Film details

The Singing Detective  2003

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

In a Los Angeles hospital, Dan Dark, a successful writer of crime pulp fiction, is stricken with psoriatic arthropathy, a disfiguring and painful skin disease, and under the large amounts of medication given to take away the pain and irritation he starts to relive the plot of The Singing Detective, his first novel, casting himself in the role of the tough, laconic hardboiled private eye, his fantasies encroaching on reality as the drugs work on his system. Seeing himself in a low-rent detective's office, he is hired by a mysterious man called Mark Binney and told to investigate the killing of a hooker called Nina. Dark starts to investigate the case, but as she does so his fictional and real lives become intertwined. In reality Mark Binney was his father's business partner, and who Dan as a child saw having sex with Dan's mother, Nina, an ongoing betrayal which eventually finally crushed Dan's weak and ineffectual father. His mother Nina starts to get confused in his drug-addled mind with his own wife, Nicola, who Dark also believes is having an affair. Being tended to by the pretty Nurse Mills, who has to apply grease all over his body to stop his lesions from becoming septic, Dark sees the hospital staff forming into a dance troupe and singing 50's hits by the likes of Danny And The Juniors and The Coasters. Nicola visits Dark, when his condition is at its worst, and gives him what should be good news, that a major film company wants to buy the rights for The Singing Detective, but Dark starts to rant at her incoherently, accusing her of plotting with her lover, Mark Binney once more, to cheat him on the deal and steal his work. As his condition continues Dark is given an appointment with the small and wizened psychiatrist Dr Gibbon, who deduces that his psoriasis is psychosomatic, caused by the guilt and trauma he felt during his childhood which has translated into his current feelings of rejection and self-loathing. Dark scoffs at the Doctor's diagnosis but as he starts to think about his past and the damage inflicted on him and starts to cope with it his skin starts to slowly heal and the pain decreases. As the hospital starts to wean him off his medication he sees two thugs from The Singing Detective, one tall and thin and the other small and squat, appear in the hospital ward, demanding to be told what part they play in the story and wanting Dark to continue with the narrative. Baffled by their demands he tries to ignore them but they start to assault him, while the hospital staff seem not to see them. They start to torture Dark and his mind reels with the pain but then, arriving as if a saviour, appears Dan Dark, the hardboiled 50's private eye.....

Production

Director
Keith Gordon
Producer
Mel Gibson and Bruce Davey
Art Director
Patricia Norris
Editor
Jeff Wishengrad
Music
(Supervisor) Ken Weiss
Screenplay
Dennis Potter, based on his own BBC TV series
Director of Photography
Tom Richmond

Review

Hoping to avoid a repeat of the shameful treatment given to his Pennies From Heaven by Hollywood, Dennis Potter wrote this film adaptation of The Singing Detective just two years before his death in an effort to tailor it to the American audience, and while viewers who never saw the mould-breaking TV series on which it is based will be intrigued, the changes, made for understandable reasons, nevertheless severely diminish the impact of the piece until it almost resembles one of the bland TV dramas Potter was so opposed to. The casting of a far younger actor in the form of Robert Downey Jr as opposed to the splenic Michael Gambon is explicable, but lessens the viciousness of the character. Similarly the shift in location and time of the detective story from London in the Blitz to 50's neo-noir L.A., most Americans having no knowledge of Wartime London and the danger it faced. But where the film is severely weakened is in the diminution of Dan Dark's abusive childhood and his relationship with his damaged father until it is barely a footnote rather than one of the major traumatic events in his life, making the diagnosis of Dr Gibbon, an almost unrecognisable Mel Gibson under a bald cap and wrinkled make-up, rather perfunctory. Downey is impressive and actor turned director Keith Gordon (Static / A Midnight Clear) does a fine job of handling the shift in atmosphere between the time-frames, but the compressing of six complex hours of TV into 109 minutes inevitably means that a lot of the impact of the original has been lost.