Film details

Gods and Generals  2003

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

As the American Civil War moves towards its commencement in 1861, Robert E.Lee is offered the post of commander of the United States Army, intended to be sent in against rebels in the South. Lee declines until his own home state of Virginia votes for succession from the Union, then he accepts the command of the Confederates. As conflict nears, Thomas 'Stonewall' Jackson is an instructor at the Virginia Military Institute and, seeing that the recruits under his command are not yet battle-ready, becomes an officer and prepares them for fighting Union forces, leading them into the Battle of First Manassas where the Confederate troops seem to be outmanouvered and defeated, until Jackson's tactics rally them, helping them to eventually defeat the Union soldiers. Jackson acquires a black cook, Jim Lewis, who asks him his stance on slavery, which is essentially what the South has taken to fighting in order to retain, but does not get a straight answer from Jackson. As another battle seems set to precipitate at Fredericksburg, next to a river crossing, Professor Joshua Chamberlain, a scholar who has joined the Maine Volunteers, who support the Union, lectures the troops on the lessons to be learned from Julius Caesar's crossing of the Rubicon. With the Confederates having taken the high ground, the Union troops have to cross the river under heavy fire and Chamberlain and his men sustain heavy losses, but after the Feds repeatedly assault their positions, the Union soldiers retreat. Christmas sees Jackson and several of his officers billeted with a Christian family and they spend the holiday singing carols in the lull in fighting, Jackson himself becoming friends with the youngest daughter of the family, but she soon dies of scarlet fever, just before her sixth birthday. While he is away, Jackson's wife, Anna Morrison Jackson, gives birth to their first child. Asked why such a learned man is fighting, Chamberlain defends the Union's part in the War, declaring that as long as the South supports slavery there can never be freedom, and they can never claim to fight for the freedom of the common man. As the War drags on into 1863, General Lee commands Jackson to attack a well-supplied Union position at Chancellorsville. It is a bloody and gruesome battle with thousands of casualties, and one of them is Jackson, accidentally shot by his own men.

Production

Director
Ronald F. Maxwell
Producer
Ronald F. Maxwell
Art Director
Gregory Bolton
Editor
Corky Ehlers
Music
John Frizzell
Screenplay
Ron Maxwell, based on the novel by Jeff Shaara
Director of Photography
Kees Van Oostrum

Review

As having been proved after his epic length Gettysberg, writer and director Ronald F. Maxwell has been justly identified as probably the world's leading living expert on the Civil War, but the fact that Gods and Generals is taken from a novel set during that period and focusing on the role played by 'Stonewall' Jackson rather than actual factual events doesn't excuse such risible and offensive facets such as slaves who are honoured to be the 'property' of their noble masters and who quote from the Bible. As with Gettysburg, which was a laudible effort but became increasingly repetitive and, dare one say it, boring, as it lurched on over its four and a quarter hour running time, (Gods and Generals being a mere three and three-quarters) the film is unashamedly slanted towards the South, despite the despicable reasons why the South rebelled against the North, and the Southerners are portrayed as the victims of the cruel, heartless Union troops, although oddly this virtuous God-fearing idyllic version of the South features no slave traders, or indeed anyone who may interrupt the fantasy. As with Maxwell's previous film the battles are restaged by Civil War reenactment societies, dubious gatherings which they invariably are, and although Stephen Lang reprises his Gettysburg role as Jackson, soon the cast just becomes scene after scene of muddy men with ridiculously bushy beards and moustaches. It has been said that south of the Mason-Dixon line the Civil War has never been declared formally over. That's because of men like Maxwell, and their own, dubious reasons for keeping this macabre rewriting and laundering of events alive.