Film details

Benefit of the Doubt  1993

Film still

Cast

  • Rider Strong
  • Christopher McDonald
  • Graham Greene
  • Theodore Bikel
  • Gisele Kobach
  • Ferdy Mayne
  • Julie Hasel
  • Patricia Tallman
  • Ralph McTurk
  • Shane McCabe

Synopsis

Released from prison after twenty-two years behind bars, Frank Braswell walks free, having been accused of killing his wife and being convicted largely on the testimony of his young daughter, Karen. Now grown-up, and a single mother, working as a waitress in a strip club in the small Kansas town of Cottonwood to try to earn a living, Karen still believes he is guilty, despite Frank protesting his innocence at the time. Hearing he has been released, Karen dreads the idea of him returning to the town, threatening the life she has managed to make for herself with her son Pete and her boyfriend, Dan. Frank arrives in Cottonwood, keen to see Karen but also wanting to keep a low profile, insisting he was wrongly imprisoned but otherwise accepting his fate, which Karen finds unnerving, and it becomes obvious that he wants to work his way back into his daughter's affections, even though she wants nothing to do with him. When a body is found on the outskirts of town and Karen is forced to reveal a very dark and deep family secret, the truth about Frank Braswell seems about to be revealed, but the story of the night of the murder and what followed is far more twisted than anybody could have imagined.

Production

Director
Jonathan Heap
Producer
Dieter Geisler, Michael Spielberg and Brad M. Gilbert
Art Director
Marina Kieser
Editor
Sharyn L. Ross
Music
Hummie Mann
Screenplay
Jeffrey Polman and Christopher Keyser, based on a story by Michael Lieber
Director of Photography
Johnny Jensen

Review

What would have made a good hour-long TV drama, or perhaps a Night Gallery episode, Benefit Of The Doubt, despite a very solid cast, including the veteran Donald Sutherland, who has a truly great line in unsettling creepiness when he wants to and Amy Irving giving a very good performance as the young woman who fears the return of her murderous father after a 22-year jail sentence, is over-stretched even at just ninety minutes, and all pivots on revelations and twists which unfortunately become very apparent once Sutherland's Frank Braswell arrives back in town and the first murder is discovered. The script by Jeffrey Polman and Christopher Keyser adds a couple of red herrings and a couple of twists, but few viewers are going to be duped. A decent supporting cast including Christopher McDonald (The Perfect Storm), Graham Greene (The Last Of The Mohicans) and Theodore Bikel (Shattered), do the best they can with the script, and Irving's performance as the increasingly frightened and desperate Karen is laudable, showing how this very capable actress really hasn't been used to her full advantage by Hollywood, but this material is really a TV hour 'procedural' such as Criminal Minds or Law And Order, stretched out half as long again.