Film details

Sylvia  2003

Ted and Sylvia
Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Having come to Britain in the mid-Fifties in order to further her studies at Cambridge University, Fulbright scholar Sylvia Plath meets Ted Hughes, an already published and acclaimed poet, Sylvia aspiring to be published herself but having little real faith in her own work. Ted Hughes gives her encouragement after reading some of her verse and the two fall in love, their relationship being intense and all-consuming. Sylvia starts to submit Hughes' work for various poetry competitions and, after winning one, the pair marry. They return to the States where Sylvia has secured a teaching job at Smith College in Massachusetts where she used to study and introduces Ted to her mother Aurelia before enjoying a holiday in Cape Cod, but when Sylvia starts to try to write she finds she is struck with insurmountable writer's block. The term begins and she finds writing no easier but is alarmed by the amount of attention Ted receives from the young female students in the facility, feeling jealousy and frustration which spills over into their home life, causing vicious, spite-tongued arguments. They agree that to ease Sylvia's fears they will return to England and once there Sylvia falls pregnant, giving birth to a daughter, Frieda. Ted Hughes' reputation grows and she starts to resent both his fame and his popularity. After having another child, a son called Nicholas, they leave London and the city's literati for a cottage in Devon, having sold their flat to a young couple, David and Assia Wevill, whom they also invite down to stay for the weekend in the countryside. Even before they arrive Sylvia, increasingly consumed by jealousy and dark thoughts, has convinced herself that Ted and Assia are having an affair. After a fraught weekend with their visitors, Ted Hughes goes to London and begins an affair with Assia. On his return Sylvia confronts him, telling him that their relationship is over - she wants a divorce but does not tell him that she also feels suicidal. She rents a flat in London and moves there with Frieda and Nicholas and starts to write her poetry once more, some of which will eventually become the collection Ariel. She meets writer and poet Al Alvarez, who has always admired her work, but once he tries to make a crude pass at her she is both repelled and upset. Ted returns to London to see her and the two end up sleeping together. Sylvia takes this as a sign that he wants some sort of reconciliation, but is crushed when he tells her that Assia is pregnant and has left David, so he cannot leave to return to Sylvia. For Sylvia this is the final blow....

Production

Director
Christine Jeffs
Producer
Alison Owen and Neris Thomas
Art Director
Maria Djurkovic
Editor
Tariq Anwar
Screenplay
John Brownlow
Director of Photography
John Toon

Review

One has to think that the attention-seeking Sylvia Plath would have enjoyed her post-mortem fame, which has elevated her to a level she certainly never attained in life, she being claimed by feminists as a symbol of a woman's talent being extinguished by an unfeeling man, and some of the claims made against Ted Hughes in his treatment of her, totally refuted by the truth of what happened, virtually brand him a murderer instead of admitting that Sylvia Plath was self-absorbed before the pair ever met and the fact that Hughes became immediately more successful and more famous than herself was something with which she could not cope. Any film version of her life is bound to be a compromise, but director Christine Jeffs is further constrained by the refusal of Plath's daughter Frieda to allow her mother's poetry to be used in the film, so although the audience is constantly being told of how Plath is a genius there isn't actually any poetic evidence to back this up. Ironically Frieda Plath has written several poems about the making of the film and how she feels resentment towards it. Embodied by Gwyneth Paltrow, her Plath is perhaps more forgiving than the real thing, several sources telling of vicious arguments between herself and Hughes, he stoically absorbing all her blows, slaps and kicks. Daniel Craig's Hughes manages to impart some of the man's darkly attractive nature while being in no way physically similar, the real Hughes being a bear of a man in stature. A study of two people who should probably never have been involved with each other, never mind marry, Sylvia is dramatic and well acted but curiously lacking in sympathy at its core, and some may wonder just why Hughes stayed with the demanding Plath so long, following her from Britain to the US and back again, her all-consuming jealousy demanding they leave the Smith College post. And through having no access to the poetry, Sylvia Plath has been left a poet without a voice