Film details

Dilemma  2011

Cheaters / What You Didn't Know
Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Ronny Valentine runs an auto design company with his longtime friend and business partner Nick Brannen, Nick being married to the younger and surprisingly alluring Geneva, given Nick's own unprepossessing appearance. Ronny is still single, although he has been in a relationship with his girlfriend Beth for a number of years, she helping him through his gambling addiction, and Geneva urges him to propose to her. Working on a project to pitch a new design to Chrysler, Ronny plans to pop the question to Beth, planning to ask her while visiting the Chicago botanical garden, but while he is there working out where to take Beth for the best effect, he is shocked to see Geneva there, kissing another man, Zip. Alarmed by what he has seen, he plans to tell Nick, but his nerve fails him at the last moment. Instead he confronts Geneva, who tells him that Nick hasn't slept with her in more than six months, and instead regularly visits massage parlours, but she assures Ronny she will end her affair. When Nick leaves the office, claiming an appointment, Ronny follows him to a local massage parlour and phones Geneva, but discovers that she is still with Zip, Geneva retaliating by threatening to tell Nick that she and Ronny slept together while at college, something of which her husband is unaware. Worried he is going to be blackmailed, Ronny follows Geneva and takes pictures of her with her lover, but Zip discovers him spying on them and a fight ensues. Taking Beth to her parent's anniversary dinner, he seems distracted and troubled, the speech he gives in celebration being so disjointed that Beth fears he may be gambling again. Realising he camera is still at Zip's house, Ronny goes there to get it, but is followed by an increasingly suspicious Nick. Ronny returns home to be confronted by Beth and a bunch of people, she having decided to organise an 'intervention' as to his return to gambling, Ronny being equally stunned to see Zip among the group, Ronny having brought him under the mistaken impression that he is a bookie Ronny is visiting, and in the confusion and heated arguments, the truth is bound to come out....

Production

Director
Ron Howard
Producer
Brian Grazer and Vince Vaughn
Art Director
Michael B. Clancy
Editor
Daniel P. Harvey
Screenplay
Allen Loeb
Director of Photography
Salvatore Totino

Review

The first comedy directed by Ron Howard in over a decade, and with some relatively bankable names in the cast, The Dilemma deals with subject material which some may not find tremendously funny, and as such can been seen as contributing to the film's surprising flop at the US box-office, audiences obviously finding it too uncomfortable, and the actions of some of the characters too manipulative, to spread word of mouth, the sort of good reception which was propelled other films by the leads, notably Vaughn's Wedding Crashers and James' Paul Blart: Mall Cop, to very good b.o. numbers after less than glowing reviews. The dilemma of the title is a classic one, when a man discovers that his best friend, who he has known for decades and is now his business partner, is being cheated on by his wife. Does he tell him, or try to discover more in order to confirm just what is going on, only to find that his own suspicious behaviour in trying to keep someone else's secret is making his own partner believe he is carry on, or at least has reverted to his old ways, having conquered a gambling problem. Vaughn and James are well cast as friends and partners Ronny and Nick, but such audience-friendly casting doesn't quite work when one is supposed to believe that James, who we are sure is a prince among man and a candidate for sainthood, is actually married to Geneva, played by the still reasonably gamine Winona Ryder (Edward Scissorhands), and that she can actually be so manipulative when she realises her affair with the unfortunately but possibly aptly named Zip (Channing Tatum - The Eagle) is discovered by Ronny, whose viewpoint the entire film is told from, and which pretty quickly stops being particularly funny as the knots in which Ronny ties himself in order to try to keep the truth from his friend, and not incidentally jeopardise the potentially lucrative Chrysler contract they are angling for, become more and more tangled. Despite a 111 minute running time one still suspects that there's quite a lot of salient footage on the editing room floor, or the recycle bin of an Avid suite, giving the way some characters, such as Ronny's girlfriend Beth (Jennifer Connelly - A Beautiful Mind), and Tatum's Zip (as it were) seem to have various subplots curtailed, and the central idea, that we really know very little about our friends, no matter how long we have known them, never really gels when the script keeps shifting focus from comedy to surprisingly serious emotional scenes. Given how manipulative Howard's films usually are one is taken aback that the neat tie-up and happy crowd-pleasing ending never actually arrives, and this isn't the unchallenging, slickly-made multiplex filler which the cast and concept may initially suggest, which is perhaps why American audiences found it a dilemma they were unwilling to face.