Film details

Me Without You  2001

Film still

Cast

  • Michelle Williams
  • Oliver Milburn
  • Kyle MacLachlan
  • Trudy Styler
  • Marianne Denicourt

Synopsis

Marina and Holly are best friends, growing up in London in the late 70s. Both trust each other implicitly even though they are very different in nature and background. Holly comes from a stable Jewish family while Marina lives with her brother Nat, looked after by their skittish, unfit mother. At a teenage party both girls lose their virginity, Marina after she has tried heroin for the first time and is generally anethesisted to the experience, while Holly finds warmth and comfort in the arms of Nat. She doesn't know that he already has a girlfriend and he leaves the next morning without waking her, but leaving a message about how much the night meant to him. Marina finds the message and fails to pass it onto Holly. On leaving school both girls go to Sussex University where Holly becomes involved with Daniel, one of her lecturers and who she sees as handsome and sophisticated. But Daniel is also attracted to Marina's up-front nature and soon he is having a relationship with both of them, although neither knows about the other. Marina discovers that Daniel is also seeing Holly but does nothing about it for the moment. Nat visits Marina at the university, telling her he has just ended his relationship with his latest girlfriend. He meets Holly once more and she realises that she still has feelings for Nat. She plans to end her affair with Daniel and goes round to his flat to tell him, but once there she sees Marina leaving and is upset, so much so she turns against Nat, who cannot understand what he has done. The two girls remain friends but subtly distance themselves, Marina throwing an annual new year's party where Holly still sees Nat, and Marina still manages to lure most of Holly's boyfriends away from her. After taking another of her boyfriend's Marina finds she is pregnant and doesn't know what to do. She goes to see Holly to ask for advice, but Holly takes this as her cue to tell her friend how badly she has treated her over the years, and that she has decided she wants Nat. The two friends look at each other, one with her future planned, the other facing uncertainty and doubt....

Production

Director
Sandra Goldbacher
Screenplay
Sandra Goldbacher

Review

With two terrific central performances from Michelle Williams and Anna Friel as the chalk-and-cheese friends, bound together by so much but really very different and independent people, Me Without You is very well observed by director Sandra Goldbacher (The Governess). She has conveyed the gestures, remarks and interplay between two close friends and also realising the extent to which such friendships will go, Holly having incredible patience as Marina makes a play for all her boyfriends and, at one point, even her father. Kyle MacLachlan is also well cast as the suave college lecturer, seeming unperturbed about having simultaneous affairs with two of his students and the whole tone of the drama rings true. Well directed, sympathetically played, and a movie that will have a lot of the audience nodding in identification.