Film details
Talk to Her 2002
Hable Con Ella
Still unavailable
Cast
-
Leonor Watling
-
Darío Grandinetti
-
Rosario Flores
-
-
Javier Cámara
-
Paz Vega
Synopsis
At a theatre in Madrid a performance of the dance piece Cafe Muller is taking place. Audience member Benigno notices another member of the audience, Marco Zuloaga, crying helplessly. Both men have tragedy in their lives. For years Benigno, a trained hairdresser and beautician, had to abandon his career and take care of his ailing mother, rarely leaving the house and instead being at his mother's side at all times. His enforced incarceration meant Benigno could observe the rehearsals at the dance studio across the road and slowly, from afar, he fell in love with Alicia, a young dancer. After his mother died he finally met Alicia, but his happiness was short-lived as Alicia was hit by a car and plunged into a coma. Now at the El Bosque Clinic, Benigno nurses her tenderly. Marco's story is also a similar one of loss. A travel writer in his forties, he was commissioned to interview Lydia Gonzalez, a famous and brave female bullfighter. During the course of their interview Marco discovered that she was mourning the loss of her boyfriend who had recently left her. Totally besotted with her, Marco and Lydia started a relationship and one day Lydia confesses she has something to tell him, but goes into the bullring and is badly gored, also falling into a coma. Marco has never discovered what she intended to say to him. Both men meet at the clinic when they are there to tend to Alicia and Lydia. Benigno feels threatened by Marco's interest in himself and Alicia and pretends to be gay. The two men, linked by their mutual loss, become friends, Benigno urging Marco to talk to Lydia, even though it is doubtful whether he can hear her. In Lydia's apartment he finally discovers what she was planning to tell him but what she found so difficult to say - that she was going to leave him and return to her ex-lover. Benigno watches a bizarre silent film, The Shrinking Lover, and the film's imagery gives him the reasoning for what he intends to do. On the next visit to the clinic Benigno has sex with the comatose Alicia and is discovered and arrested. Marco hears of what has happened, and of the terrible consequences when Alicia is discovered to be pregnant. With Marco now having to take care of Alicia as well as Lydia, who he now knows was planning to leave him, he has to make a painful and heart-rending decision.....
Production
- Director
- Pedro Almodóvar
- Producer
- Agustín Almodóvar
- Art Director
- Antxón Gómez
- Editor
- José Salcedo
- Music
- Alberto Iglesias
- Screenplay
- Pedro Almodóvar
- Director of Photography
- Javier Aguirresarobe
Review
A hit in its native Spain, Pedro Almodóvar's Talk to Her is a deviation from his camp comedies (i.e. Law of Desire) and acclaimed melodrama (All About My Mother), instead being very much an art movie where the two men at the centre of the story - Marco and Benigno - are brought together by one thing, their grief. The fact that the women they love are both in comas only emphasises the gap in communication between men and women, and the fact that Marco and Lydia's relationship was left with something unspoken only underlines this fact. Some viewers may think that some of Almodovar's visual contrivances, the opening and closing modern dance sequences and the seven-minute silent film which Benigno watches, are contrived, and others may complain at the bullfight sequences and Benigno's eventual rape of the comatose Alicia, but rather than sticking to his successful formula Almodovar is willing to try and move in a different direction, something such acclaimed European directors in his position are often unwilling to do.