Film details

Down with Love  2003

Film still

Cast

  • David Hyde Pierce
  • Sarah Paulson
  • Tony Randall
  • Jeri Ryan
  • Ivana Milicevic
  • Melissa George
  • Dorie Barton
  • Florence Stanley
  • Jude Ciccoletta
  • John Christopher Storey

Synopsis

The permissive society of the 1960s is only three years old when Barbara Novak, having written the sensational book Down With Love which deals with female demands for equality in the work place and a right to satisfaction in the bedroom, arrives in New York City from her home in Maine as the publishers plan to hit the market with her book, planning a major publicity blitz. The all-male editorial board, headed by the elderly Theodore Banner are having second thoughts about publishing such an incendiary work but Barbara's editor, the fearless and emancipated Vicki Hiller, stands her ground, and a large print run is planned. Wanting to get an article on the book in the high-circulation men's magazine Know, Vicki arranges a meeting with the publisher, the weak-willed Peter McManus. Knowing Peter has a crush on her, but is too feeble to do anything about it, Vicki manages to arrange a major interview with Barbara, to be carried out by the magazine's hottest reporter, the playboy Catcher Block. The reporter has a reputation as a ladies' man, a roue and a serial seducer, and the reputation is fully deserved, repeated breakfast, lunch and dinner meetings being called off through phone calls from Block, always coming up with another excuse when in reality another of his air-hostess girlfriends has arrived in town for just a few hours. After several days of Block brush-offs Barbara decides he does not want to talk to Know, and especially not to Catcher Block. In a local dry cleaners Catcher is waiting for his clothes when Barbara enters for her cleaning. He hears her name and, since they have never met and using a NASA pass he has obtained on one of his adventures and donning a pair of horn-rimmed glasses, Block poses as Zip Martin, an astronaut, behaving like a perfectly chaste young man in order to get to know Barbara better. Block's plan, seeing that the book protests that women should not fall in love with men, is to be the perfect man, have Barbara fall in love with him and then write a devastating expose. Peter and Vicki start a tentative romance, more tentative on his part than hers, while Barbara and 'Zip' fall dizzily in love, hitting all the tourist sites and nightspots as Down With Love becomes both a nationwide and worldwide bestseller, women all over the world warming to its message. Even as millions of copies are being sold, Barbara decides to admit to 'Zip' that she has fallen for him, and that the message in her book is perhaps not the right one. 'Zip Martin' reveals himself to be Catcher Block, and both Block and Peter believe they have not only a scoop but the upper hand on Barbara and her theories, but she has a surprise or two for them also.....

Production

Director
Peyton Reed
Producer
Bruce Cohen and Dan Jinks
Art Director
Martin Whist
Editor
Larry Bock
Music
Marc Shaiman
Screenplay
Eve Ahlert and Dennis Drake
Director of Photography
Jeff Cronenweth

Review

A send-up of the contrived Doris Day / Rock Hudson romantic comedies of the Sixties, themselves given additional amusement value given what we now know about about both protagonists, the raw material of Down With Love wasn't exactly to be taken seriously when they were made, and the result is a garish, beautifully designed and obviously sincere labour of love which misses the target of its lampoon because the originals are still funnier then the parody. To be fair to director Peyton Reed (Bring It On) there's been one hell of a lot of devoted work put into Down With Love, in the costuming and set design alone, both of which conjure up a 60s neverland New York of clashing fabrics and architectural dream apartments, but Reed doesn't seem to know how to pitch the film - mild parody, knowing romantic comedy in a 60s wrapping, or out and out camp. The performances help it through the rough parts, and there are more then a few. Renée Zellweger is appealing in an underwritten role and Ewan McGregor is smarmy and believable as the proto-Hugh Hefner reporter, even if director Reed is very keen on showing him sans shirt, trousers or both. The excellent David Hyde Pierce (TV's Frazier) carries off the role of the shy and repressed Peter perfectly, but the handling of some of the set-pieces, such as the horribly predictable 'risque' scene involving a split-screen, is disastrous. Oddly for a film with such possibilities there is surprisingly little energy expended, and the final 'denouement' scenes seem to drag on for a reel or so. All the more galling then that the final fantastic song and dance number, performed by Zellweger and McGregor under the closing titles, should have all the energy and panache the film needed, and still some left over.