Film details

A Soldier's Daughter Never Cries  1998

Still unavailable

Cast

Synopsis

Eight-year-old Charlotte Anne ("Channe") lives in Paris with her American father Bill, a writer, and her fun-loving mother, Marcella. As Marcella cannot have any more children, she and Bill decide to adopt Benoît, a six-year-old whose years in foster homes have left him emotionally withdrawn. However, with the passage of time, Benoît comes out of his shell, even taking the name Billy after his father. Despite this, both he and Channe feel they are outsiders and constantly get into scrapes at school. As she grows up, Channe begins to take an interest in boys and in particular the campy oddball Francis, who lives with his English mother. Francis widens Channe's interests, taking her to the opera and the like, but refrains from taking the relationship beyond friendship as he is unsure of his own sexuality. However this abruptly ends when Channe and her family leave France for the United States, where Billy wants to return when his health takes a turn for the worse. In New England, Channe and Billy are still unhappy. Channe has a number of spiritless flings with boys, until she finally meets one who promises more than just sex.

Production

Director
James Ivory
Producer
Ismail Merchant
Art Director
Per-Olof Renard and Linwood Taylor
Editor
Noëlle Boisson
Music
Richard Robbins
Screenplay
James Ivory and Ruth Prawer Jhabvala, based on a novel by Kaylie Jones
Director of Photography
Jean-Marc Fabre

Review

An allegory of what it means to feel like an expatriate, to be part of a society or family but not actually to "belong" to it, Merchant-Ivory's coming-of-age tale is a beautifully photographed adaptation of Kaylie Jones' autobiographical novel, but sorely lacks narrative thrust or any kind of focus - as it drifts from set-piece to set-piece - each well and good in themselves but adding up to something less than the sum of their parts.