Film details

Shallow Hal  2001

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

As nine year old Hal Larson stands by his father's bed, the Reverend Larson, in delirium through sedatives, gives him some advice before he dies, to value beauty in women above all else. Then he expires, Hal taking his last words to heart. Hal grows up to be a perfectionist in the field of women, he and his equally obsessed friend Mauricio going out with women the equivalent of supermodels but rejecting them all because of uneven toenails or a less than perfect ear, though the pair of them are not exactly Greek Gods themselves. Hal seems doomed to live his life alone, and is constantly accused of being shallow, until he is trapped in a lift in an office building with Tony Robbins, a self-help guru whose books have sold millions of copies. Robbins' seductive, penetrating words give Hal the power of seeing the inner beauty in a person, and not just the outwardly physical appearance. This power changes Hal dramatically, and he starts to see all women, including the most horrific crones, as beautiful, enchanting creatures. He meets and falls deeply in love with the slender, beautiful blonde Rosemary Shanahan, who works with sick children, and believes her to be the most wonderful women he has every met. The truth of the matter is that she is not only the daughter of his fearsome boss Steve Shanahan, but is also a hulking behemoth weighting nearly three hundred pounds. Taken to her parent's house by Rosemary, Hal makes a good impression on his boss by defending Rosemary when the family make snide comments about her size, Hal of course seeing her as slim and svelte. Hal is promoted, but his elevation causes problems with his colleagues, who make hurtful comments about what he is willing to do to get promotion from the boss. Hal also refuses to believe his friend Mauricio, putting his friend's warnings down to jealousy, and also refuses to listen to his friend Walt, a spina bifida sufferer and successful businessman who has a beautiful nurse as a girlfriend, but Hal's power makes him realise what she is really after, seeing her as ugly and mean. Finally tricked into reversing the Robbins treatment, Hal is stunned when he sees how Rosemary really is and refuses to answer either the phone or the door of his apartment, secretly hating having taken Mauricio's advice and having had his illusions shattered. He finally accepts a dinner invitation from Jill, an old girlfriend, and while they are having dinner, Rosemary sees them entering the restaurant and realises that it is all over between them. But while they are dining, Hal realises that he loved Rosemary for her genuine inner beauty, and decides to surprise her at her upcoming birthday, not knowing that she has a similar unexpected statement to make....

Production

Director
Peter and Bobby Farrell
Screenplay
Peter Farrell, Bobby Farrell and Sean Moynihan

Review

The Farrelly brothers have often been criticised for the 'gross-out' content of their movies, and the actual physical appearance of Gwyneth Paltrow as Rosemary in her 'real' form, not seen through Jack Black's rose-tinted eyeballs, is a shocker, but the brothers also make what are very genuine love stories - both Me, Myself and Irene and the essentially tender There's Something About Mary. The fact is that their handling of certain subjects (such as disability) or physical impairment is handled not with kid gloves but in a firm and completely conventional manner, and how many other directors or writers regularly write roles for disabled actors. The pair also go for some great visual gags, such as a well-devised scene of Hal and Rosemary canoeing, but they also use the usually abrasive Jack Black (High Fidelity / Saving Silverman) in a role which seems completely wrong - the love-struck young man seeing everything as beautiful - and he plays it extremely well. Certainly there's enough 'Farrelly' moments to be in questionable taste, but Shallow Hal is a good deal better-natured than most of Hollywood's recent output.