Film details

The Two Jakes  1990

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Los Angeles, 1948, and private detective JJ 'Jake' Gittes runs a very successful P.I. agency. Now almost a respectable and influential businessman, his main stock-in-trade is still snooping on unfaithful spouses, one of his most high-profile clients being real estate agent Jake Berman, the co-owner of the hugely successful B&B Homes business, Gittes carrying out observation on Berman's possibly wayward wife, Kitty. Gittes gets the evidence Berman wants, that she is having an affair with another man, and gets the details of their next liaison at the Bird of Paradise Hotel in Rodondo Beach so that she can be caught in the act and Berman can go ahead with divorce proceedings as the aggrieved partner. Once Kitty and her lover arrive for their tryst, Berman confronts them, finding that her lover is Mark Bodine, his business partner, and a furious Berman shoots him dead. Gittes is stunned at the identity of the adulterer, but also finds that Berman now inherits Bodine's half of the company under their partnership agreement, which surprisingly excluded Bodine's own wife, the volatile Lillian, and makes Berman the sole beneficiary. Re-examining the tape recording he made of the two in bed together, evidence for Berman, Gittes' is stunned when he hears a certain name being mentioned in the lover's conversation, Katherine Mulwray, the provocative teenage daughter of Evelyn Mulwray, Jake's murdered former client and lover, Katherine being the incestuous offspring of Evelyn and her perverted, sadistic father, Noah Cross, a man Gittes dealt with eleven years earlier in a case in Chinatown which broke both his heart and his spirit. Gittes starts to believe that he has been set up in the case of Bodine's killing, suspecting that Berman set it up with his wife in order to take his partner's shareholding, and that he will be cleared of murder in court, claiming self-defence. Finding that one of major B&B developments is in an orange grove which once belonged to Noah Cross, Gittes investigates further, wondering what part if any Katherine Mulwray has in all this, only to be drawn into a dark and complex plot, where it seems nobody can be trusted, and the past has echoes which resonate in the present day.

Production

Director
Jack Nicholson
Producer
Robert Evans and Harold Schneider
Art Director
Richard Schreiber
Editor
Anne Goursand
Music
Van Dyke Parks
Screenplay
Robert Towne, based on characters created by Robert Towne
Director of Photography
Vilmos Zsigmond

Review

Although The Two Jakes seems misjudged, a belated sequel coming eleven years after its' inspiration, the film is hampered by having to be a sequel to one of the very best films of the 70s, and one of the best detective films ever made also, a mountainous liability to begin with, and although this stylish but often almost fatally muddle film is certainly easy to watch, if not follow. The sad fact is that it simply cannot match up to Chinatown, and it seems surprising that anybody ever thought it would. The version of The Two Jakes which finally hits the screens is rather different from what was initially planned, producer Robert Evans, an actor while in his twenties, initially being announced in the role of real stage magnate Jake Berman, with the film to be directed by screenwriter Robert Towne, but Evans was soon ditched from the role of Berman to be replaced by Harvey Keitel, and Jack Nicholson stepped into the director's chair, an ambitious choice since the very fine actor had only helmed two films previously, the 70's obscurity Drive, He Said and the misjudged comedy Western Goin' South. Jakes is certainly trying to be ambitious and not just another JJ Gittes film, and by the time the film opens he is actually quite respectable, even though his business is still largely grubby, but Towne's script brings in so many very direct references to Chinatown, some obvious and some others not so, that those who have not seen the first film are going to be baffled, but some of the ideas, that the past is inescapable, are often effective, Nicholson giving a performance which becomes increasingly melancholic as the connections to the events of eleven years earlier start to reveal themselves, Gittes realising that despite his new-found wealth and style, the deeds of years before are always there. A coupe of scenes are remarkably effective, such as Gittes dealing with the aggressive Detective Loach (David Keith - Firestarter), and his first meeting with Lillian Bodine (Madeline Stowe - Blink), very far from being a grieving widow, and the photography by Vilmos Zsigmond (The Deer Hunter / Heaven's Gate) captures the immediate post-War period perfectly. A considerable box-office flop, The Two Jakes is attempting the insurmountable task of trying to compare to a film as fine as Roman Polanski's Chinatown, the last film the director made in America, and while the pic has problems, including a truly knotty plot which at times seems to be bringing in elements just so that they can connect to the original film, it remains a more than honourable failure, impressive visually and richly cast, and certainly isn't deserving of the reputation it has among some critics, being far more of a considered and ambitious film than the vanity project it initially seemed like. The third part of the intended trilogy, believed to have been entitled Cloverleaf, now seems very unlikely ever to be made.