Film details
The Man Who Wasn't There 2001
Still unavailable
Cast
-
-
-
-
-
Scarlett Johannsson
-
Michael Badalucco
Synopsis
Ed Crane is a barber, working at his brother-in-law Frank's shop in the Californian town of Santa Rosa in 1949. He has been married to Doris, Frank's borderline alcoholic sister, for several years and their marriage has frozen to an emotionless routine. Doris works as the bookkeeper at Nirdlinger's department store and 'Big Dave' Nirdlinger, a bluff and hearty fellow, is her boss. Ed starts to suspect something is going on between them after seeing them get close at a party for employees as well as having Dave and his withdrawn wife over for dinner one evening. After cutting the hair of Crighton Tolliver, a touring franchise salesman trying to interest a local businessman in investing in the new science of dry cleaning and into opening a string of stores, Ed is piqued with interest. Realising that Tolliver would require $10,000 to take Ed on as a business partner, he arrives at a plan to blackmail Big Dave for the money. He leaves a note referring cryptically to what he knows is going on between Nirdlinger and a married woman in the town, threatening to expose it. Surprisingly Big Dave asks his advice, telling him that he is involved with a woman who Ed does not know and that any money Dave has is earmarked to open an annex to the store, which Doris would run. Ed just recommends he should do what the blackmailer wants to avoid complications. Dave complies with the blackmailer's demands and makes the drop at a local hotel, $10,000 dollars in cash. He gives the cash to Tolliver and signs legal contracts. After a family picnic which ends with Doris drunk and unconscious, Ed receives a call from Dave asking him to meet him in the store late at night. Once there Dave tells him that he tracked down Tolliver, who he believed was blackmailing him, Dave being the local businessman he had first approached in the town. He has beaten the truth out of Tolliver and found the contacts signed by Ed. A fight ensues and Ed only overcomes the much bigger man after stabbing him in the throat with a paper knife, causing Dave to die a slow, bloody death. Ed returns home to the still-unconscious Doris. The next day Ed is in the barber's shop when two detectives come to him with the bad news. Dave Nirdlinger has been murdered, and Doris has been arrested for the crime. Ed goes to see Walter Abundas, the local lawyer, who recommends city lawyer Freddy Riedenschneider. Ed also meets Walter's daughter, Birdy, who is a piano protegee. Frank mortgages the shop, which he owns, to pay Riedenschneider's fees, the man being brilliant, but also expensive and with extravagant tastes, staying at the most exclusive hotel in Santa Rosa. He constructs an alibi for Doris, even after Ed has confessed, believing Ed is just trying to save his wife. Finding out that Dave's war record, which he proudly boasted about, is a fabrication, he plans to use that as one of the mainsprings of his defence. As the case comes to trial, a tragedy occurs which will affect Ed and everybody he knows, even as he tries for forgiveness and redemption..
Production
- Director
- Joel Coen
- Producer
- Ethan Coen
- Art Director
- Chris Gorak
- Editor
- Roderick Jaynes (Joel and Ethan Coen) and Tricia Cooke
- Music
- Carter Burwell
- Screenplay
- Ethan Coen and Joel Coen
- Director of Photography
- Roger Deakins
Review
The Coen Brothers are still on form after the whimsical O Brother Where Art Thou?, firing back with a stinging film noir which has elements of black comedy but also boasts down the line excellent performances and a truly clever circular plot, which confirms that no good deed will go unpunished. Billy Bob Thornton, almost unrecognisable under a wig and false eyebrows, is perfectly cast as the quiet, unremarkable Ed, the 'man who wasn't there' of the title, so bland that even a brief alien abduction subplot is added just to be paid off with a bleak punchline. Shot in black and white by British cinematographer Roger Deakins, the movie oozes atmosphere, from the clever, understated titles through terrific production design and use of light and shadow. With a couple of brilliant plot twists, none of which the audience will see coming, The Man Who Wasn't There is on a level with the Coen's very best work.