Film details

Adaptation.  2002

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

While the film of his script Being John Malkovich is being shot in 1999, screenplay writer Charlie Kaufman is approached to adapt Susan Orlean's bestselling book The Orchid Thief into a film. The self-loathing Charlie agrees after reading the book, which concerns John Laroche, a Florida naturalist who is obsessed by orchids, and is planning on stealing a precious 'ghost orchid'. But once he tries to adapt the book Charlie hits trouble, being unable to crack the structure, and his wrestling with the text mirrors Susan Orleans' own writing of the book and her dealings and relationship with John Laroche himself. As Charlie struggles, his twin brother Donald, having visited a screenplay writing workshop by famed teacher Robert McKee, is working on his own script, a high concept serial killer story. Charlie is horrified at his brother seemingly making progress on such an overly commercial project, and even more distressed when Donald tells him of the script's main selling point - that the script's killer, Detective, and imprisoned next victim, are the same person, different facets of one mind. Despite being overweight and balding, Charlie catches the eye of Amelia, a young and pretty English violinist and they go out on two dates, but Charlie's self-obsession and struggles with his work eventually make her lose interest. Realising if he meets Susan Orlean herself he may be able to get a better grip on the book, Charlie travels out to New York to meet her, only to let panic overwhelm him and he ducks out of their meeting. Finding Donald has sold his serial killer script, Charlie goes to one of Robert McKee's writing classes, and after his lecture McKee tells him that the way Charlie can get out of his script difficulties is to give the audience a great ending. Charlie is forced to ask Donald for help and Donald, posing as Charlie, goes to meet Susan Orlean. As they talk Donald suspects that she is hiding something important, or has some sort of guarded secret. When Susan travels to Florida the brothers follow her and find that she is still seeing John Laroche and the two are creating designer hallucinogenic drugs from the ghost orchids they are secretly cultivating. Both Donald and Charlie realise that they are in deep trouble, especially after Susan Orlean and John Laroche realise that their secret has been discovered, and chase them, Laroche being armed and in no mood to have their 'business' revealed. Charlie may just have found his great ending, if he lives long enough to write it...

Production

Director
Spike Jonze
Producer
Edward Saxon, Vincent Landay and Jonathan Demme
Art Director
Peter Andrus
Editor
Eric Zumbrunnen
Music
Carter Burwell
Screenplay
Charlie Kaufman and Donald Kaufman, based on the novel The Orchid Thief by Susan Orlean
Director of Photography
Lance Acord

Review

Having already played with audience perceptions of fiction and reality with the remarkable Being John Malkovich, Adaptation. tampers even more with the boundaries of the screenwriter and truth. Charlie Kaufman was indeed employed to write the screen version of The Orchid Thief, and did have trouble with it, but even though he has a co-screenplay credit Donald Kaufman does not exist, being just a creation of the real Charlie Kaufman. Spike Jonez directs with a sure and convincing hand, even when we are asked to believe that the author Susan Orlean is actually involved in distilling designer drugs from orchids, and the film flies away in such digressions as after Charlie reads a quote by Charles Darwin from the book the film segues seemlessly into a scene of Darwin writing the passage in question, and the entire history of the world is shown in a visual medley at one point. Kaufman is having fun with shifting both the audiences and his own characters' expectations, and all the while wanting to avoid the standard 'Hollywood ending' for the book, but is forced to live it himself within the framework of the film. Kaufman's fiendishly clever and unexpected screenplay is also given an added dimension by a brilliant, almost unrecognisable Nicolas Cage under prosthetics and hideous hair as both Kaufmans and the whole film is a remarkable testament to the creative teaming of Kaufman and Jonez.