Film details

Dying Young  1991

Film still

Cast

  • Campbell Scott
  • Vincent D'Onofrio
  • Colleen Dewhurst
  • David Selby
  • Eilen Burstyn
  • Dion Anderson
  • George Martin
  • A.J. Johnson
  • Daniel Beer
  • Michael Halton
  • Larry Nash

Synopsis

Victor Geddes, the son of a vastly wealthy family, is twenty-eight, but was diagnosed with leukaemia for over a decade ago. Undergoing bouts of aggressive chemotherapy which leave him weak and violently ill, he places an ad, wanting to find a young woman who will be with him through the gruelling session and their side-effects. Applying for the post is Hilary O'Neil, a woman from a blue collar Oakland family, Victor realising she is poorly educated, with bad dress sense, and isn't at all who he expected, but he also sees something good and kind in her, and gives her the job. Hilary is initially unprepared for the bouts of vomiting which accompany the treatments, and linger with Victor for hours afterwards, but soon realises how debilitating the chemotherapy is, and how dependent Victor becomes on her. On his part Victor finds himself falling in love for the first time in his life, but also secretly knows that the treatment is only at best going to delay the inevitable, and has to make a decision - to tell Hilary that he has not much time left, or to turn her away, not letting her see his inescapable decline, knowing that both courses of action will break his heart.

Production

Director
Joel Schumacher
Producer
Sally Field and Kevin McCormick
Art Director
Guy J. Comtois
Editor
Robert Brown and Jim Prior
Music
James Newton Howard
Screenplay
Richard Friedenberg, based on the novel by Marti Leimbach
Director of Photography
Juan Ruiz Anchía

Review

Made by Julia Roberts' only a year after her career-establishing role in the smash-hit Pretty Woman, this was also very nearly her swansong, a box-office disaster which soon became known as Dying Fast, and frankly what studio executive thought a film about terminal cancer, with a title like Dying Young, would appeal to a mainstream audience, especially when released over the Christmas holiday! Directed by Joel Schumacher (Batman Forever), who had also directed Roberts in Flatliners, and scripted by Richard Fridenberg, based on the novel by Marti Leimbach, this is very much styled along the lines of Pretty Woman, which in itself was a retread of G.B. Shaw's Pygmalion, with the borderline sluttish Hilary (Roberts) arriving to initially be a companion to the seriously ill Victor (Campbell Scott - (The Sheltering Sky), a wealthy young man with leukaemia, and early scenes of her have the director's camera spending an unconscionably long time focusing on her legs, and her character is portrayed as being surprisingly tough and unsympathetic, until she starts to realise how vulnerable Victor is and the film starts to become interesting but never fulfilled the hints of a deeper relationship, Victor being clearly attracted to Hilary, who becomes rather kinder and softer, but there is a certain unpleasantness to using the man's illness as a plot device in a rather maudlin drama which ends almost exactly as the title promises. What is annoying is that there is a solid line-up of character actors largely wasted, including Vincent D'Onofrio (later to be a TV staple in Law & Order: Criminal Intent), Colleen Dewhurst (The Dead Zone) in one of her last screen appearances, David Selby (TV's Falcon Crest) and Ellen Burstyn (The Exorcist), but while Scott is touching and effective as the defiant but dying Victor, both Schumacher and Roberts seem content to make this just another uncomfortable spin on the film which made her famous, and with scant regard for good taste.