autopsy reveals that she was raped before being murdered and Max Stuart, an Aboriginal fairground worker, is soon arrested and charged with the crime despite evidence being flimsy. He signs a confession. Taken to Adelaide for trial, lawyers David O'Sullivan and Helen Devaney are assigned as his defence council. O'Sullivan is not convinced by the confession, believing that Stuart was brutalised into signing it but on interviewing him find he is confrontational and aggressive, traits which will not go down well with either the judge or the jury. The trial is almost perfunctory, slick and efficient prosecuting council Roderic Chamberlain easily managing to secure a guilty verdict. Stuart is sentenced to death by hanging. O'Sullivan is told by Father Tom Dixon, a priest who visits Stuart in prison and who knows the aboriginal language that from what he knows of the tongue the statement is fabricated, an opinion reinforced by a professor of linguistics. O'Sullivan wins a stay of execution and an appeal is launched, but fails. O'Sullivan and Devaney are approached by Rupert Murdoch, the young owner of the local paper, The Adelaide News, who offers his support in protesting Stuart's innocence. The paper, edited by the campaigning Rohan Rivett, starts to run the story as one of injustice and an unsafe prosecution but Roderic Chamberlain is unimpressed by the paper's arguments although, to his annoyance and bemusement, his wife Roma starts to believe the paper may be right. Chamberlain is told by State Premier Thomas Playford that the growing scandal surrounding the case is threatening Chamberlain's ambition of becoming Chief Justice. As a further stay of execution is granted Father Dixon and a reporter from the newspaper quiz the fairground staff to see if they can provide an alibi for stuart while O'Sullivan and Devaney fly to England to ask the Privy Council, responsible for the judiciary in Australia, for another appeal. The request is rejected but Father Dixon finds the required alibi. Rupert Murdoch finds himself arrested on a case of seditious libel. The lawyers manage to have a Royal Commission conviened. Chamberlain finds that there is a serious backlash among the public and Premier Playford tells Chamberlain to inform the commission that the death sentence has been commuted. The guilty verdict remains however, and Max Stuart eventually serves fourteen years in prison.
Production
- Director
- Craig Lahiff
- Producer
- Nik Powell and Helen Leake
- Art Director
- Sarah Gilligan
- Editor
- Lee Smith
- Music
- Cezary Skubiszewski
- Screenplay
- Louis Nowra
- Director of Photography
- Geoffrey Simpson
Review
Nothing is just in black and white, states one of the lawyers defending Aboriginal Max Stuart as he waits for his sentence of execution to be carried out, but in Craig Lahiff's film, based on a genuine case and its outcome, everything is - the lawyers are good and crusading, the prosecution and state officials are bad and, most surprising of all, Rupert Murdoch (yep, that one), is a fearless crusader for the truth, his taking-up of the case being in the interests of justice and not just a cheap sensationalist trick to gain circulation. But one element is omitted from this flattering portrait of a newspaper owner - that only weeks after the case and being cleared of libel, Murdoch fired editor Rohan Rivett who had been the one to bring the case to his notice. Of Max Stuart himself he is virtually sidelined in the film, seen as a victim almost unable to defend or indeed control himself, his memories of having a once promising boxing career being one of the few character insights which are offered. More usually when something has to be said pertaining to Stuart, it is one of the white lawyers who does so and such an attitude, added to the glowing portrait of Murdoch, makes one wonder why someone with such convictions as Robert Carlyle, who has regularly worked with Ken Loach, wished to appear in such a project. Max Stuart himself was released on parole in 1973 but breached the terms five times, eventually being released permanently in 1984. In virtually sidelining him the filmmakers have obliterated the most interesting and certainly the most distinctive character in the whole sad story.